Okay, so I’ve been testing the COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Ultimate Finish Foundation in Ivory for weeks now, and I’ve GOT to share my thoughts! Plus, I’ve analyzed feedback from dozens of actual users to give you the most comprehensive review possible. Let’s dive in!
First Impressions
When I first got this compact, I was honestly skeptical. At this price point (WAY cheaper than department store brands), could it really deliver? The packaging is simple but functional – a basic black compact with a decent-sized mirror and included sponge applicator. Nothing fancy, but totally gets the job done.
What’s interesting about this foundation is it’s a 3-in-1 formula that claims to work like liquid, stick, AND pancake makeup all at once. Ambitious, right? Let’s see if it lives up to the hype!
Application & Texture
This is where things get INTERESTING! The texture is creamy but sets to a powder finish. It’s not quite a cream-to-powder and not quite a traditional compact foundation either. It has this unique consistency that glides on smoothly (especially if your skin is properly prepped).
The included sponge works surprisingly well, though some users mentioned it expands after several uses and can be tricky to fit back in the compact. I found application super easy and quick – perfect for busy mornings or touch-ups on the go.
One thing I noticed right away: this is NOT a lightweight, barely-there foundation. It provides medium to full coverage depending on how you apply it. You can build it up in areas where you need more coverage without it looking cakey.
Coverage & Finish
Let me be clear: if you’re looking for something sheer and natural, this might not be your best bet. This foundation is ALL about coverage! It covers:
- Acne and acne scars
- Dark circles
- Redness and discoloration
- Uneven skin tone
The finish is semi-matte – not completely flat but definitely not dewy either. Several reviewers with mature skin mentioned how well it works for them, which surprised me since full-coverage foundations often settle into fine lines. The slightly creamy formula seems to help it lay nicely on drier, more mature skin.
Shade Range & Color Match
Here’s where we need to talk! The Ivory shade is supposed to be one of the lightest options, but MULTIPLE reviewers mentioned it runs darker than expected. Several noted it has slight orange/pink undertones that might not work for everyone with fair skin, especially those with cool undertones.
If you’re extremely fair, you might find even this lightest shade too dark. This is definitely something to consider if you typically wear the lightest shade in other foundation ranges.
Staying Power
Now THIS is where the product shines! True to its “Outlast” name, this foundation genuinely stays put throughout the day. Several reviewers mentioned it:
- Doesn’t transfer to masks
- Holds up well in hot, humid weather
- Lasts through a full workday
- Doesn’t require tons of touch-ups
For oily skin types, you might still need a powder touch-up in your T-zone, but overall, the longevity is impressive for the price point.
Skin Types & Compatibility
Based on user feedback, this foundation seems to work best for:
- Normal to dry skin types
- Mature skin (surprising but true!)
- Those needing serious coverage
- People who prefer a semi-matte finish
For very oily skin, reviews were mixed. Some found it too greasy, while others said it worked well with proper setting powder. If you have extremely dry, flaky skin, you’ll definitely want to prep with a good moisturizer first.
Potential Concerns
In the interest of total honesty, here are some consistent issues mentioned in reviews:
- Compact Size – At just 0.4 ounces, several users mentioned they go through it quickly with regular use.
- Packaging Issues – A few reviewers had problems with the compact breaking apart easily.
- Limited Shade Range – Particularly for very fair skin tones.
- Pore Visibility – One reviewer specifically mentioned it settled into pores, making them more noticeable.
The MAJOR Pros
- Affordable Price – You get serious coverage for a drugstore price!
- Great for Mature Skin – Many reviewers in their 50s and beyond LOVED how it worked with their skin.
- Versatility – Works as both foundation and concealer, and can be applied lightly or built up.
- Longevity – Genuinely lasts throughout the day.
- Cruelty-Free – COVERGIRL is now 100% bunny safe and cruelty-free!
Who Should Buy This?
This foundation is PERFECT for you if:
- You want serious coverage without the luxury price tag
- You have normal to dry skin
- You’re looking for a foundation that can double as a concealer
- You need something that lasts all day
- You’re on a budget but don’t want to compromise on quality
- You value cruelty-free beauty products
You might want to skip this if:
- You prefer sheer, natural-looking coverage
- You have extremely oily skin
- You have very fair skin with cool undertones
- You’re looking for a dewy finish
Application Tips from Real Users
- Skin Prep Is Key – Many reviewers emphasized the importance of moisturizing well before application.
- Less Is More – Start with a light application and build up only where needed.
- Setting Powder Option – While it has a powder finish, many users found adding a light setting powder helped longevity, especially in hot weather.
- Color Matching – Consider going one shade lighter than you think you need based on feedback about the darkness of the shades.
- Application Method – The included sponge works well, but some users preferred using their fingers for a more natural finish.
My Personal Experience
After testing this foundation for several weeks, I’ve found it’s become my go-to for days when I need reliable, long-lasting coverage. I love that I can apply it quickly in the morning and not worry about it for the rest of the day.
The Ivory shade works for my light-medium skin tone during winter months, but I’d definitely need to go darker for summer. The texture is interesting – it feels almost slightly oily going on, but sets nicely without looking greasy.
For me, the best application method is using the sponge to pat it into areas where I need coverage, then blending the edges with my fingertips. This gives me the coverage I need without looking mask-like.
One thing I particularly appreciate is how well it covers redness around my nose and dark circles under my eyes WITHOUT having to use a separate concealer. One product, multiple uses = WIN in my book!
Value for Money
Let’s talk bang for your buck. At under $10 (typically), this foundation is a STEAL compared to similar coverage options from higher-end brands. Yes, the compact is small at 0.4 ounces, but a little goes a long way.
When you consider that this one product can replace your foundation, concealer, and powder, the value becomes even more apparent. Many reviewers mentioned they’ve been loyal to this product for YEARS (some for decades!) because of its reliability and value.
Final Verdict
Overall Rating: 4.2/5
The COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Ultimate Finish Foundation in Ivory is a solid drugstore option that punches well above its weight class. It delivers serious coverage, genuine longevity, and a skin-friendly formula at an extremely accessible price point.
While it has some limitations (primarily in shade range and compact size), the overall performance makes it easy to recommend, especially for those on a budget who don’t want to compromise on coverage or staying power.
If you’ve been searching for an affordable foundation that actually WORKS and stays put all day, this little compact deserves a spot in your makeup bag. Just be aware of the potential shade matching issues if you’re extremely fair or have strong undertones.
The fact that so many users mentioned coming back to this foundation after trying more expensive options speaks volumes about its quality and performance. Sometimes the best products are the classics that have stood the test of time!
Would I Repurchase?
ABSOLUTELY! This foundation has earned a permanent place in my makeup routine. For days when I need reliable, long-lasting coverage, this is my new go-to. The price point makes it a no-brainer to keep on hand, even if I rotate between other foundations.
Have you tried this COVERGIRL foundation? I’d love to hear your experience with it, especially if you’ve found tricks for making it work even better!
Buy on Amazon: Here
