Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m SUPER excited to spill ALL the tea about a lip gloss that’s been my ride-or-die for months now – the COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss in “My Main Squeeze”. If you’re tired of dropping $25+ on fancy lip glosses that don’t deliver, you NEED to keep reading!
FIRST IMPRESSIONS
When I first got my hands on this gloss, I was honestly skeptical. I mean, a $10 drugstore lip gloss competing with my Sephora favorites? Yeah right! But let me tell you – I was WRONG.
The packaging is simple but cute – nothing fancy, just functional. The applicator is your standard doe-foot that picks up the perfect amount of product. But the REAL magic happens when you open it – that SMELL! The coconut scent is absolutely delicious without being overwhelming. It instantly gives me summer vibes even in the dead of winter.
APPLICATION & TEXTURE
Okay, let’s talk about the texture because this is where most lip glosses either win me over or get tossed in my drawer forever. This gloss is:
- NOT super sticky (hallelujah!)
- Smooth and creamy going on
- Lightweight on the lips
- Easy to apply without a mirror
The consistency hits that perfect middle ground – not too thin that it disappears in 5 minutes, but not so thick that your hair sticks to your lips every time there’s a slight breeze. It glides on effortlessly and feels comfortable right away.
Some reviewers mentioned it has a slight tingle when applied. I personally don’t find this to be a plumping sensation (it’s not marketed as a plumper), but more of a slight freshness. If you have super sensitive lips, this might be something to note!
COLOR & FINISH
“My Main Squeeze” is definitely on the sheer side – it gives a beautiful hint of color rather than an opaque coverage. The color is a flattering peachy-pink that honestly seems to work on EVERYONE. It’s one of those “your lips but better” shades that you can throw on with any makeup look.
The finish is glossy without looking like you applied pure petroleum jelly to your lips. It catches the light beautifully and makes your lips look plumper and more hydrated instantly.
If you’re looking for intense color payoff, this probably isn’t your jam. Several reviewers mentioned being disappointed with the color intensity, especially in the darker shades. This is definitely more about the glossy finish with a HINT of tint rather than a pigmented lip product.
STAYING POWER
Let’s be real – no lip gloss lasts forever, and anyone who claims theirs does is straight-up LYING. That said, this one has surprisingly decent staying power for a gloss!
I can get about 2-3 hours of wear before needing to reapply, which is actually impressive for a $10 gloss. It fades evenly without leaving that weird white line around your lips (we’ve ALL dealt with that nightmare before!).
If you eat or drink, you’ll definitely need to reapply, but that’s standard for any gloss. The good news is that even as it wears off, your lips still feel moisturized.
HYDRATION FACTOR
This is where the COVERGIRL Yummy Gloss really shines! Many reviewers specifically mentioned how hydrating this formula is, with some even using it as a lip balm replacement.
The formula contains hydrating ingredients that actually improve lip condition over time. After using this consistently for a few weeks, I noticed my lips were less prone to dryness and flaking – even in harsh winter conditions.
If you struggle with dry, chapped lips like I do, this gloss is a game-changer. It feels nourishing immediately upon application and continues working throughout the day.
SCENT & FLAVOR
The coconut scent is DIVINE – not artificial or chemical-smelling like some drugstore products can be. It’s subtle enough that it’s not overpowering but noticeable enough to be enjoyable.
Several reviewers specifically called out the delicious taste/smell as a major selling point. If you’re sensitive to scented products, you might want to give this a sniff at the store first, but most people seem to love it!
VEGAN & CRUELTY-FREE STATUS
A HUGE plus for this product is that it’s both vegan and cruelty-free! One reviewer specifically mentioned this was an important decision factor for them, noting that “it’s a must that it be cruelty-free and vegan! That makes all the difference.”
In a beauty industry that’s becoming increasingly conscious about ingredients and testing practices, it’s refreshing to find affordable options that don’t compromise on ethics.
VALUE FOR MONEY
At around $10, this gloss is an INCREDIBLE value. Many reviewers specifically mentioned switching from high-end glosses costing $23-25 to this more affordable option without sacrificing quality.
One particularly enthusiastic reviewer noted: “Can’t believe all the money I’ve been throwing away on expensive lip gloss.” They went on to say that the product amount is generous – “You get plenty of product (like, a lot)” – making it even more economical in the long run.
When you consider that some reviewers mentioned having their tube last for a YEAR with regular use, the cost-per-wear is practically pennies!
THE NOT-SO-GREAT STUFF
In the interest of keeping it 100% real with you, I should mention a few downsides that popped up in reviews:
- Packaging/Shipping Issues: Several people mentioned receiving the product with the seal broken or the product appearing used, which is obviously a major turn-off. This seems to be a shipping/handling issue rather than a product problem, but it’s worth noting.
- Texture Preferences: A couple of reviewers found it “very thick and sticky,” though this was definitely the minority opinion. Texture preferences are super subjective when it comes to lip products.
- Color Payoff Expectations: If you’re buying a darker shade expecting opaque color, you might be disappointed. These are designed to be sheer, so keep that in mind when selecting your shade.
- Potential Sensitivity: A few reviewers mentioned a tingling sensation that made them wonder if they were having a mild allergic reaction. If you have sensitive lips, patch test first!
WHO SHOULD BUY THIS?
This gloss is PERFECT for:
- Anyone tired of spending $$$ on high-end lip products
- People who prefer a more natural, sheer look
- Those who prioritize comfort over intense color
- Dry lip sufferers looking for hydration AND shine
- Conscious consumers who want vegan, cruelty-free options
- Coconut scent lovers!
WHO SHOULD SKIP IT?
You might want to pass if:
- You’re looking for highly pigmented, opaque color
- You hate any hint of stickiness in lip products
- You’re sensitive to scented cosmetics
- You specifically want a lip plumper (this isn’t marketed as one!)
THE VERDICT
After using this gloss consistently and reviewing feedback from dozens of other users, I can confidently say that the COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss in “My Main Squeeze” is a SOLID 9/10 and one of the best drugstore lip glosses on the market today.
It delivers everything most of us want in a daily gloss – comfort, hydration, a beautiful natural finish, and a delicious scent – all at a price point that won’t make you wince when it’s time to replace it.
As one reviewer summed it up perfectly: “This is a great gloss and great price.” Sometimes the simplest statements say it all!
I’ve actually purchased this gloss MULTIPLE times now (currently on my third tube!), which is probably the strongest endorsement I can give any beauty product. In an industry where I’m constantly testing new products, returning to the same one again and again speaks volumes.
Whether you’re a makeup minimalist looking for an easy everyday option or a beauty enthusiast wanting to save some cash without sacrificing quality, this gloss deserves a spot in your collection. At $10, it’s a low-risk purchase that might just become your new obsession!
Have you tried the COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss? Drop a comment below with your favorite shade and let me know how it worked for you! 💋
QUICK STATS:
- Price:Â Around $10
- Shades Available:Â Multiple options (including clear and tinted)
- Best For:Â Everyday wear, hydration, natural finish
- Vegan/Cruelty-Free:Â YES to both!
- Scent:Â Coconut (delicious!)
- Staying Power:Â 2-3 hours (good for a gloss!)
- Repurchase Probability:Â Already on my 3rd tube – 100% YES!
Buy on Amazon: Here
