As a makeup artist who’s tested countless products over the years, I’m always on the hunt for affordable gems that perform like high-end options. Today, I’m diving deep into CoverGirl’s popular combo: the Lash Blast Clump Crusher Mascara in Very Black paired with the Black Onyx Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil.
After analyzing dozens of customer reviews and combining them with my professional experience, I’m giving you the REAL scoop on whether these products deserve a spot in your makeup bag!
Lash Blast Clump Crusher Mascara: Does It Live Up to Its Name?
First Impressions & Packaging
The Clump Crusher comes in CoverGirl’s recognizable green tube with a curved rubber wand. The packaging is functional but nothing fancy – this isn’t about shelf appeal, it’s about performance. One clever detail many users appreciate: the mascara comes with a screw-on cap for shipping, with the wand packaged separately. This not only prevents leakage during transit but could be super handy when traveling!
The Wand – The Real Star
Let’s talk about this wand because it’s TRULY what sets this mascara apart. The curved rubber bristles are designed specifically to prevent clumping, and most users agree it delivers on this promise. The curve fits naturally against your lash line, making application remarkably easy.
As one long-time user mentioned: “I’ve tried all the mascaras out there, but this one truly lives up to its name—it doesn’t clump, no matter how many coats you apply.”
The wand is slightly stiff, which means you need to be careful near your eye, but this firmness has a purpose – it allows for precise application and better lash separation. The curved design is versatile too:
- Use the arch (outer curve) to help curl lashes
- Use the inner curve for your lower lashes
- Use the side of the wand for a feathery look
Formula & Performance
The formula tends toward the drier side compared to goopier mascaras like L’Oréal Voluminous. This isn’t a flaw – it’s actually by design to prevent clumping! The drier consistency means:
- Building without bulk: You can layer multiple coats without creating spider lashes
- Less mess: It doesn’t easily transfer to your eyelids during application
- More control: The product distributes more evenly
In terms of what it offers your lashes:
- Volume: Good but not dramatic (about 150% volume, not the 200% the packaging claims)
- Length: Decent but not extraordinary
- Definition: EXCELLENT – this is where it truly shines
- Curl hold: Average to good, depending on your natural lashes
Staying Power
Most users report that the regular (non-waterproof) version has surprisingly good staying power. It doesn’t typically smudge or create raccoon eyes by mid-day, which is impressive for a non-waterproof formula. However, it’s specifically water-RESISTANT, not waterproof – an important distinction!
As one reviewer put it: “The best part is, it doesn’t smear or leave those dreaded black marks under your eyes, even on the sweatiest days. No more raccoon eyes!”
That said, it WILL come off with tears – something to consider if you’re heading to a wedding or sad movie!
Color Options
A major plus is the range of colors available. While many brands only offer black and maybe brown-black, CoverGirl provides:
- Very Black (most dramatic)
- Black
- Brown-Black
- True Brown (rare in drugstore mascaras!)
The brown option is especially appreciated by redheads and those with fair coloring who find black too harsh for everyday wear.
Common Complaints
No product is perfect, so let’s address the issues that came up repeatedly:
- Drying out: Several users mentioned their mascara dried out faster than expected, sometimes within just 1-2 months
- Flaking: While most praised its flake-free formula, some experienced flaking after several hours of wear
- Application learning curve: The unique wand shape takes some getting used to
- Handle design: Some find the handle bulky and oddly shaped, making precise application tricky at first
Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner in Black Onyx
While the reviews focused heavily on the mascara, there’s also the Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner to consider as part of this duo.
What Sets It Apart
This self-sharpening eyeliner pencil eliminates the hassle of manual sharpening. It delivers a precise line that can be smudged while fresh but sets for longer wear. The Black Onyx shade is a rich, deep black that complements the Very Black mascara perfectly.
Formula & Application
Based on the reviews that mentioned eyeliner, some users found it slightly dry, which might require multiple passes for a fully opaque line. However, this drier formula also means it’s less likely to smudge throughout the day.
The Dynamic Duo: How They Work Together
When paired together, these products create a defined, polished eye look that works for both everyday wear and special occasions. The mascara’s ability to separate and define lashes complements the eyeliner’s precision.
For best results:
- Apply the Perfect Point Plus eyeliner first, keeping close to the lash line
- Allow it to set for 30 seconds
- Apply Clump Crusher mascara, using the curved wand to reach every lash
- For more volume, add a second coat of mascara while the first is still slightly wet
Value Proposition
At drugstore prices (typically under $10 each), these products offer exceptional performance that rivals high-end brands. Many reviewers specifically mentioned switching from premium brands to this CoverGirl combo and being pleasantly surprised by the results.
One reviewer summed it up perfectly: “I usually get my mascara from Sephora… But based on all the great reviews, I gave this a shot… The end result was really natural pretty lashes.”
Who Should Buy This Duo?
Perfect For:
- People seeking a natural, defined eye look
- Those frustrated by clumpy mascaras
- Makeup minimalists who want reliable basics
- Anyone with sensitive eyes (many reviews mentioned no irritation)
- Fair-skinned individuals who appreciate the brown shade option
- Budget-conscious shoppers who don’t want to compromise on quality
Maybe Skip If:
- You want dramatic, falsie-like lashes from a single product
- You need guaranteed waterproof performance
- You prefer very wet mascara formulas
- You have extremely short lashes that need specialized lengthening formulas
Application Tips From Reviews
Some clever application techniques emerged from the reviews:
- For the mascara: “The wand is curved, so I’ll call it concave and convex… The convex side is great for lengthening, and the concave is fantastic for bottom lashes.”
- Building volume: “You can easily build up to a heavy coverage without any mess.”
- Keep old wands: “I keep the clean wand of each successive Clump Buster to follow up from my first coat to get my lashes just right.”
- For the eyeliner: Apply to the upper waterline for the appearance of fuller lashes before adding mascara.
My Professional Take
As a makeup artist, what impresses me most about these products is their reliability and versatility. They work across different eye shapes, lash types, and skin tones. The mascara particularly stands out in a market flooded with formulas that promise the world but deliver clumpy, flaky results.
While neither product will give you the most dramatic look possible, they excel at creating clean, defined eyes that enhance your natural features – exactly what most people want for everyday makeup.
The staying power of both products is impressive for their price point, though the mascara does outperform the eyeliner in longevity based on the reviews.
Final Verdict
Lash Blast Clump Crusher Mascara
Rating: 4.5/5 Pros: True clump-free formula, easy application, good color options, decent staying power Cons: Tends to dry out quickly, occasional flaking, not dramatically volumizing
Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Rating: 4/5 Pros: Convenient self-sharpening design, good pigmentation, complements the mascara Cons: Can be slightly dry, may require multiple passes
As a Duo
Rating: 4.5/5 These products work beautifully together to create defined, polished eye looks without breaking the bank. They’re reliable workhorses that deserve a place in both beginner and professional makeup kits.
The Bottom Line
If you’re tired of mascara that clumps, flakes, or gives you raccoon eyes by lunchtime, the CoverGirl Lash Blast Clump Crusher is DEFINITELY worth trying. Paired with the Perfect Point Plus eyeliner, you’ve got an affordable eye duo that delivers consistent results.
As one devoted user put it: “I’ve been using this mascara for years now, and whenever I try something different thinking it might be better, I am inevitably proven wrong.”
Sometimes the classics are classics for a reason! 😊
Buy on Amazon: Here
