As a beauty expert who has seen countless makeup products come and go over the years, I’ve had the opportunity to test the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil in Basic Black extensively. This review compiles my professional assessment along with insights from numerous user experiences to give you the complete picture of this longtime drugstore staple.
First Impressions and Packaging
The COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner comes in simple, recognizable packaging that has remained largely unchanged for years – a testament to its enduring popularity. The dual-ended design features the pencil on one end and a smudging tip on the other, making it immediately apparent that this product aims to offer versatility in application styles.
At first glance, this eyeliner pencil might seem unremarkable compared to newer, trendier options on the market. However, there’s something to be said for consistency and reliability, qualities that have kept this product in makeup bags for what many users describe as “decades.”
Price Point and Value
One of the most frequently praised aspects of this eyeliner is its affordability. Priced around $3-5 depending on the retailer, it represents exceptional value in the cosmetics world. Many users specifically mention choosing this product because of its budget-friendly price combined with performance that rivals more expensive alternatives.
The pencil contains a generous amount of product that, when properly maintained with regular sharpening, can last for months of daily use. This longevity further enhances its value proposition, especially for those who apply eyeliner daily.
Application Experience
Texture and Pigmentation
The texture of the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner appears to vary somewhat between batches, according to user feedback. When at its best, the pencil offers a smooth, creamy consistency that glides across the eyelid without pulling or tugging at the delicate skin. The pigmentation is described as rich and dark, delivering a true black color that stands out beautifully.
However, some users report receiving pencils that are harder in texture, requiring more pressure to apply. This inconsistency is mentioned several times throughout the reviews, suggesting quality control may be an issue. When encountering a harder pencil, some users recommend warming it briefly with a hairdryer to soften the formula for easier application.
Precision and Control
Where this eyeliner truly excels is in the level of control it offers. Unlike liquid or gel liners that can be intimidating for beginners, this pencil format allows for precise application that can be built up gradually. Users note that it’s ideal for creating thin lines along the lash line or building to a thicker, more dramatic look.
The pencil maintains its point reasonably well during application, though it does require regular sharpening to maintain precision. Many users mentioned the importance of having a quality sharpener on hand, as the pencil does not come with one included.
The Blending Tip
The standout feature of this product is undoubtedly the blending tip at the opposite end of the pencil. This sponge-like applicator allows for immediate smudging and softening of the line after application, creating a smoky, diffused effect that many users cherish.
The blending tip proves especially useful for:
- Correcting minor mistakes without having to remove and reapply
- Creating a softer, more natural look
- Achieving a smoky eye effect with minimal effort and tools
- Transitioning from a daytime to evening look by smudging an already applied line
Users with less steady hands particularly appreciate this feature, as it forgives imprecise application and transforms wobbly lines into an intentionally smudged, smoky look.
Wear Performance
Longevity
The longevity of this eyeliner varies considerably based on individual factors such as skin type, environmental conditions, and application method. Many users report satisfactory wear time of 6-8 hours without significant fading or smudging, particularly when applied to the upper lash line.
For those with oily eyelids, the wear time may be reduced, with some reporting the need for midday touch-ups. Several users recommend using an eyeshadow primer beneath the eyeliner to extend wear time significantly.
It’s worth noting that this is not marketed as a waterproof formula, and indeed, it does not hold up well to tears, rain, or swimming. For emotional events or water activities, a waterproof alternative would be more suitable.
Smudging and Transfer
The intentional smudging capability of this eyeliner (via the blending tip) is a definite strength, but unintentional smudging can be an issue for some users. Those with oily skin or hooded eyelids report more problems with transfer to the upper lid and smudging throughout the day.
Several users note that the eyeliner performs particularly poorly on the waterline, with the color fading quickly or transferring to the lower lash line, creating a “raccoon eyes” effect. Those who primarily use eyeliner on the waterline may want to consider other options specifically designed for that purpose.
However, many long-term users express that they’ve learned techniques to minimize these issues, such as setting the eyeliner with a matching eyeshadow or using a translucent powder on the areas prone to transfer.
Removal Process
One universally appreciated aspect of this eyeliner is its easy removal process. Unlike waterproof formulas that require dedicated makeup removers and potentially harsh rubbing, this eyeliner washes away easily with regular facial cleanser or makeup remover wipes.
This gentle removal process is especially beneficial for those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, as it minimizes irritation and pulling on the delicate eye area. Several users specifically mentioned switching to this eyeliner from waterproof formulas for this very reason.
Special Considerations
For Sensitive Eyes
Many users with sensitive eyes or contact lenses report that this eyeliner causes minimal irritation compared to other formulas. The absence of strong fragrances and the creamy (rather than flaky) texture likely contribute to this compatibility with sensitive eyes.
One user specifically mentioned that this is the only eyeliner they’ve found that doesn’t cause their eyes to “itch and water like crazy,” suggesting it may be worth trying for those who typically experience eye irritation with cosmetics.
For Mature Skin
Several users with mature skin commented on the eyeliner’s performance as they’ve aged. The general consensus is that the creamy formula works well on less taut skin, though some noted it can be slightly dry for application on very mature skin with fine lines.
The blending capability proves particularly useful for older users who may prefer a softer, less harsh line around the eyes. One user mentioned that the perfect blend eyeliner “gives you a nice and soft look” that works well with hooded or aging eyelids.
For Beginners
This eyeliner receives frequent recommendations for makeup beginners. The pencil format, blending tip, and forgiving formula make it an excellent choice for those still developing their application skills. Several users mentioned that they were “teaching themselves how to use eyeliner” and found this product to be “by far the easiest method.”
Potential Drawbacks
While the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner has many devotees, no product is without its flaws. Based on user feedback, the main drawbacks include:
- Inconsistent quality control – Some users report receiving pencils that are harder in texture and difficult to apply smoothly
- Limited wear time on oily skin – Without primer, may require touch-ups throughout the day
- Poor performance on the waterline – Fades quickly when applied to this area
- Frequent sharpening required – The soft formula means more frequent sharpening than harder pencils
- No sharpener included – Requires separate purchase of a quality sharpener
- Possible counterfeit issues – Some users suspect receiving counterfeit products when purchased online
- Recent formula changes – Long-term users note changes in the formula over the years, with some preferring the older version
Comparison to Alternatives
Many users compare this eyeliner to both drugstore and high-end alternatives. The consensus seems to be that while there are longer-lasting options available (particularly gel or liquid formulas), few match the ease of application, blendability, and value proposition of the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend.
Several users specifically mentioned returning to this product after trying more expensive options, finding that the performance difference didn’t justify the price increase. As one user succinctly put it: “I’ve bought the very best, spent so much money, but was never satisfied! I’ve used this for years. Those fancy ones simply don’t wow me.”
Who Should Buy This Product
Based on the compiled feedback, this eyeliner is most suitable for:
- Budget-conscious makeup users who want quality without a high price tag
- Beginners learning eyeliner application techniques
- Those who prefer a soft, smudged, or smoky eye look
- People with sensitive eyes who experience irritation with other formulas
- Anyone who values easy makeup removal
- Those who appreciate versatility in their makeup products
It may be less suitable for:
- Those who require extremely long-wearing or waterproof formulas
- People who primarily apply eyeliner to their waterline
- Users with very oily eyelids (unless willing to use with primer)
- Those who prefer the precision and intensity of liquid or gel liners
Final Verdict
The COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil in Basic Black has earned its place as a drugstore classic through decades of reliable performance. While not the most innovative or longest-lasting eyeliner on the market, it offers exceptional value, versatility, and user-friendliness that continues to attract both loyal users and newcomers.
For those seeking an affordable, easy-to-use pencil eyeliner with the added benefit of a blending tip, this product remains one of the best options available. Its staying power in a rapidly changing beauty industry speaks volumes about its fundamental quality and utility.
This eyeliner earns 4 out of 5 stars – losing one star for the inconsistent quality control and limited wear time reported by some users, but gaining strong marks for value, versatility, and user-friendliness.
Whether you’re just starting your makeup journey or have been applying eyeliner for decades, the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner deserves consideration for your makeup collection.
Quick Summary:
Pros:
- Affordable price point
- Dual-ended design with useful blending tip
- Smooth application (when at its best)
- Rich black pigmentation
- Easy to control and build up
- Simple to remove
- Suitable for sensitive eyes
- Versatile for different eye looks
Cons:
- Inconsistent quality between pencils
- Not waterproof
- Limited wear time on oily skin
- Requires frequent sharpening
- No sharpener included
- Not ideal for waterline application
Rating: 4/5 stars
Buy on Amazon: Here
