In the ever-evolving world of lip products, finding the perfect balance between longevity, comfort, and color payoff remains the holy grail for many makeup enthusiasts. COVERGIRL’s Outlast Lipstain in shade 60 Plum Berry promises to check all these boxes with its innovative formula and pen-like applicator. As someone who has spent years testing and reviewing beauty products, I was eager to put this affordable drugstore option to the test and see if it lives up to its bold claims.
Product Specifications
Product Name: COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain
Shade: 60 Plum Berry
Size: 0.06 oz
Key Features:
- Pen-like precision tip applicator
- Transfer-proof formula
- Satin stained finish
- Vegan formula
- Long-wearing color
First Impressions
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain comes in a sleek, marker-style packaging that feels lightweight in the hand. Its design is practical and travel-friendly, resembling a felt-tip pen more than a traditional lipstick. The shade 60 Plum Berry presents as a rich, deep berry tone with purple undertones that appears quite vibrant in the packaging.
Upon first inspection, the precision tip applicator stands out as a differentiating feature from other lip stains on the market. This design choice clearly aims to provide better control during application, especially when defining the cupid’s bow and corners of the lips.
Application Experience
The application process with the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain is straightforward and user-friendly. The pen-like tip allows for precise application without the need for a separate lip liner, which is a significant time-saver for those with busy morning routines. As one reviewer noted, it’s “beginner-friendly” since you don’t need additional products to achieve a clean, defined lip look.
The tip dispenses color evenly when the product is fresh, though it’s important to note that several reviewers mentioned issues with the pen drying out relatively quickly. For optimal application, I recommend storing the product cap-down and using it within the first few months of opening.
The formula glides on smoothly and feels incredibly lightweight – almost undetectable once applied. Unlike traditional lipsticks that can feel heavy or creamy, this stain truly merges with the lips, creating what one user described as a “semi-permanent marker for your lips.”
Color Payoff and Finish
The Plum Berry shade delivers a beautiful, rich color that enhances the natural lip tone while adding a sophisticated pop of color. The pigmentation is buildable, allowing for a subtle stain with one light coat or a more intense color with additional layers.
The finish is best described as a satin stain – not completely matte, yet not glossy either. This middle-ground finish creates a natural-looking lip that doesn’t appear flat or overly made-up. For those seeking more shine, several reviewers mentioned layering a clear lip gloss or balm over the stain with excellent results, creating what one called a “perfect” look.
Longevity and Wear
The longevity of this product appears to be its most polarizing aspect based on user feedback. Many loyal users praise its remarkable staying power, with comments like “really does last for hours and hours” and “stays on longer and doesn’t rub off easily.” These satisfied customers report minimal need for touch-ups throughout a full workday.
Particularly impressive is the stain’s resistance to transfer – it doesn’t come off on cups, napkins, or clothing. This makes it an excellent choice for situations where you don’t want to worry about lipstick marks or constant reapplication, such as during meals, long meetings, or special events.
However, a significant number of reviewers had contrary experiences, noting that the product “does not last like it is advertised” or “doesn’t stay with you more than a few hours.” This discrepancy in experiences could be attributed to several factors:
- Lip preparation: Stains generally perform better on exfoliated, balm-free lips
- Individual lip chemistry: Some people’s natural lip pH and oil production may break down the stain faster
- Product age: As several reviewers noted, these pens can dry out over time, potentially affecting performance
- Application technique: Applying in thin layers allows better absorption into the lips
- Eating and drinking habits: Oily foods and frequent drinking will naturally remove the stain faster
One particularly helpful observation came from a reviewer who noted that the stain “does not fade off in sections, nor does it bleed over the lips” – suggesting that even as it wears, it does so evenly rather than creating the dreaded “ring around the lips” effect that many long-wearing lip products can leave behind.
Comfort and Feel
The weightless nature of this lip stain sets it apart from many long-wearing lip products that can feel drying or tacky. Multiple reviewers commented on how they “forget” they’re wearing it, which is high praise for any lip product intended for all-day wear.
That said, like most stains, it doesn’t provide moisture on its own. Several users mentioned pairing it with a hydrating balm or gloss, which not only enhances the comfort level but also creates a customizable finish. One reviewer specifically mentioned using an “SPF lip gloss” over it, highlighting the versatility of this product as a base for other lip products.
Value Proposition
At its price point (typically under $10), the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain represents an affordable entry into the world of long-wearing lip color. The small size (0.06 oz) was mentioned by several reviewers, with one noting they “went through it pretty quickly, but the tube is not that big. The price is not bad so I don’t mind.”
Some long-time users expressed disappointment that “this product size has been reduced significantly” compared to earlier versions, suggesting that COVERGIRL may have decreased the amount of product over the years while maintaining similar pricing.
The value equation is also affected by the product’s tendency to dry out before it’s fully used. Multiple reviewers mentioned receiving products that were already partially dried out or having them dry up within weeks of purchase. This issue significantly impacts the cost-effectiveness of the product, regardless of its initial affordable price point.
Potential Drawbacks
Based on the collective feedback, there are several potential drawbacks to consider:
- Drying issues: Multiple reports of the pen drying out prematurely or arriving already partially dried out
- Consistency in manufacturing: Some reviewers who were long-time users noted a decline in quality compared to earlier versions
- Packaging integrity: At least one reviewer mentioned receiving opened products, raising concerns about quality control
- Uneven application: Some users found the application to be blotchy or uneven, particularly as the product aged
- Limited shade range: While this review focuses on Plum Berry, it’s worth noting that COVERGIRL offers a relatively limited shade selection compared to some competitors
Who Would Benefit Most From This Product
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in Plum Berry would be ideal for:
- Busy professionals who don’t have time for frequent touch-ups
- Makeup minimalists who prefer lightweight, natural-looking color
- Those with thin lips who want definition without heaviness (one reviewer mentioned it “fills in my lips so it looks like I have some”)
- People who hate transfer and don’t want to worry about lipstick marks on cups, masks, or cheeks
- Budget-conscious beauty lovers looking for affordable long-wear options
- Those who prefer customizable finishes by layering balms or glosses over a stain base
One interesting note came from a 74-year-old reviewer who found the color too bright but used it very lightly for a subtle effect. This highlights the product’s versatility across age groups and preferred intensity levels.
Practical Usage Tips
Based on the collective wisdom from multiple reviewers, here are some practical tips for getting the most out of this product:
- Exfoliate lips beforehand for the smoothest, most even application
- Apply to completely bare lips free of balm or other products for best adhesion
- Start with thin layers and build up color gradually rather than applying heavily at once
- Store the pen cap-down to keep the tip from drying out
- Consider a clear balm or gloss topper for added comfort and shine
- Use the edge of the tip for precise lining and the flat side for filling in
- Purchase from reputable sellers to avoid potentially opened or dried-out products
- Consider buying a backup if you find it works well for you, as several reviewers mentioned difficulty finding it in physical stores
Conclusion
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 60 Plum Berry presents a compelling option in the affordable long-wearing lip color category. Its strengths lie in its lightweight feel, precise application, transfer-resistance, and beautiful color payoff when the product is fresh and properly applied.
However, concerns about product longevity in the packaging, consistency in manufacturing, and varying experiences with wear time suggest that this is a product that may perform differently based on individual factors and product freshness.
For those seeking an affordable, no-fuss lip color that can last through much of the day without the heaviness of traditional lipstick, this product is worth trying – particularly if you’re willing to pair it with a hydrating balm or gloss for optimal comfort and appearance.
Overall, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain represents a solid entry in the drugstore lip stain category, offering good value when fresh and properly stored, despite some inconsistencies in user experience.
Rating: 3.5/5 Stars
Pros:
- Precise, pen-like applicator
- Lightweight, barely-there feel
- Transfer-resistant formula
- Beautiful color payoff
- Affordable price point
- Vegan formula
Cons:
- Product may dry out prematurely
- Inconsistent longevity reports
- Reduced product size compared to earlier versions
- May require lip balm or gloss for optimal comfort
- Some quality control concerns
Buy on Amazon: Here
