In the ever-evolving world of lip products, finding the perfect balance between longevity, comfort, and color payoff can feel like searching for a unicorn. The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 70 Crimson Glory promises to solve this common beauty dilemma with its innovative formula and unique pen-like applicator. As someone who has analyzed countless beauty products and their real-world performance, I’m taking a deep dive into this particular lip stain to determine whether it lives up to its claims or falls short of expectations.
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain presents itself as a game-changer: a vegan formula with a transfer-proof finish that delivers long-lasting color without the heaviness of traditional lipsticks. But does it truly deliver? Let’s examine every aspect of this product, from application to wear time, to help you decide if it deserves a place in your makeup collection.
Before diving into performance, let’s cover the basics:
- Product Name: COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain
- Shade: 70 Crimson Glory
- Format: Pen-style lip stain with marker-like tip
- Finish: Satin stained finish
- Formula: Vegan
- Quantity: 0.06oz
- Key Claims: Transfer-proof, long-lasting, precise application
First Impressions and Packaging
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain comes in a sleek, pen-like package that immediately communicates its primary benefit: precision. The design is both practical and appealing, offering a straightforward approach to lip color application. The pen format makes it easily portable and eliminates the need for separate lip liners or brushes, which busy makeup users will appreciate.
The packaging is sturdy enough for daily use and travel, though some users might find the cap requires secure placement to prevent the tip from drying out. The minimal design aligns well with COVERGIRL’s accessible, no-frills approach to beauty products.
Application Experience
One of the most significant advantages of this lipstain is its unique applicator. The precise, pen-like tip allows for exceptional control during application, making it possible to outline and fill lips with remarkable accuracy. This feature received particular praise from users who specifically sought a product for precise lip lining.
The application process is relatively straightforward:
- Start by ensuring lips are clean and dry
- Use the tip to outline the lips with light pressure
- Fill in the remainder of the lips with sweeping motions
- Allow to dry completely before pressing lips together (approximately 30-60 seconds)
Many users note that the product applies smoothly and evenly, though the liquid consistency requires a steady hand. The color appears vibrant immediately upon application, which some users find intimidating. However, it typically settles into a more natural finish after fully drying.
Color Accuracy and Pigmentation
The shade “70 Crimson Glory” presents an interesting case study in color perception and marketing. While the name suggests a deep, true red shade, many users report that the color appears significantly more pink or fuchsia than expected. This discrepancy between naming and actual appearance is a recurring theme in customer feedback.
The pigmentation is undeniably strong—one application delivers vibrant, noticeable color. Some users employ a strategic approach of applying a small amount and blending with their finger to achieve a more subtle tint. This technique allows for versatility in the product’s use, from bold statement lips to a natural flush of color.
It’s worth noting that the shade’s appearance varies significantly depending on the wearer’s natural lip color and skin tone. Those with cooler undertones often report the color appearing more purple, while those with warmer undertones might see a brighter pink-red. This variability makes the shade somewhat unpredictable across different users.
Comfort and Feel
Lip stains, by nature, often present a comfort challenge. The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain receives mixed reviews in this department, with experience varying significantly between users.
Many users appreciate that the product doesn’t have the heavy, waxy feel of traditional lipsticks. Once dry, numerous reviewers report that it feels like wearing nothing at all—a significant benefit for those who dislike the sensation of lip products.
However, a substantial portion of users note that the formula can be drying to the lips over time. This appears to be a common trade-off with long-lasting lip products in general, rather than a specific failing of this COVERGIRL offering. A popular workaround mentioned by several users is applying a clear lip balm or petroleum jelly over the stain after it has dried completely. This technique helps maintain comfort while preserving the color underneath.
The initial texture is described as slightly sticky during the drying process, but this sensation dissipates once the product sets. The drying time is relatively quick, typically requiring just 1-2 minutes to fully set.
Longevity and Wear Performance
Longevity is perhaps the most crucial aspect of any lip stain—after all, extended wear time is the primary reason most consumers choose a stain over conventional lip products. The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain shows varying performance in this area, with significant differences in user experience.
Many users report impressive staying power, with the stain remaining visible for 6+ hours, even through drinking and light snacking. Some particularly enthusiastic reviewers mention waking up with color still visible on their lips the following morning.
However, there’s a notable contingent of users who experienced disappointing wear time, with the product fading significantly after just 1-2 hours. The most consistent feedback indicates that while the product may not completely disappear, it does fade and can become patchy after meals or frequent drinking.
Performance patterns worth noting:
- The stain tends to wear off from the center of the lips first
- Edges can sometimes remain more pigmented, creating a “lip liner” effect
- Some users notice bleeding or feathering along the lip line throughout the day
- Oil-based foods seem to break down the stain more quickly than other activities
The product performs best when lips are properly exfoliated before application, as it can cling to dry patches and accentuate lip texture. Users who take the time to prep their lips thoroughly generally report better longevity and more even wear.
Transfer Resistance
The transfer-proof claim is one of COVERGIRL’s key selling points for this product, and it largely delivers on this promise. After the initial drying period, most users report minimal transfer onto cups, clothing, or during kisses. This feature makes it particularly valuable for special occasions, masks-on environments, or situations where lipstick transfer would be problematic.
However, it’s important to note that while the product resists casual contact, it isn’t entirely transfer-proof when subjected to friction or oil. Several users mention that the color still transfers somewhat during meals or when blotted firmly. The consensus seems to be that it outperforms traditional lipsticks in transfer resistance but doesn’t achieve complete transfer-proof status.
An interesting observation from multiple users is that the product is so transfer-resistant that it’s difficult to remove from skin if accidentally applied outside the lip line. This speaks to its staying power but also suggests the need for careful application.
Value Assessment
At its typical price point (varying by retailer), the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain positions itself as an affordable option in the lip stain category. The product quantity (0.06oz) is standard for similar products, though some users note that the pen tip can dry out before the product is fully used if the cap isn’t securely fastened between uses.
Considering its performance, the product offers reasonable value for those seeking:
- Precise application
- A lightweight, non-sticky lip color
- Moderate to good staying power
- A vegan formula at an accessible price point
However, those prioritizing moisture, complete transfer resistance, or exact color matching might find the value proposition less compelling.
Comparison to Similar Products
In the context of similar lip stains on the market, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain occupies a middle ground. Some users who have tried multiple brands mention that while it outperforms many drugstore options, it doesn’t quite match the longevity of premium brand stains.
Several reviewers specifically compared it to the Maybelline SuperStay lip stain, with mixed opinions on which performs better. The COVERGIRL option appears to excel in ease of application and initial comfort, while some competing products might offer longer wear time.
The vegan formula is a distinguishing factor that gives this product an edge for ethically-conscious consumers, as many long-wearing lip products contain animal-derived ingredients.
Who Should Consider This Product
Based on aggregate feedback, this lipstain is best suited for:
- Those seeking precise lip definition without using separate liners
- People who dislike the heavy feel of traditional lipsticks
- Individuals looking for moderate staying power at an affordable price
- Those who prefer vibrant, statement lip colors
- Consumers who prioritize vegan formulations
- People who don’t mind applying a balm over their lip color for comfort
It may be less ideal for:
- Those with chronically dry or chapped lips
- People seeking a true red shade (as this leans more pink/fuchsia)
- Individuals expecting 12+ hour wear without any touch-ups
- Those who prefer subtle, barely-there lip colors without blending work
Tips for Optimal Use
To get the most from this product, consider these user-recommended techniques:
- Exfoliate lips gently before application to remove dry flakes
- Apply a light layer of balm, let it absorb completely, then apply the stain
- For a more natural look, apply a small amount to the center of the lips and blend outward with a finger
- Allow the product to dry completely (60+ seconds) before pressing lips together
- Apply a clear balm or gloss over the dried stain to add moisture without affecting color
- For special occasions, consider applying, blotting, and reapplying for intensified stay power
- Store the pen tip-down with the cap tightly secured to prevent premature drying
Potential Drawbacks
In the interest of providing a balanced assessment, several consistent drawbacks emerge from user feedback:
- Color discrepancy – The “Crimson Glory” shade appears more pink/fuchsia than true red to many users
- Drying effect – The formula can leave lips feeling parched after several hours
- Potential feathering – Some users note color bleeding beyond the lip line throughout wear
- Central fading – The stain tends to wear off from the center first, creating an uneven appearance
- Learning curve – The marker-like applicator requires practice for precise application
The Bottom Line
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 70 Crimson Glory occupies a specific niche in the lip product ecosystem. It excels as a precise, vibrant, lightweight alternative to traditional lipsticks and offers reasonable longevity for its price point. The vegan formula and transfer-resistant properties add further value to consumers prioritizing these features.
However, it isn’t without limitations. The shade name creates expectations of a true red that the product doesn’t deliver for most users, and the formula’s drying nature necessitates additional lip care measures for many. The longevity, while better than conventional lipsticks, falls short of the “outlast everything” impression that the product name might suggest.
For those seeking a lightweight, precise lip color with moderate staying power and who don’t mind the shade leaning more pink than red, this product represents a solid choice at an accessible price point. Those with specific color expectations or requiring extreme longevity might want to explore other options.
Ultimately, with proper application techniques and realistic expectations, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain can be a valuable addition to many makeup collections, particularly for those who appreciate the precision of its pen-like applicator and its comfortable, lightweight wear.
Final Rating: 3.75/5
Pros:
- Precise, pen-like applicator
- Vibrant color payoff
- Lightweight, non-sticky feel when dry
- Good transfer resistance for everyday activities
- Vegan formula
- Affordable price point
Cons:
- Shade appears more pink/fuchsia than true crimson
- Can be drying without balm application
- Moderate rather than exceptional longevity
- Potential for uneven fading
- Possible feathering around edges for some users
Whether this product earns a permanent place in your makeup rotation will depend largely on your specific priorities and expectations. For many, it represents a practical compromise between the comfort of a tint and the staying power of a traditional long-wear liquid lipstick.
Buy on Amazon: Here
