As a beauty expert with years of experience testing and reviewing cosmetic products, I’m excited to share my comprehensive analysis of the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in shade 50 Heat Wave. This product promises long-lasting color with a pen-like application, but does it live up to the hype? I’ve thoroughly examined this product and collected feedback from numerous users to provide you with the most accurate assessment possible.
Brand: COVERGIRL
Product Line: Outlast
Shade: 50 Heat Wave
Product Type: Lipstain
Weight: 0.06oz
Key Features:
- Pen-like tip for precise application
- Transfer-proof formula
- Satin stained finish
- Vegan formula
- Smooth application
First Impressions
Packaging and Design
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain comes in a sleek, marker-like package that resembles a felt-tip pen. The design is practical and straightforward, making it easy to toss into your makeup bag or purse for on-the-go touch-ups. The cap clicks securely into place, preventing any accidental uncapping that could lead to stains on your belongings.
The product features a precise pen-like tip that promises to deliver accurate application along the lip line. This design choice appears deliberate, aiming to eliminate the need for a separate lip liner while providing the control necessary for defining the lips.
Color and Appearance
Shade 50 Heat Wave is marketed as a vibrant, warm-toned color. Upon first glance, the product appears to be a rich, reddish-coral shade that would complement a variety of skin tones. The name “Heat Wave” suggests a bold, summery color that would brighten up the face and add a pop of color to any makeup look.
Application Experience
Ease of Use
The pen-like design of the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain aims to provide a user-friendly application experience. Based on user feedback, the results are mixed:
“It’s like drawing on your lips with a magic marker. A little weird but the color lasts!”
This comment highlights the unique application experience, which differs significantly from traditional lipsticks or liquid lip products. The marker-like tip allows for relatively precise application, though some users may find the sensation unusual at first.
Another user mentioned:
“The pencil application is nice as well it’s easy to draw on.”
This suggests that for many users, the design delivers on its promise of ease of application. The ability to “draw” on the lips can provide greater control than some other lip product formats.
Texture and Feel
Upon application, users report varying experiences with the texture:
“So it’s a pretty color and it’s easy to apply, but it isn’t long lasting. It’s also a little sticky even after it dries.”
This feedback indicates that the product may retain some tackiness even after the initial drying period, which could be uncomfortable for those who prefer completely dry lip products.
Another user noted:
“The felt tip is a little scratchy.”
This suggests that the applicator might not be as smooth as expected, potentially causing discomfort during application, especially for those with sensitive lips.
Dryness Concerns
A recurring theme in user feedback is the product’s dryness:
“Dries up my lips after I applied the lipstain.”
“Lip stain seemed really dry like I received an old one. I threw it out.”
“This is like a worn out dry erase marker. Hardly any color. It’s super dry.”
These comments indicate that dryness is a significant concern with this product. The formula appears to either dry out quickly in the packaging or has a drying effect on the lips themselves. For users with already dry or chapped lips, this could exacerbate the issue:
“If you have dry chapped lips it’s not going to look nice :(”
Color Payoff and Finish
Color Intensity
User experiences with the color intensity vary considerably:
“Great product. Beautiful color that lasts all day.
“The color is barely there–‘Heat Wave’ is remarkable tepid.”
This discrepancy could be attributed to several factors, including:
- Differences in application technique (number of layers applied)
- Variation in natural lip pigmentation among users
- Potential inconsistency in product quality
- Condition of the product (some may have received dried-out units)
One user describes their technique for achieving better color payoff:
“I layer it for really bold color then let it dry before putting anything over it or eating. Color does wear off a little bit but leaves a nice blush to the lips for hours.
This suggests that building up the product in layers may be necessary to achieve a vibrant color result.
Evenness of Application
A common criticism relates to the evenness of the color application:
“It doesn’t seem to apply evenly. Multiple layers are required to get a uniform color.”
“This is definitely not going to be a repeat purchase… It doesn’t leave an even color; just sporadic.”
“Did not stain, barely went on. Did not last more than an hour, very uneven.”
These comments suggest that achieving uniform color with this product can be challenging. This may be particularly problematic for a lip stain, as uneven fading could leave patchy color on the lips.
One user offered this insight about application on dry lips:
“It’s also doesn’t stain evenly if your lips have any dry areas. I apply stain to perfectly dry and product free lips, let it dry, and then apply lip balm with sunscreen over the top. Works perfect every time.”
This indicates that proper lip preparation may be crucial for achieving even results with this product.
Longevity and Wear
Staying Power
The product’s name “Outlast” suggests exceptional longevity, but user experiences are notably divided on this front:
“Great product. Beautiful color that lasts all day.
“This stain is very long wearing.”
“Color is fine for day. Goes on easily. BUT- comes off easily- does not last. Wanted more of an enduring stain- to last…”
Very pretty colors and it tastes like cotton candy on the lips, but honestly it doesn’t last anywhere NEAR 24 hours. It lasts about 1-2 hours for me.”
“It barely stayed on 2.5 hours and I didn’t drink anything other then water and did not eat.”
These wildly varying reports on longevity might be due to differences in:
- Individual body chemistry
- Eating and drinking habits
- Talking frequency
- Environmental factors
- Application technique
One particularly candid assessment states:
“It’s as long-lasting, well-defined and transfer-proof as if you’d just eaten a popsicle. At least the popsicle would taste good and last a little longer.”
This humorous but critical comparison suggests that for some users, the product falls significantly short of its long-wearing claims.
Transfer Resistance
The product is marketed as transfer-proof, but user experiences differ:
“This is long lasting and doesn’t smudge.”
“Does not stay on well at all. Colors your teeth and anything it comes into contact with.”
“Not fully transfer proof, gone with the first sip or wipe of lips.”
These conflicting reports suggest that the transfer resistance may be dependent on application technique, waiting time before eating or drinking, or possibly inconsistencies in the product formula itself.
Fading Pattern
How a lip product fades is almost as important as how long it lasts. Some users note that this lipstain fades unevenly:
“Wears off unevenly.”
“Color does wear off a little bit but leaves a nice blush to the lips for hours.
The second comment suggests that for some users, the fade-out process creates a pleasant tinted effect rather than disappearing completely or leaving an unflattering ring around the lips.
Comfort and Sensory Experience
Taste and Smell
A few users commented on the taste of the product:
“The product tastes like lipstain. It tastes exactly like the little red tablets the dentist used to hand out– you would chew the tablet after brushing and where every you missed it would be dyed bright red.”
“Applies smoothly, nice vibrant color and mild flavor.”
Very pretty colors and it tastes like cotton candy on the lips.”
These varying descriptions suggest that there might be some inconsistency in the product’s flavor profile, or that different users perceive the taste differently. For those sensitive to flavors in cosmetics, this could be an important consideration.
Comfort During Wear
Comfort during wear appears to be a concern for many users:
“Dries up my lips after I applied the lipstain.”
“It is a bit dry but it is a lip stain. I put it on then wait for it to set them use a clear lip gloss.”
These comments suggest that the product may cause some discomfort due to its drying nature. However, several users have found ways to mitigate this issue by applying lip balm or gloss over the stain once it has set.
Value and Product Lifespan
Product Quantity and Longevity
Several users expressed disappointment with how quickly the product was depleted or dried out:
“I used this product less than a handful of times and it’s Empty!!”
“After 3 uses it didn’t work anymore. Waste of money.”
“Dryer out.”
These comments suggest potential issues with the product’s design or formulation that causes it to dry out quickly or contain less usable product than expected.
Price-to-Performance Ratio
While specific price information isn’t provided in the feedback, several users commented on the value proposition:
“I would buy a million of these if I had the money.”
“Waste of money.”
“So very disappointed! Dry. Does not go on evenly. Does not stay on very long at all. Waste of money.”
These dramatically different assessments of value reflect the polarized user experiences with this product.
Versatility and Use Cases
Layering Potential
Several users mention successfully layering this product with other lip products:
I apply stain to perfectly dry and product free lips, let it dry, and then apply lip balm with sunscreen over the top. Works perfect every time.”
I put a lip oil over it and it’s definitely worth a try!”
I put it on then wait for it to set them use a clear lip gloss. It has great staying power even with gloss on top.”
These comments suggest that while the product may have some limitations on its own, it can perform well as a base for other lip products. This versatility could be valuable for users looking to create customized lip looks with long-lasting color underneath.
Occasions and Settings
Based on the feedback, this lipstain seems best suited for:
- Casual daytime wear when frequent touch-ups are possible
- As a base under clear gloss or balm
- Situations where a subtle, blotted lip look is desired
It may be less ideal for:
- Long events without touch-up opportunities
- Formal occasions requiring perfect, long-lasting color
- Users with very dry lips
- Those looking for a one-step lip solution
Comparable Products and Alternatives
While the feedback doesn’t explicitly mention alternative products, the criticisms suggest that users seeking similar benefits might want to consider:
- Other marker-style lip stains with potentially more hydrating formulas
- Traditional lipsticks with long-wearing claims
- Liquid lipsticks with staining properties
- Lip tints that might provide more even application
Target Audience
Based on the collected feedback, this product seems best suited for:
- People with naturally hydrated lips
- Those willing to prep lips thoroughly before application
- Users comfortable with building up color in layers
- People who don’t mind reapplying throughout the day
- Those who typically layer products (using balm or gloss over color)
It may not be ideal for:
- Those with chronically dry or chapped lips
- People seeking truly long-lasting (8+ hours) wear
- Users who prefer one-step lip products
- Those seeking very precise, even application without effort
Tips for Best Results
Synthesizing the more positive user experiences, here are some tips for getting the best results with this product:
- Prep Your Lips: Ensure lips are exfoliated, clean, and completely dry before application.
- Layer Strategically: Build color gradually with multiple light layers rather than one heavy application.
- Wait Between Layers: Allow each layer to dry completely before adding another.
- Set Before Eating: Give the product ample time (at least 5 minutes) to set before eating, drinking, or applying any other products.
- Top with Balm or Gloss: Once the stain has completely dried, apply a clear balm or gloss to add moisture without disturbing the color.
- Store Properly: Keep the cap tightly closed when not in use to prevent the product from drying out.
Conclusion
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in shade 50 Heat Wave presents a mixed bag of experiences for users. While some praise its color, ease of application, and lasting power, others find it drying, patchy, and short-lived.
The stark contrast in user experiences suggests that individual factors such as lip condition, application technique, and product expectations play a significant role in satisfaction with this product. It may also indicate inconsistencies in product quality or formulation.
For those considering this product, understanding its limitations is key. This appears to be a product that can perform well under specific conditions and with proper technique, but may disappoint those expecting foolproof, long-lasting color without any special care or application methods.
The pen-like design and staining formula offer a unique approach to lip color that some users clearly appreciate, particularly when used as a base layer under other products. However, those seeking moisture, opacity, or guaranteed all-day wear might want to explore other options.
Overall, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in shade 50 Heat Wave seems to be a product with potential that doesn’t consistently deliver on all its promises for all users. Your mileage may vary significantly depending on your lips, application technique, and expectations.
Final Rating
⭐⭐⭐☆☆ (3/5 stars)
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in shade 50 Heat Wave earns a middle-of-the-road rating due to its highly variable performance across different users and conditions. While it has strengths in certain areas like precise application and vibrant color potential, issues with dryness, longevity, and consistency prevent it from scoring higher.
Buy on Amazon: Here
