As a beauty expert who’s tested countless lip products over the years, I’ve seen the evolution of lip color formulations from traditional lipsticks to long-wearing stains. Today, I’m diving deep into the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in shade 05 All-Star to give you my comprehensive thoughts on this popular drugstore option that’s been generating significant buzz online.
First Impressions: Packaging and Design
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain comes in a sleek, pen-like format that immediately distinguishes it from traditional lipsticks. The slim design makes it portable and easy to slip into even the smallest makeup bag or clutch. What makes this product unique is its marker-like applicator with a precision tip that allows for detailed application – something that stood out to many users in their feedback.
One minor packaging concern worth noting: several customers mentioned that the product arrived without external packaging or tamper-evident seals. While this doesn’t affect performance, it’s something to be aware of when purchasing online versus in-store where sealed packaging would typically be expected.
Application Experience: Just Like Using a Marker
The most distinctive aspect of this product is its application method. Unlike creamy lipsticks or glossy liquid lips, this truly applies like a marker for your lips. The precision pen-like tip offers exceptional control, making it surprisingly easy to:
- Create crisp, defined lines around the lip border
- Precisely overline lips if desired
- Fill in the entire lip area with consistent color
The applicator’s fine tip provides excellent precision for lip lining – many users actually prefer using this product specifically as a lip liner rather than full coverage. This precision is particularly beneficial for those with aging lips who struggle with feathering or bleeding with traditional formulas.
When applying, you’ll notice the formula feels cool initially and has a light, pleasant scent that many users described as slightly fruity but not overpowering. The scent dissipates quickly after application.
Color Payoff: Rich, Buildable Pigmentation
The 05 All-Star shade is a vibrant, classic red with impressive color payoff on the first application. The pigmentation is rich and can be built up with additional layers for more intensity. Several reviewers noted that the color appears slightly darker in person than in product images – something to keep in mind if you’re ordering online.
One of the most significant advantages of this particular red shade is its staying power throughout wear. Unlike some red lip products that fade to an unflattering pink, All-Star maintains its true red tone even as it naturally fades throughout the day.
The finish is a satin-stained look – not fully matte, but definitely not glossy. It creates what several users described as a natural-looking stain effect, particularly after it’s been on for a few hours. The color intensity does deepen slightly as it sets, so starting with a lighter application might be advisable for those wanting a more subtle look.
Longevity: Does It Really Last All Day?
The “Outlast” in the product name sets high expectations, and based on customer feedback, it largely delivers on this promise. The consensus among users is that this lip stain genuinely provides exceptional longevity compared to traditional lipsticks. Many reported that it:
- Stays vibrant through eating and drinking
- Doesn’t transfer to coffee cups or water bottles
- Maintains a visible stain effect even after 6+ hours of wear
- Often requires makeup remover for complete removal
One particularly enthusiastic user reported the stain lasting through three HIIT workout classes – an impressive testament to its staying power! Several others mentioned that even after attempting to remove it, a subtle stain remained, giving credence to the “stain” in its name.
However, longevity experiences varied somewhat. While most users experienced all-day wear, a small minority reported more limited staying power of just a few hours. This variance might be attributed to differences in application technique, lip preparation, or individual body chemistry.
Comfort and Feel: The Trade-Off for Longevity
As with most long-wearing lip products, there is a comfort trade-off for that impressive staying power. The most consistent critique from users was that the formula can feel drying on the lips, particularly when worn alone.
Fortunately, there’s an easy solution that many users discovered: applying a clear lip balm or gloss over the stain after it sets. The good news is that, unlike many lip colors, this stain doesn’t smear or transfer significantly when balm is applied over it. Several users specifically mentioned successfully layering products like lip oils, clear balm, or gloss without compromising the color’s integrity or longevity.
The texture after application is described as lightweight and “airless” – you barely feel it on your lips, except for occasional stickiness reported by some users, particularly at the corners of the mouth.
Transfer-Resistance: A Standout Feature
One of the most praised aspects of this lipstain is its impressive transfer resistance. Multiple users specifically highlighted that it:
- Doesn’t leave marks on cups, glasses, or straws
- Doesn’t transfer to teeth (a common problem with red lipsticks)
- Remains intact through eating and drinking
- Doesn’t smudge during wear
This transfer-proof quality makes it particularly valuable for special occasions, long workdays, or any situation where you don’t want to worry about constant touch-ups or embarrassing lip color transfer.
Application Tips for Best Results
Based on consolidated user experiences, here are some pro tips for getting the best results with this lip stain:
- Exfoliate lips beforehand: Several users emphasized the importance of starting with smooth, exfoliated lips, as the stain can cling to dry patches.
- Apply to clean, dry lips: For maximum longevity, apply to completely bare lips – lip balm or moisturizer applied beforehand can prevent the stain from adhering properly.
- Work quickly: The formula sets rapidly, so work efficiently when applying. Going over areas after the formula has started to dry can cause patchiness.
- Build gradually: Start with a light application and build up if needed, as the color can appear darker than expected and intensifies slightly as it sets.
- Add hydration after setting: Allow the stain to set completely (2-3 minutes) before applying any lip balm or gloss on top.
- Remove with oil-based products: At the end of the day, use an oil-based makeup remover or cleansing balm for complete removal.
Versatility: Multiple Ways to Wear
What makes this product particularly interesting is its versatility. Users reported several different ways of incorporating it into their makeup routines:
- As a traditional full-coverage lip color
- As a precise lip liner paired with other lip products
- As a base stain with clear gloss or balm on top
- Applied lightly for a subtle bitten-lip effect
- Built up for a bold, dramatic statement lip
This adaptability allows for customization based on the occasion, desired look, or personal preference.
Value for Money: Product Longevity Concerns
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain is priced in the affordable drugstore range, which initially suggests good value. However, several users raised concerns about how quickly the product dries out. Multiple reports indicated that the marker-like applicator began drying out after just a few weeks of regular use, with some users noting significant dryness after only a month.
This short product lifespan was the most consistent negative feedback across reviews. Some users mentioned storing the product tip-down to extend its life, but this appeared to have limited effectiveness. For those who love the product, this means potentially needing to repurchase frequently, which affects the overall value proposition.
Comparison to Similar Products
Several reviewers compared this product to other lip stains on the market, with one specifically mentioning they preferred the COVERGIRL Outlast to the pricier Wonderskin alternative. Others noted that it outperformed similar stain products they had tried, particularly in terms of longevity and color payoff.
The marker-tip format was frequently mentioned as superior to cream-based lip liners for precision application, especially for those with aging lips concerned about feathering.
Who Is This Product Ideal For?
Based on user feedback, this product seems particularly well-suited for:
- Those who struggle with traditional lipsticks transferring or fading quickly
- People who want precise application without feathering or bleeding
- Makeup wearers who prioritize longevity over extreme comfort
- Those looking for a versatile product that can be used as both liner and full color
- Anyone who enjoys a natural-looking stained finish rather than a heavy lipstick look
It may be less ideal for those with chronically dry lips or who prioritize moisturizing formulas over longevity.
Shade Analysis: 05 All-Star
The 05 All-Star shade is described consistently as a vibrant, classic red. Several reviewers with fair skin tones mentioned it was particularly flattering, though the shade appears to work across various skin tones.
What makes this particular red shade stand out is its true-to-color wear. Unlike some red lip products that fade to pink or orange undertones, All-Star maintains its red character even as it naturally fades throughout the day.
Environmental and Ethical Considerations
COVERGIRL highlights that this formula is vegan, which will appeal to consumers making conscious purchasing decisions. However, the packaging concerns regarding the lack of outer packaging or seals may be a consideration for those focused on sustainability or hygiene.
The Bottom Line: Is It Worth It?
After analyzing numerous user experiences, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 05 All-Star emerges as a standout drugstore option for those prioritizing longevity and transfer resistance in their lip products.
Pros:
- Exceptional longevity compared to traditional lipsticks
- Impressive transfer resistance
- Precise application with marker-like tip
- Versatile (can be used as liner or full coverage)
- Affordable price point
- Beautiful, vibrant color that maintains its tone as it fades
- Vegan formula
Cons:
- Can be drying on the lips
- Product appears to dry out quickly with regular use
- May apply unevenly if not working quickly
- Limited shade range compared to traditional lipsticks
- Some packaging concerns regarding seals/tampering
Final Verdict
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 05 All-Star earns a solid 4 out of 5 stars. It delivers impressively on its core promises of long wear and transfer resistance, with the precision applicator being a standout feature. The main drawbacks are the potential for dryness and concerns about how quickly the product dries out with regular use.
For those tired of constantly reapplying their lip color or dealing with transfer issues, this affordable lip stain offers professional-level staying power with a comfortable enough wear when paired with a balm or gloss. The fact that it can function effectively as both a lip liner and full coverage color adds value and versatility to your makeup collection.
If you’re willing to trade some moisture for serious staying power and don’t mind potentially repurchasing more frequently than other lip products, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 05 All-Star is a worthwhile addition to your makeup arsenal – especially for special occasions, long workdays, or any time you need your lip color to truly outlast your day.
How to Maximize Your COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain Experience
To get the most out of this product, consider these expert tips:
- Prep routine: Develop a consistent lip care routine including regular exfoliation and overnight moisturizing to maintain a smooth canvas.
- Storage solution: Store the product tip-down to potentially extend its lifespan and prevent premature drying.
- Strategic application: For everyday wear, consider using it primarily as a liner and base stain, then topping with balm or gloss for added comfort and shine.
- Layering technique: Experiment with layering under or over other lip products to find your perfect combination of comfort and longevity.
- Removal routine: Invest in a good oil-based makeup remover specifically designed for long-wearing lip products to ensure complete removal without excessive rubbing.
Whether you’re a makeup minimalist looking for a fuss-free lip color that actually lasts or a beauty enthusiast adding to your collection, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 05 All-Star offers impressive performance at an accessible price point – just keep that lip balm handy for the perfect balance of longevity and comfort.
Buy on Amazon: Here
