As an American beauty expert, I’ve had the opportunity to test and analyze the Covergirl Outlast “Extra Witchy” Lipstain Halloween Limited Edition. This transfer-proof, non-drying, lightweight, and buildable formula (0.05oz) offers a unique seasonal option for makeup enthusiasts. Here’s my concise review focusing on this special edition.
PACKAGING & DESIGN
The “Extra Witchy” edition features Halloween-themed packaging that perfectly captures the spooky season’s spirit. The marker-pen design is compact and portable, making it ideal for on-the-go touch-ups during Halloween parties or events. The fine tip provides precision for detailed lip lining—perfect for creating dramatic vampire or witch-inspired looks.
COLOR & PIGMENTATION
True to its name, “Extra Witchy” delivers a deep, vampy red that embodies Halloween mystique. The pigmentation is impressive, especially for a drugstore product. The color intensity builds well, allowing for anything from a subtle tint to a bold, dramatic lip. The shade particularly complements gothic or dark-themed Halloween costumes while remaining wearable for everyday fall looks.
APPLICATION & FEEL
Application feels like using a marker on your lips—smooth and controlled. The formula goes on wet but dries quickly to a slightly tacky finish that isn’t uncomfortable. Some users report:
“It smells like nothing, doesn’t go on thick, but does dry a bit sticky. It’s a smooth finish though, once you let it dry and apply a little gloss, which does not make it budge.”
For best results, exfoliate lips beforehand, as the formula tends to cling to dry patches. The Halloween edition seems particularly well-formulated for creating ombre effects or “bitten” lip looks that complement spooky costumes.
LONGEVITY & TRANSFER RESISTANCE
This is where opinions diverge. The Halloween edition claims to be transfer-proof, but real-world performance varies:
Positive experiences:
- “This pen is highly pigmented…once you let it dry and apply a little gloss, which does not make it budge.”
- “No feathering, and it stays put for quite awhile as long as you don’t eat a bunch of greasy food.”
Negative experiences:
- “It’s doesn’t [outlast]. I kept reapplying and it smudged and smeared with drinking and smooching.”
- “Definitely does NOT stain. And it was kinda sticky.”
For Halloween parties involving food, drinks, or costume masks, you’ll likely need touch-ups throughout the night. The darker “Extra Witchy” shade does have better staying power than lighter colors in the same line, making it a practical choice for extended wear during Halloween events.
HALLOWEEN-SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE
What makes “Extra Witchy” stand out for Halloween specifically:
- Spooky Aesthetics: The deep, vampy shade creates an authentically eerie look that complements costumes.
- Versatility for Character Makeup: The precision tip allows for creating special effects like blood drips at the corners of the mouth, vampire bites, or exaggerated gothic lip shapes.
- Layering Capability: Works well under clear gloss for a “freshly bitten” look or as a base for more elaborate Halloween lip art.
- Collectibility: The limited edition packaging adds appeal for makeup enthusiasts who collect seasonal products.
COMPARISON TO OTHER HALLOWEEN LIP PRODUCTS
Unlike many Halloween lip products that focus solely on unusual colors not wearable beyond October 31st, “Extra Witchy” offers a shade that transitions well into general fall wear. It’s less gimmicky than competitors that rely on color-changing formulas or novelty packaging but don’t deliver on performance.
VALUE PROPOSITION
At its drugstore price point, this limited edition offers good value for Halloween makeup enthusiasts. One user noted: “Price wasn’t horrible for just a wearable lipstick.” The collectible Halloween packaging adds value beyond the formula itself, making it an affordable way to update your makeup collection for the season.
PROS & CONS
Pros:
- Halloween-appropriate deep, vampy shade
- Precision applicator for detailed costume makeup
- No discernible scent
- Affordable limited edition collector’s item
- Versatile for both costume and everyday fall looks
Cons:
- Inconsistent longevity
- Can feel slightly sticky
- May highlight dry patches on lips
- Requires careful application technique to avoid patchiness
FINAL VERDICT
Covergirl’s Outlast “Extra Witchy” Lipstain Halloween Limited Edition earns 3.5/5 stars. While it doesn’t fully deliver on its long-lasting claims, its intense pigmentation, precision applicator, and Halloween-perfect shade make it a worthwhile seasonal purchase. It’s particularly well-suited for Halloween parties where you want a dramatic lip look that complements costumes without the heaviness of traditional lipstick.
This is an accessible, affordable way to achieve a spooky seasonal look from a trusted drugstore brand. Just keep it in your costume pocket for occasional touch-ups throughout your Halloween festivities.
Based on user feedback and professional testing. Individual results may vary depending on application technique and personal habits.
Buy on Amazon: Here
