Hey there, beauty lovers! Today I’m diving into a product that’s been flying under the radar but deserves WAY more attention – the Covergirl Outlast All-Day Ultimate Finish Foundation in Creamy Natural (#420). Let me tell you, this isn’t just another foundation review – this is about a product that countless women have been quietly loyal to for DECADES!
First Impressions & Packaging
Let’s start with the basics – this foundation comes in a classic compact design, which means NO MESSY SPILLS like you get with liquid foundations! The compact is pretty standard Covergirl fare – nothing fancy, but totally functional. Each compact includes a sponge applicator, making it super convenient for on-the-go touch-ups.
One slight issue some users mentioned – there was a report of receiving a compact where the fold-down top had been attached upside down, making it impossible to close properly or carry in a purse. But this seems to be a rare manufacturing defect rather than a common problem.
Price Point – VALUE ALERT!
Let’s talk money! This foundation typically retails for around $7 at most drugstores – an absolute STEAL compared to high-end brands offering similar formulations. Many reviewers noted buying them in packs of two for convenience, and some found even better deals on Amazon. Just be careful with online purchases – one reviewer mentioned feeling ripped off when they paid $12 for a single compact, thinking it was a 2-pack.
The consensus? This is a drugstore gem that performs like a much more expensive product!
Formula & Texture
What makes this foundation stand out is its unique cream-based formula. It’s not quite a liquid and not quite a powder – it sits somewhere perfectly in between!
The texture is described as “creamy yet solid” by longtime users. Unlike liquid foundations that can feel drying once applied, or powders that look flat and lifeless, this cream foundation offers something different. It feels substantial in the compact but applies with a lightweight finish that most users LOVE.
One review particularly stuck with me – a former MAC makeup artist compared it to MAC’s much pricier Studio Tech foundation! That’s some serious professional endorsement!
Application – SUPER User-Friendly!
Application couldn’t be simpler. The most recommended technique is to:
- Lightly dab the sponge applicator into the creamy foundation
- Gently tap and blend over areas needing coverage
- Build up layers if needed for problem areas
No brushes required, no beauty blender needed – just you and the included sponge. This makes it perfect for makeup beginners or those of us who don’t have time for a complicated routine!
Coverage & Finish
This is where this foundation really SHINES (but not literally – the finish isn’t shiny!). Reviewers consistently praise its ability to provide natural-looking coverage that doesn’t look “cakey” or obvious.
The coverage is described as buildable – you can go from light to medium coverage depending on your needs. It’s particularly good at:
- Evening out skin tone
- Hiding shadows under eyes
- Concealing blotchiness
- Dulling shininess
The finish is described as natural – not matte, not dewy, just healthy-looking skin. One reviewer put it perfectly: “doesn’t shine or rub off…isn’t flat like a mat finish…face looks moist and healthy.”
Longevity – Does “Outlast” Live Up To Its Name?
While not every review specifically mentioned staying power, the “Outlast” in the name does seem appropriate based on user experiences. The foundation appears to hold up reasonably well throughout the day without significant touchups.
However, one reviewer did mention becoming oily by mid-day, which suggests it might not control oil for a full day for those with very oily skin types.
Skin Types – Who Is It Best For?
This is where the reviews get REALLY interesting! This foundation seems to have found a special place in the hearts of women with mature or dry skin. Multiple reviewers specifically mentioned being older women with extremely dry skin who find this cream-based formula perfect for their needs.
As one reviewer explained, liquid foundations can go on “dry” and become stationary, which isn’t ideal for dry or mature skin. The cream formula of this Covergirl foundation addresses that issue perfectly.
That said, this foundation isn’t necessarily limited to mature skin. Several reviewers mentioned using it since they were teenagers and continuing into their 30s and beyond! The difference seems to be in how much powder you pair with it:
- For younger/oilier skin: Consider setting with powder
- For mature/dry skin: Use alone for a natural, non-drying finish
Shade Range – Focused on Creamy Natural (#420)
While the reviews focused specifically on the Creamy Natural shade (#420), there were some insights about color matching. This shade appears to work well for light to light-medium skin tones, especially those with neutral undertones.
One reviewer mentioned it was perfect for their “winter skin” when they don’t have much of a tan, suggesting it’s on the lighter end of the spectrum.
Another reviewer initially worried the shade would be too dark but found it matched well and was “true to the description online.”
Skin Sensitivity & Breakouts
The reviews were somewhat mixed regarding how this foundation interacts with acne-prone skin. Most users didn’t report any issues, with one specifically noting that the foundation “cleans easily at night, so skin is not clogged.”
However, one less favorable review mentioned that because the product lasts a long time, “bacteria builds up and will break me out by the time I get through with it.” This suggests that proper hygiene with the sponge applicator might be important for those with acne-prone skin.
The LOYAL Following – A Foundation With History!
What impressed me most about this foundation is the INCREDIBLE loyalty it inspires! Review after review mentioned using this product for YEARS – even DECADES:
- “Same as I’ve worn for years.”
- “I accidentally picked this product up 15 years ago…”
- “…tried on a whim when I was a teenager, and it’s been my foundation of choice ever since. I am now going on 31 years old…”
- “I’ve used this product for ten years…”
- “I’ve probably used it for 25 yrs and never found anything else…”
This kind of long-term commitment to a beauty product is RARE and speaks volumes about its consistent performance!
Availability Concerns
One recurring theme in the reviews was concern about the product’s availability. Multiple reviewers mentioned having trouble finding it in stores:
- “I hope this particular brand and color, CoverGirl #420 Creamy Natural, does not go by the wayside as I’m noticing fewer and fewer places in which to get it.”
- “My local rite aide stopped selling it, so here I am in Amazon…”
- “Love this have been using this for years and glad you are selling it because it hard to find hope you keep on selling it!”
- “Can’t always find it so glad to find on Amazon.”
This suggests that while the product maintains a dedicated following, it might not be as prominently featured in stores as newer foundation releases.
Pros and Cons Summary
What Reviewers LOVED:
- Natural-looking coverage that doesn’t look “fake”
- Lightweight feel on the skin
- Easy application with included sponge
- Affordable price point
- Great for mature or dry skin
- Compact design prevents spills
- Long-lasting formula
- Non-clogging for most users
Some Complaints:
- Occasionally difficult to find in stores
- One user found it drying and cakey
- Potential for bacteria buildup in long-lasting product
- Limited shade information (focused mostly on #420)
- Rare packaging defects
Final Thoughts – Is It Worth Trying?
Based on the overwhelmingly positive reviews spanning DECADES of use, this foundation seems to be a hidden gem in the drugstore makeup aisle. It’s particularly well-suited for:
- Those with dry or mature skin
- Anyone seeking natural-looking coverage
- People who prefer cream formulas over liquids or powders
- Makeup users who value simplicity and ease of application
- Budget-conscious beauty lovers who don’t want to sacrifice quality
If you’re struggling to find a foundation that doesn’t look cakey, doesn’t emphasize dry patches, and gives your skin a healthy appearance without looking made-up, this longtime staple from Covergirl is DEFINITELY worth trying!
The fact that former professional makeup artists and decades-long loyal users continue to choose this affordable option over higher-end alternatives speaks volumes. Sometimes the best products aren’t the newest or trendiest – they’re the reliable standbys that quietly deliver results year after year!
Have you tried the Covergirl Outlast All-Day Ultimate Finish Foundation? I’d love to hear YOUR experiences with this longtime beauty favorite!
Buy on Amazon: Here
