In the ever-evolving world of beauty products, finding reliable, effective, and affordable staples can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Today, I’m taking a deep dive into one such product that has quietly built a cult following over the years: the COVERGIRL Outlast All Day Top Coat.
Product Overview
The COVERGIRL Outlast All Day Top Coat is a clear lip product that comes in a traditional lipstick tube format. It’s designed primarily as a companion to long-lasting lip colors, particularly those from COVERGIRL’s own Outlast line, but as we’ll see, its versatility extends far beyond this single purpose.
Originally sold as part of a duo with COVERGIRL’s long-lasting lip colors, this top coat has earned its place as a standalone product. Many users report running out of the top coat long before finishing the matching lip color, which speaks to both its effectiveness and the frequency with which it needs to be applied.
Packaging and Presentation
The top coat comes in a traditional twist-up lipstick tube with COVERGIRL’s signature black band. It’s worth noting that the packaging appears to have gone through some changes over time, with some users noting differences between newer and older versions. The current packaging features a black band with the COVERGIRL logo, though some older versions had a silver band.
The tube is standard size for a lipstick product, though some users wish it came in a shorter tube option for easier pocket storage. The product itself has a clear appearance and applies smoothly without any noticeable color.
Performance and Effectiveness
Moisture Factor
One of the most consistently praised aspects of this top coat is its moisturizing properties. Many users specifically mention purchasing this product to combat the dryness associated with long-wearing lip products. The formula provides immediate relief to dry lips and creates a comfortable barrier that helps prevent further dehydration.
Several reviewers note that this top coat has replaced their regular lip balm, with one user even crediting it with helping them “kick [their] chapstick habit.” The moisturizing effect is described as lasting anywhere from 10 minutes to several hours, with most users reapplying throughout the day as needed.
Texture and Finish
The COVERGIRL top coat receives high marks for its texture, which is frequently described as “silky,” “smooth,” and “non-sticky.” This stands in contrast to many liquid lip glosses that can feel heavy or tacky on the lips.
The finish is another point of differentiation. While it provides a noticeable shine when first applied, it’s not an intense, mirror-like gloss. Several users describe it as having a “satin sheen” that looks natural and flattering. The shine tends to absorb into the lips over time, leaving behind the moisturizing benefits without the high-gloss appearance.
For those seeking a subtle enhancement rather than a dramatic gloss effect, this more moderate shine level is a significant selling point. As one reviewer put it, “If you like shine, this is NOT for you. The shine is there at the beginning but soaks in and just looks like lipstick an hour or so later.”
Longevity and Wear
When it comes to longevity, experiences vary. The product is marketed as “All Day,” but most users report needing to reapply it several times throughout the day, particularly after eating or drinking. This is fairly standard for any lip product, and many users don’t consider this a negative, especially given the affordable price point.
Where the top coat truly excels is in its role as a protector for long-lasting lip colors. Users report that regular application of the top coat helps their lip color last longer and wear more evenly. One enthusiastic reviewer claims that when used with long-wearing lipsticks, “it will last 100x longer if you use this as a top coat. Magic*”
Versatility
Though designed as a companion to COVERGIRL’s Outlast lip colors, a significant number of reviewers use this top coat with other brands’ long-lasting formulas. It works particularly well with matte formulations, helping to soften the dry, flat appearance that can make matte lips look aged or dehydrated.
Users mention successfully pairing it with brands like Maybelline Super Stay, Wonderskin lip stain, Lipsense, Revlon ColorStay, and various other long-wearing formulas. This versatility makes it a valuable addition to any makeup collection, regardless of brand loyalty.
Beyond its use with long-wearing lip products, many users employ this top coat as:
- A standalone lip balm
- A glossy topper for regular lipsticks
- A base layer under matte formulas
- A remedy for dry, chapped lips
This multi-functionality adds significant value to an already affordable product.
Scent and Taste
Several users mention the top coat having a pleasant scent, with one nostalgic reviewer specifically noting that it “smells like cotton candy.” This subtle fragrance seems to be a positive feature for most, though it’s not mentioned frequently enough to be considered a primary selling point.
Importantly, the product doesn’t have a noticeable taste, which is crucial for a product that will inevitably be ingested in small amounts throughout the day.
Value and Accessibility
The COVERGIRL Outlast All Day Top Coat is universally praised for its affordability. As one reviewer put it, “All women can afford this product and it lasts a long time!” This accessibility is particularly appealing given that it performs functions similar to much more expensive products from high-end brands.
The value proposition is further enhanced by the product’s longevity. While users do report needing to reapply throughout the day, many note that a single tube lasts for months of regular use. The twist-up format also ensures that product isn’t wasted, unlike some doe-foot applicator glosses that can dry out or become unsanitary over time.
Consumer Experiences
The reviews reveal several common usage patterns and experiences:
The Lipstick Extender
Many users purchased this product specifically because they ran out of the top coat that came with their COVERGIRL Outlast lip color. They consistently report that the top coat is depleted long before the color component and appreciate being able to purchase it separately.
The Brand Hopper
A significant number of reviewers use this top coat with long-lasting lip products from other brands. These users appreciate the versatility of the product and often report that it works better than the companion products offered by those brands.
The Nostalgia Seeker
Some reviewers have a long history with this product, having used it since their teenage years. These users often express strong brand loyalty and excitement about finding the product available for purchase online.
The Problem Solver
Many reviewers came to this product seeking a solution for dry, uncomfortable lips caused by long-wearing lip products. These users typically report high satisfaction with the moisturizing properties of the top coat.
Potential Drawbacks
While the majority of reviews are positive, there are some commonly mentioned drawbacks:
Consistency Issues
Some users report that the product can melt in warm weather, making it difficult to apply. This seems to be a particular issue during shipping in hot months.
Formula Changes
A few long-time users believe the formula has changed over time, becoming “mushier” or less firm than previous versions. This may be related to the consistency issues mentioned above.
Limited Effectiveness with Regular Lipsticks
While the top coat works well with long-lasting formulas, some users report that it doesn’t significantly extend the wear time of regular lipsticks. This is to be expected, as the product is specifically designed to work with special long-wearing formulas.
Packaging Concerns
A small number of reviewers expressed concerns about receiving counterfeit products, noting differences in packaging and product consistency compared to what they purchased in stores. This appears to be an isolated issue and may be related to specific sellers rather than the product itself.
Comparison to Similar Products
Several reviewers directly compare this top coat to other brands’ offerings. It’s frequently mentioned as a more affordable alternative to Lipsense’s Glossy Gloss, with one reviewer explicitly calling it a “dupe” for the more expensive product.
Others note that it performs better than the companion products offered with other brands’ long-lasting lip colors, particularly in terms of texture and moisture.
Who Should Consider This Product?
Based on the collective feedback, this product is particularly well-suited for:
- Users of long-lasting lip colors seeking to combat dryness
- Those looking for a non-sticky, moderately glossy lip topper
- Anyone in need of an affordable, versatile lip product
- People who prefer a traditional lipstick format over liquid lip gloss
Final Verdict
The COVERGIRL Outlast All Day Top Coat has earned its place as a beauty staple through its versatility, effectiveness, and affordability. While it may not truly last “all day” without reapplication, its ability to extend the wear of long-lasting lip colors while providing moisture and comfort makes it a valuable addition to any makeup collection.
For the price point, it offers exceptional value, particularly when compared to similar products from higher-end brands. Its traditional lipstick format makes it easy to apply and carry, and its ability to work with various brands’ long-lasting formulas adds to its utility.
The nostalgic enthusiasm of long-time users speaks to the product’s consistent quality over the years, even as makeup trends have come and gone. In a beauty industry that’s constantly chasing the next big innovation, there’s something to be said for a product that simply does what it promises, does it well, and does it at a price point accessible to all.
Whether you’re a dedicated user of long-lasting lip colors seeking relief from dryness, someone looking to extend the wear of your favorite lipstick, or simply in need of a reliable, non-sticky lip gloss, the COVERGIRL Outlast All Day Top Coat deserves a place in your makeup bag. It’s a reminder that sometimes, the most impressive beauty products aren’t the ones with the most buzz, but the ones that quietly solve everyday problems and earn their place in our daily routines.
Buy on Amazon: Here
