Hey there, beauty lovers! Today I’m diving into an honest review of the “Covergirl Outlast All-day Moisturizing Lip Color” in the shade “Ever Reddy,” which comes in a convenient pack of 4. After testing this product thoroughly and gathering feedback from numerous users, I’m ready to share the REAL tea on whether this lipstick lives up to its claims!
First Impressions & Packaging
Let’s start with the basics. The Covergirl Outlast comes in a dual-ended package – one end has the liquid lip color with a doe-foot applicator, and the other end contains a clear moisturizing balm. This two-step system is designed to give you both color longevity AND comfort. Smart concept, but does it deliver?
The packaging is pretty standard for drugstore products – nothing fancy, but functional. The pack of 4 is actually a great value if you end up loving the product!
Application Experience
The application process is straightforward but requires a bit of technique:
- Apply the liquid color to clean, dry lips
- Allow it to dry completely (about 60 seconds)
- Apply the clear moisturizing balm on top
The liquid formula goes on smoothly and the doe-foot applicator makes it easy to outline your lips with precision. BUT – and this is important – you need to work FAST! This formula starts setting quickly, and if you make a mistake, it’s not easy to fix without starting over.
The Color – Ever Reddy
Ever Reddy is a GORGEOUS classic red shade with slightly cool undertones that seems to work well for most skin tones. It’s vibrant without being too loud, making it appropriate for both everyday wear and special occasions. If you’ve been searching for the perfect red lipstick, this might be your holy grail!
Staying Power – The REAL MVP
This is where the Covergirl Outlast truly shines! Let me tell you – this lipstick is NOT playing around when it comes to longevity. Based on my experience and user feedback:
- It genuinely lasts 12-16 hours without significant fading
- Survives coffee, water, and even full meals with minimal transfer
- Doesn’t smudge or feather throughout the day
- Doesn’t transfer onto masks (a huge plus in recent years!)
- Stays put during kisses (your significant other will thank you!)
One user mentioned wearing red lipstick daily for over 30 YEARS and calls this the best non-smudge option they’ve found. That’s a serious endorsement!
Comfort & Moisture
Here’s where things get a bit complicated. The liquid color itself is definitely drying – there’s no getting around that. However, the clear balm on top helps tremendously with comfort.
What’s interesting is that several users noted that despite the initial dryness, their lips didn’t crack or peel with regular use. One user specifically mentioned that it seems to “seal the moisture in,” which is an interesting benefit!
The moisture balance seems to be:
- Initial application: Dry before balm
- After balm: Comfortable but not “moisturizing” per se
- Long-term: May actually help prevent peeling and cracking
You’ll likely need to reapply the clear balm throughout the day, but that’s easy enough to do and doesn’t disturb the color underneath.
Removal Process
Despite its incredible staying power, users report that removal is surprisingly easy with the right technique. Simply apply some chapstick or lip balm over the color, let it sit for a minute, then wipe off. No need for harsh makeup removers or excessive rubbing that can irritate your lips!
The Cons – Let’s Keep It Real
Nothing’s perfect, so let’s talk about the downsides:
- Potential for cakey buildup: Some users reported that reapplication can cause product buildup, leading to a cakey, dry appearance. This seems to be more of an issue if you’re trying to reapply the color without proper removal first.
- Drying formula: While the balm helps, this is still a drying formula compared to traditional lipsticks. If you have EXTREMELY dry or sensitive lips, you might find it uncomfortable.
- Learning curve: There’s definitely a technique to applying this product correctly. Expect a few trial runs before you master it.
- Product longevity: One tube lasts about a year with constant use, which is decent but not exceptional.
Value for Money
At around $10-12 per tube, this isn’t the cheapest drugstore lipstick, but considering its performance, it’s an excellent value. The pack of 4 makes it even more economical if you’re a devotee of the Ever Reddy shade.
Given that many high-end long-wear lipsticks sell for $20-30+ and don’t necessarily perform better, Covergirl Outlast is a solid investment for your makeup bag.
Who Should Buy This?
This lipstick is PERFECT for:
- People who need genuinely long-wearing color
- Those who are tired of lipstick transfer onto cups, masks, or loved ones
- Fans of classic red lips who don’t want to constantly reapply
- Busy individuals who don’t have time for frequent touch-ups
- Anyone who kisses their significant other often (seriously, multiple users mentioned this!)
Who Should Skip It?
You might want to pass if:
- Your lips are extremely dry or sensitive
- You prefer a one-step application process
- You change your lip color multiple times throughout the day
- You’re looking for a deeply moisturizing lip product
Final Verdict
Covergirl Outlast All-day Moisturizing Lip Color in Ever Reddy is a STANDOUT product in the drugstore lipstick category. It delivers exceptional staying power, beautiful color payoff, and reasonable comfort when used correctly. While it’s not without flaws, the pros significantly outweigh the cons for most users.
Is it the most luxurious, most comfortable lipstick on the market? No. But is it the best long-wearing option at this price point? According to many dedicated users – absolutely YES!
If you’re tired of lipstick that disappears after your morning coffee or transfers onto everything your lips touch, this product deserves a spot in your makeup collection. The pack of 4 ensures you’ll have your perfect red shade ready whenever you need it!
Remember to apply the balm regularly for best results, and enjoy hours of vibrant, transfer-resistant color. Your lips (and anyone you kiss) will thank you!
Rating: 4.5/5 stars – An impressive, reliable performer that delivers on its promises!
Buy on Amazon: Here
