Hey everyone! So I’ve been using the COVERGIRL Outlast All-day Moisturizing Lip Color Set in “Always Rosy” for a while now, and I NEED to share my thoughts with you all. This is actually a pack of 2 sets, so you get two color tubes and two clear gloss tubes. Let me break down everything about this product – the good, the bad, and the stuff nobody tells you!
First Impressions
When I first got my hands on this lip color, I was pretty excited. The packaging is simple – nothing fancy, but it gets the job done. Each set comes with the color itself and a clear gloss tube. The “Always Rosy” shade looks like a light pink in the tube, which seemed promising for everyday wear.
One thing I noticed right away – this isn’t your regular lipstick. It’s more of a stain/color combo that comes with a separate moisturizing top coat. This two-step system is what COVERGIRL claims makes it last “all day.”
Application Experience
OK SO HERE’S THE DEAL – you HAVE to be careful when applying this stuff! I learned this the hard way, trust me. The color applies wet and then dries down completely, so if you make a mistake, you’re pretty much stuck with it all day.
I found that using a lip liner first helps create cleaner edges. Then I apply a thin layer of the color and wait for it to dry completely before adding the clear gloss. The applicator is decent – not amazing, but it gets the job done if you’re careful.
The color dries FAST, which is both good and bad. Good because you can move on with your routine quickly, bad because if you mess up, there’s little time to fix it. I’ve found that having a cotton swab ready for quick clean-up around the edges helps a ton.
The Color – “Always Rosy”
For those with fair skin like me, this shade is PERFECT! It really does look like your natural lip color but slightly enhanced. It’s a lovely light pink that has just enough color to look polished without being overpowering. I’d describe it as a “my lips but better” shade that works for both office settings and casual outings.
What’s interesting is how this shade seems to adapt slightly to your natural lip color. On my friend with medium skin, it looked a bit different but still flattering. If you have very dark skin, I’m not sure this particular shade would show up well, though.
Staying Power – Does It REALLY Last All Day?
This is where this product truly SHINES! Once this stuff sets, it is NOT coming off easily. I can put it on at 7am, eat breakfast, drink my coffee, have lunch, and the color is still going strong by dinner time. I might need to reapply the clear gloss 2-3 times throughout the day, but the actual color stays put.
The best part? It doesn’t leave marks on coffee cups, straws, or your significant other’s cheek. That alone makes it worth trying!
But here’s my warning – this staying power works BOTH ways. If you accidentally get this on your clothes, it WILL stain them. I learned this lesson when I was rushing one morning and got a smudge on my white blouse collar. That stain never completely came out, so be careful during application!
Comfort and Feel
Let’s be honest – this is NOT the most comfortable lip product I’ve ever worn. The color itself can feel quite dry once it sets. That’s where the clear gloss comes in – it’s ESSENTIAL, not optional.
When I first apply the clear gloss over the color, my lips feel moisturized and comfortable. But after a couple of hours, that feeling fades and I need to reapply the gloss. Without the gloss, my lips start to feel tight and a bit dry.
By the end of the day, I can definitely tell I’m wearing something on my lips. If you have naturally dry lips to begin with, you might find this product a bit uncomfortable after long wear. I’ve started applying a heavy-duty lip balm before bed on days I wear this lipstick, and that seems to help counteract any drying effects.
The Gloss Component
The clear gloss that comes with this lip color deserves its own section because it’s CRUCIAL to the whole experience. It adds shine, comfort, and helps the color look fresh throughout the day.
The gloss isn’t sticky at all, which I appreciate. It feels more like a light balm than a typical sticky lip gloss. It doesn’t have much of a scent, which is nice for those sensitive to fragrances.
I find myself reapplying the gloss about 2-3 times during a typical day. The small tube is easy to carry in even my smallest purse, so touchups are convenient. Without the gloss, the lip color can start to look a bit flat and feel uncomfortable.
Removal Process – The Struggle Is REAL!
OMG, getting this stuff off at the end of the day is a CHALLENGE! Regular makeup wipes barely make a dent. I’ve found that an oil-based makeup remover works best – I massage it into my lips for a good 30 seconds before wiping away.
Even with proper makeup remover, I sometimes find traces of color the next morning. This is both impressive and slightly annoying. If you’re someone who’s inconsistent with removing makeup before bed (no judgment!), you might wake up with still-tinted lips!
Value for Money
Each pack comes with 2 complete sets (2 color tubes and 2 gloss tubes), which I think offers decent value. The color lasts so long on your lips that a single tube lasts me about 3-4 months of regular use. The gloss tends to run out faster than the color, so having extras is helpful.
Compared to high-end long-wear lip products, this is MUCH more affordable while offering similar or even better staying power. If longevity is your primary concern, this is definitely worth the price.
Consistency Between Purchases
I’ve noticed something that other reviewers mentioned too – there seems to be some inconsistency between purchases. Sometimes the product seems to be older or slightly different in texture. When this happens, the color can feel cakey and less pleasant to wear.
I’ve also encountered the issue of receiving the wrong shade despite the packaging saying “Always Rosy.” This has happened a couple of times when ordering online, which is frustrating when you know exactly which shade works for you.
Another thing I’ve noticed is that sometimes one of the lipsticks in the two-pack seems to have less product than expected. It’s like it’s been partially used or not filled completely, which affects the value.
Pro Tips From My Experience
If you decide to try this lip color, here are some tips I’ve learned:
- Exfoliate your lips BEFORE application – any dry flakes will be highlighted by this formula
- Apply a thin layer – less is more with this product
- DON’T rub your lips together after applying the color (before it dries) or it will look patchy
- Wait until the color is COMPLETELY dry before applying the gloss
- When eating, blot your lips with a napkin instead of rubbing
- Keep an oil-based makeup remover handy for when you want to take it off
- Apply a super hydrating lip mask at night to combat any dryness
Who Should Buy This?
This lip color is PERFECT for:
- People who need their lip color to last through long days
- Those who hate constantly reapplying lipstick
- Anyone who eats, drinks, or talks a lot during their day
- People who prefer a natural-looking lip color
- Those with fair to medium skin tones looking for a “my lips but better” shade
Who Should Skip It?
You might want to pass if:
- You have extremely dry or chapped lips
- You prefer to change your lip color throughout the day
- You don’t like the feeling of product on your lips
- You’re not willing to commit to a two-step process
- You’re looking for a bold, dramatic lip color
Final Thoughts
The COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Moisturizing Lip Color in “Always Rosy” is one of those products that delivers on its main promise – LONGEVITY – but comes with some trade-offs in comfort. It’s become my go-to for long workdays and special occasions where I don’t want to worry about touch-ups.
Is it the most comfortable lip product? No. But does it STAY PUT better than almost anything else I’ve tried? Absolutely!
If you’ve been searching for a truly long-lasting lip color that won’t break the bank, this is definitely worth trying. Just be prepared for the dry feeling and invest in a good makeup remover! 😉
Would I buy it again? YES! Despite its flaws, I haven’t found anything else at this price point that lasts as well. Just remember – apply carefully, keep that gloss handy, and enjoy hours of worry-free color!
Buy on Amazon: Here
