Hey there makeup lovers! Today I’m diving deep into one of the most talked-about drugstore lip products on the market – COVERGIRL’s Outlast All-Day Moisturizing Lip Color in Pink Cashmere 564. After seeing so many mixed reviews, I had to try it myself and gather feedback from other users to give you the FULL picture of what you can expect.
First Impressions
Let’s talk about what you notice right out of the package. This is a two-step lip color system featuring a color base and a clear moisturizing top coat. The packaging is pretty standard for drugstore makeup – nothing fancy, but functional. The Pink Cashmere shade is advertised as a soft, wearable pink, but several reviewers (myself included) noticed it appears MUCH brighter on the lips than it looks in product images.
One reviewer described it perfectly: “Pink cashmere is more like bubble gum pink. Way brighter than the picture so beware!” This is important to note if you’re expecting a subtle, muted pink – you might be surprised by how vibrant it actually is!
Application Experience
The application process is where opinions really start to divide. When applied correctly (with a THIN layer), the color can go on smoothly. However, multiple users reported issues with texture:
“You have to be careful putting it on or it’s too thick and will later peal or clump or separate or some other odd thing.”
“Product does not glide on smoothly. It’s kind of ‘globby'”
I found that application technique matters A LOT with this product. If you apply too much product at once, you’re going to have problems later in the day. The key is using a very light hand and building up only if necessary. Consider using a lip brush for more precise application rather than applying straight from the tube.
The Big Question: Does It Really Last All Day?
This is where we see the biggest divide in user experiences. Some users are ABSOLUTE FANS of the staying power:
“I put it on of the mornings. It’s still on late at night.” “Lasts all day, no reapplying needed! Does not flake or transfer!” “It truly stays on all day. I haven’t used any other lipstick since I started using Outlast.”
But others had completely different experiences:
“This doesn’t stay on well at all! I used to be able to put my lipstick on and not touch it up all day.” “If you put it on thin it lasts for about half a day before it looks old and dried out.” “Doesn’t stay on while eating, drinking, kissing unless you reapply the cover coat after every bite/sip/kiss.”
After testing it myself and analyzing the reviews, here’s the truth: when applied correctly and in optimal conditions, this lip color can last 6-10 hours. But there are MAJOR factors that affect longevity:
- Lip preparation (exfoliation and moisturizing beforehand)
- Thickness of application (thinner is better)
- Frequency of top coat reapplication
- Eating oily foods (which break down the color faster)
- Product freshness (some reviewers received products that seemed old)
One long-time user mentioned: “I have used Cover Girl moisturizing lip color for many years and always enjoy the way it lasts throughout the day, and doesn’t come off. I do apply the colorless lip gloss that comes with it after eating, to keep moisture in!”
This points to an essential tip – the top coat is crucial for both comfort AND longevity.
Comfort & Moisture Factor
Almost every long-wearing lip product struggles with the moisture balance, and this one is no exception. User experiences vary widely:
“Really good lipstick definitely works better than traditional lip stick and doesn’t dry out your lips.”
But contrast that with:
“It is great lipstick but dries my lips out bad.” “With the ones that I have recently purchased, I have to constantly touch it up and the texture is horrible!! It is so tacky feeling and that never goes away.”
The consensus seems to be that the initial application will feel dry until you apply the top coat. The top coat provides temporary relief, but many users need to reapply it throughout the day. Some users have found alternative solutions:
“I sometimes use chapstick as the top layer rather than the top layer application that comes with the lip color.”
This hack seems to work well for many people who like the color and staying power but need extra moisture.
The Color: Pink Cashmere 564
Pink Cashmere is described as a medium pink, but reviewers have very different takes on the actual shade:
“It’s the perfect shade of pink.” “A bit too dark but does stay on most of the day.” “It’s a little too pink for me. Maybe in the spring it’ll be more fitting.” “This color is pinker than I expected.”
After seeing it in various lighting conditions, I’d describe Pink Cashmere as a medium-bright pink with slightly cool undertones. It’s definitely NOT a subtle nude-pink as some might expect from the name “cashmere.” Think more “pretty in pink” than “barely there.”
The color payoff is quite good, though some users noted it can be semi-opaque in certain applications: “the color was semi opaque, not solid on my lips.”
Quality Control Issues
A concerning theme in several reviews was inconsistency in product quality:
“The package was dirty and faded, not sealed, and the color portion was more than half empty. The contents looked dried out.”
“This product came with the tube half full and the product was thick and more dry than it should be.”
“There were 4 little black spots on my lips that had to wear off.”
These issues seem to be the exception rather than the rule, but they’re worth mentioning. Some reviewers specifically warned against certain sellers on Amazon, suggesting that in-store purchases might be more reliable for freshness.
Common Issues
Let’s talk about the most frequently mentioned problems:
- Flaking/Peeling: “Did not stay on flaked and chipped do not buy!” This happens most often when applied too thickly or when the top coat isn’t reapplied after eating.
- Clumping: “It becomes cakey and not smooth even when the extra moisturizing stick is applied over it.” This seems to happen more often as the product ages or if multiple layers are applied.
- Dryness: Many users find that despite the “moisturizing” claim, their lips feel dry after several hours.
- Color Availability: “My only complaint is that COVERGIRL changes product colors so often that when one finds a great color, it’s not there the next time around.” This is a frustration for many loyal users.
The Price Factor
At around $8-12 depending on where you purchase, this is definitely in the affordable drugstore range. Many reviewers felt the price point was appropriate:
“I feel it priced reasonably.” “Reasonably priced considering quality of product.”
Even users who weren’t completely satisfied often conceded that at this price point, they couldn’t expect perfection.
Comparison to Other Long-Wear Lipsticks
Several reviewers compared this to other long-wear options:
“Then I found Max Factor Lipfinity that was perfect with nice sophisticated colors and lasted all day. Too bad that Max does not make them any more.”
“I actually the Color Stay lipstick remains on longer, but I don’t like their companion gloss so I use the Covergirl top coat.”
This suggests that while the COVERGIRL Outlast is good, particularly at its price point, it might not be the absolute best in the long-wear category. The top coat, however, seems to be a standout component that some users pair with other brands’ color bases.
Who Should Buy This?
Based on all the reviews and my own experience, I’d recommend this product for:
- People who need lip color that lasts through meetings or events without constant touch-ups
- Those who don’t mind reapplying a clear top coat occasionally
- Makeup users on a budget who want long-wear without high-end prices
- Anyone who likes brighter pink shades (for this specific color)
It might NOT be ideal for:
- Those with very dry or sensitive lips
- People who dislike two-step lip products
- Anyone expecting a subtle, muted pink (from this specific shade)
- Those who eat oily foods frequently throughout the day
My Final Verdict
After weighing all the feedback and my own testing, I’m giving COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Moisturizing Lip Color in Pink Cashmere 564 a solid 3.5/5 stars.
The staying power IS impressive when used correctly, and the price point makes it accessible. However, the inconsistent quality control, potential for dryness, and application learning curve prevent it from being a perfect product.
My TOP TIPS for success with this product:
- Exfoliate lips before application
- Apply a VERY thin layer of color
- Wait 60 seconds before applying the top coat
- Carry the top coat with you for reapplication after eating
- Consider purchasing in-store to ensure product freshness
- Be prepared for a brighter pink than product images suggest
Have you tried this lip color? I’d love to hear about YOUR experience in the comments! Did it last all day for you? What application techniques worked best?
Quick Pros & Cons Summary
PROS:
- Long-lasting color (6+ hours for most users)
- Affordable price point
- Bright, vivid color
- Doesn’t transfer easily
- Top coat can be used with other lipsticks
CONS:
- Can be drying for some users
- Application technique has a learning curve
- May flake or peel if applied incorrectly
- Some quality control issues reported
- Color is brighter than expected
Remember, finding your perfect long-wear lipstick is a journey! What works for one person might not work for another, but I hope this detailed review helps you decide if COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Moisturizing Lip Color Pink Cashmere 564 deserves a spot in YOUR makeup bag!
Buy on Amazon: Here
