As a beauty expert with years of experience evaluating cosmetic products, I’ve had the opportunity to analyze the COVERGIRL Outlast All-day Moisturizing Lip Color Clear Top Coat in depth. This review combines my professional assessment with the collective experiences of numerous consumers who have incorporated this product into their daily beauty routines.
Product Overview
The COVERGIRL Outlast All-day Moisturizing Lip Color Clear Top Coat comes in a sleek, slender tube design and is sold as a stand-alone product or bundled with COVERGIRL’s Outlast lip colors. This clear gloss serves primarily as a moisturizing top coat designed to work with long-wearing lipsticks, particularly the COVERGIRL Outlast line, though many consumers have found additional uses for it.
Performance Analysis
Moisturizing Properties
The primary function of this top coat is to add moisture to lips while preserving the underlying color, and in this regard, it performs admirably. Numerous users report significant improvement in lip comfort when using this product over long-wearing lipsticks, which tend to have drying formulations. One particularly telling comment came from a user who experienced “severe dry cracked lips” and found relief “almost instantly” after application.
The moisturizing effect seems to be one of the product’s strongest attributes, with multiple consumers specifically purchasing it exclusively for its hydrating properties. Some even report using it around their eyes, though this is not a recommended application by the manufacturer.
Compatibility with Long-Wearing Lipsticks
This top coat truly shines when paired with long-wearing lip colors. Users consistently praise how it works seamlessly with COVERGIRL Outlast lipsticks, adding moisture “without causing the lipstick transfer or come off.” The synergy between the Outlast lipstick and this top coat creates what many describe as an unbeatable combination for extended wear. As one enthusiastic customer noted, even dental hygienists have remarked on the impressive staying power of this combination.
While designed specifically for COVERGIRL products, many consumers successfully use it with other brands’ longwearing formulas, including Revlon ColorStay and LipSense, reporting excellent results across the board.
Shine and Appearance
The product provides a subtle, sophisticated shine that enhances underlying lip colors. Users describe it as “a step above natural” rather than an intensely glossy finish. This makes it versatile enough for both professional environments and more glamorous occasions.
Several reviews mention that it helps “even out” lipstick application, particularly for those who apply multiple layers of color. This smoothing effect creates a more polished finished look that many appreciate.
Comfort and Texture
The texture consistently receives positive feedback, with users appreciating that it’s “not sticky” unlike many competitive lip glosses. This non-tacky formula makes it comfortable for all-day wear without the annoying hair-sticking-to-lips issue that plagues many gloss wearers.
The lightweight feel allows for comfortable wear, with one user comparing it to an “upscale chapstick” in a “fancy white container,” suggesting a premium experience despite its drugstore price point.
Scent and Taste
Reports on scent and taste vary slightly among users, but most describe it as having little to no fragrance or taste—a significant advantage for those sensitive to heavily scented products. A few users mention a light, pleasant smell, with one specific reference to a subtle “Koolaid” scent. The absence of a bitter taste, common in many lip products, was explicitly noted as a positive attribute.
Longevity
The longevity of the moisturizing effect receives mixed reviews. Some users report needing to “re-apply several times a day when my lips feel dry,” suggesting that the hydration doesn’t last as long as some might hope. Others mention having one in their purse and one in their makeup case for convenient reapplication throughout the day.
However, when used over the COVERGIRL Outlast lip colors, many users find that a single application at the start of the day sufficiently maintains moisture and shine, with perhaps one refresh after eating.
Packaging and Value
Tube Design
The product comes in a slim tube with a sponge-tip applicator. This design receives praise for its portability, with one user specifically mentioning that the “slim tube is preferred to fit in a pocket.” However, some users express surprise at the size, describing the tubes as “smaller than expected.”
Product Volume and Duration
A frequent criticism concerns how quickly the product is used up. Multiple reviews mention having to “purchase frequently” because the “tube dissolves rather quickly.” The consumption rate appears to be faster than the companion lip colors, with several users reporting they go through “more clear coat than the color, almost 2 to 1.”
One particularly detailed review stated that using the product “a couple of times a day” resulted in it lasting only “8 days,” suggesting that heavy users may find themselves repurchasing frequently.
Price-to-Value Ratio
Value assessments vary widely among users. Some describe it as “great value” compared to retail store prices, while others note that “it’s def not worth the $ anymore” due to price increases over time. The short duration of each tube factors significantly into these value calculations, with those who use it sparingly finding more satisfaction with the price point than daily, frequent appliers.
Versatility and Alternative Uses
While primarily marketed as a companion to COVERGIRL’s longwearing lip colors, consumers have found multiple uses for this product:
- Stand-alone lip gloss: Many use it independently as a clear gloss for a natural, moisturized look.
- Over matte lipsticks: Users often apply it over matte formulations from various brands to add shine without compromising color.
- Treatment for chapped lips: Several reviews mention successful use as a treatment for severely dry or chapped lips, with one user even convincing their husband to use it for this purpose.
- Alternative to chapstick: Some have replaced their regular lip balm with this product, finding it more effective for daily maintenance.
This versatility adds significant value, particularly for minimalists who prefer multi-purpose products in their beauty arsenal.
Availability Concerns
A recurring theme across numerous reviews involves difficulty finding the product in physical retail locations. Comments like “cannot find this item in stores” and “so hard to find in the stores but Amazon came through” suggest that online purchasing has become the primary acquisition method for many loyal users.
Some express concern that the product may be discontinued, given its increasingly limited retail presence. This anxiety has prompted stockpiling behavior among devoted users who fear losing access to their tried-and-true favorite.
Quality Control Issues
While most reviews reflect positive experiences, some customers report receiving defective products. The most common complaints involve melted product, particularly during summer shipping seasons. One user reported that both tubes in their order were “MELTED!” with one being “somewhat usable” while the other had “simply disappeared.”
Another concerning report mentioned opening a tube to find it “completely empty,” suggesting potential manufacturing or packaging inconsistencies.
Pros and Cons Summary
Pros:
- Exceptional moisturizing properties
- Works seamlessly with long-wearing lipsticks
- Non-sticky, comfortable texture
- Little to no taste or fragrance
- Subtle, sophisticated shine
- Portable, pocket-friendly packaging
- Versatile applications beyond its intended use
- Helps create an even, polished finish
Cons:
- Product is consumed relatively quickly
- Increasingly difficult to find in retail stores
- Some quality control issues with shipping in hot weather
- Moisturizing effect requires reapplication for some users
- Price increases have affected perceived value
- Smaller product volume than some expect
Who Should Consider This Product
This top coat is particularly well-suited for:
- Users of long-wearing lipsticks: Anyone who regularly wears 24-hour or transfer-resistant lip colors will benefit from this moisturizing companion product.
- Professionals who need all-day lip color: Those in customer-facing roles or who have limited opportunities to reapply makeup during their workday will appreciate the lasting comfort this provides when used over longwearing formulas.
- People with naturally dry lips: The effective moisturizing properties make this suitable even for those with chronically dry or sensitive lips.
- Minimalists seeking versatility: Those who prefer multi-purpose products will appreciate its functionality as both a gloss and treatment.
- Those who dislike sticky lip products: The non-tacky formula offers shine without the uncomfortable stickiness of many competitive products.
Who Should Look Elsewhere
This may not be ideal for:
- Those seeking intense shine: The subtle finish may disappoint users looking for dramatic, high-impact gloss.
- Budget-conscious consumers who apply frequently: Given how quickly some users go through the product, frequent appliers might find the cost-per-use ratio unsatisfactory.
- People who dislike frequent reapplication: Some users report needing to reapply multiple times throughout the day for optimal moisture.
The Verdict
The COVERGIRL Outlast All-day Moisturizing Lip Color Clear Top Coat has earned its loyal following for good reason. It effectively delivers on its primary promise: providing moisture and comfort to lips wearing long-lasting color formulas. The non-sticky texture, subtle shine, and minimal scent create a pleasant user experience that distinguishes it from many competitive products.
While concerns about product volume, longevity, and retail availability are valid, the performance advantages—particularly for users of transfer-resistant lip colors—generally outweigh these limitations. The versatility as both a treatment and cosmetic further enhances its value proposition.
For those who prioritize comfort without compromising color longevity, this top coat represents one of the more successful solutions in the mass-market beauty space. Its continued popularity despite availability challenges speaks to its effectiveness and the difficulty in finding comparable alternatives.
Rating: 4.2/5
The COVERGIRL Outlast All-day Moisturizing Lip Color Clear Top Coat earns 4.2 stars out of 5—losing points primarily for consumption rate and availability issues but scoring highly for performance, comfort, and versatility. For users of long-wearing lip colors, this remains a valuable addition to their makeup collection, providing the comfort and polish that makes extended wear not just possible but pleasant.
Buy on Amazon: Here
