Let me start by saying I’ve been in the beauty industry for YEARS, and I’ve seen products come and go. When I first got my hands on the COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color in Rose Pearl, I was honestly excited. The packaging is simple but functional – nothing fancy, just what you’d expect from COVERGIRL.
The product consists of two parts: the color itself and a clear topcoat that comes in a separate tube. This dual-system approach is supposed to give you both long-lasting color AND moisture. Does it deliver? Well, that’s what we’re here to talk about!
The Color – Rose Pearl
Let’s talk about this shade! Rose Pearl is a BEAUTIFUL rose shade that’s bright without being too in-your-face. It’s one of those versatile colors that works across different skin tones, and it’s particularly flattering for older women as it’s not harsh like some other bright shades can be.
However, I noticed from the reviews that there’s some inconsistency in the color. Some people mentioned receiving different shades despite ordering the same product number. One person specifically mentioned getting a more bubble-gum pink than expected, while another said it was more coral than anticipated. This inconsistency is definitely something to keep in mind.
The pigmentation is surprisingly strong – several users mentioned that the color is more saturated than they expected. If you’re looking for something subtle, this might not be it!
Application Experience
Applying this lip color is relatively straightforward. The color goes on smoothly according to most users, though some mentioned it can feel a bit thick or chalky. The key is to apply a thin, even layer and let it dry COMPLETELY before adding the topcoat.
One thing I noticed from the reviews is that application technique matters A LOT with this product. If you apply too much or don’t let it dry properly, you’re likely to experience bleeding past your lip line or a patchy appearance.
The Big Question: Does It Actually Last All Day?
This is where opinions are SERIOUSLY divided!
Some loyal users swear by this product’s staying power:
- “It stays on for long periods of time, even during eating and after.”
- “I put this on in the morning and at night take it off.”
- “Stays on about 14 hours with no reapply.”
- “This lipstick stays with you through ER all nights, 6 am-10 pm days, marathon shopping days and pool days.”
But others were deeply disappointed:
- “Goes on smooth but does NOT last even half a day.”
- “Now it stays on only for 2 hours.”
- “This does NOT stay on. As it comes off what’s left is an outline of lipstick.”
- “It does not last at all. And I bought it because it said it was long lasting.”
What’s fascinating is that some long-time users mentioned that the formula seems to have changed over the years. One person who had been using it for 25 years said: “This used to last truly all day… Year after year this product changed slowly. Now it stays on only for 2 hours.”
From my analysis, it seems like the staying power varies depending on:
- Your individual lips (chemistry, moisture level, etc.)
- Your activities (talking, eating, drinking)
- Possibly the batch or when it was manufactured
Most users agree that it does survive drinking water or coffee pretty well, but eating, especially greasy foods, will definitely affect its longevity.
The Moisturizing Topcoat
The topcoat is meant to add moisture and shine to your lips after applying the color. Many users find it helpful, but it’s clear that you need to reapply it throughout the day to maintain comfort.
Some observations about the topcoat:
- It helps prevent the dry feeling that many long-lasting lipsticks have
- It needs frequent reapplication
- Using other lip products over this color can ruin the formula’s effectiveness
One user mentioned: “You just have to keep applying the clear sealer to keep your lips moist and other clear products will ruin this. It is apparently formulated only to work with this sealer.”
Comfort and Feel
This is another area where experiences vary wildly. Some users find it comfortable and forget they’re wearing it, while others experience significant dryness:
The happy campers say:
- “I can’t feel it on my lips”
- “This lipstick stays on without drying out my lips”
- “Leaves the lips moisturized for a long time”
The not-so-happy campers report:
- “My lips felt so dry, even using the extra top coat”
- “Lips get a little dry, but clear lip container helps a bit”
- “It made my lips very dry and chapped”
- “Gorgeous colour but it dries my lips severely. Liked super crusty no matter how much I exfoliated and moisturized before.”
From reading all the reviews, it seems like the comfort level depends a lot on your natural lip moisture and how frequently you reapply the topcoat.
Transfer-Proof Performance
This is where the product truly SHINES according to most users. Even those who were dissatisfied with other aspects praised its transfer-resistant qualities:
- “It doesn’t transfer to drinks, grandbabies faces, etc.”
- “It doesn’t leave a mark on wine glasses”
- “If you kiss someone, it will not leave a mark!”
- “I’ve worn it through surgeries and nurses have asked me several times how I get my lipstick to stay on!”
One user even mentioned wearing it to the dentist: “I even wear it to the dentist and they are amazed that it does not rub off during dental procedures such as cleaning!”
Removal Process
While not everyone mentioned the removal process, those who did had strong opinions. This stuff does NOT come off easily, which is both a pro and a con:
Pro: It stays on when you want it to Con: It can be a challenge to remove
Some users mentioned:
- “The color stays, so much that even after using remover it was still there”
- “Got tired of ripping my lips off every time I had to take it off”
One helpful tip from a user: “You can use petroleum jelly to remove it. It’s much cheaper than buying the Cover Girl lip stick remover.”
Value for Money
The price point for this product is generally considered reasonable for what it offers. One user called it “very affordably priced,” especially compared to similar long-lasting formulas from other brands.
However, some longtime users felt that the amount of product in each tube seems to have decreased over time, affecting the value.
Wear Patterns
An interesting observation from multiple reviews is how this lipstick wears off. Several users noted that it tends to fade from the inner part of the lips first, creating what one person described as “a terrible look unless you left your lips shut together.”
Another mentioned: “As it comes off what’s left is an outline of lipstick,” which can create an unintended liner effect.
This wear pattern seems to be common with long-lasting lip products but is worth noting if you’re considering this one.
Special Considerations
Some specific situations where this product might be particularly useful:
- If you’re wearing a mask (one user specifically mentioned it stays on under masks)
- For special occasions where you don’t want to worry about reapplication
- For medical professionals or others who need to wear masks for long periods
- For people who hate having to check and reapply lipstick throughout the day
Comparison to Other Products
Some users compared this to other long-lasting lip products:
- One preferred Maybelline 24hr matte over this one
- Another preferred L’Oreal Infinity
- Several mentioned it was better than more expensive brands like LipSense
Availability Issues
A recurring theme in the reviews was difficulty finding this product, especially specific shades, in stores. Many users turned to online shopping specifically because they couldn’t find their preferred shade locally.
One user mentioned: “This color cannot be found in stores. Thank you for carrying it. I’ve set it up on subscribe and save.”
The Bottom Line
After analyzing all the reviews, it’s clear that the COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color in Rose Pearl is a product that people either LOVE or are disappointed by. It seems to work amazingly well for some users while failing to deliver for others.
The key factors that determine your experience appear to be:
- Your natural lip chemistry and moisture level
- Your expectations about what “all-day” means
- Your willingness to reapply the topcoat throughout the day
- Your tolerance for the removal process
For those who find it works for them, it becomes a holy grail product they use for YEARS. For others, it’s just another disappointing “long-lasting” lip color that doesn’t live up to its claims.
Would I Recommend It?
Based on the reviews, I would recommend this product IF:
- You’ve had good experiences with long-lasting lip colors before
- You don’t mind reapplying the topcoat throughout the day
- You’re looking for a truly transfer-proof option
- You’re willing to experiment with application techniques
I would NOT recommend it if:
- Your lips tend to be very dry naturally
- You expect it to last through multiple meals without touchups
- You want something that feels lightweight on the lips
- You’re looking for a subtle, sheer color
Final Thoughts
The COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color in Rose Pearl is a product that has inspired loyalty among many users, some for decades. While it’s not perfect and doesn’t work for everyone, it offers something that’s hard to find in the lipstick world: serious staying power without the designer price tag.
If you’re on the fence, it might be worth trying at least once – just make sure you have some petroleum jelly on hand for removal! And if you find a shade you love, you might want to stock up, as several users mentioned concerns about their favorite colors being discontinued.
Have you tried this product? I’d love to hear YOUR experiences with it!
Buy on Amazon: Here
