For those in search of a lip color that promises to last through meals, meetings, and everything in between, Covergirl’s Outlast All-Day Lip Color has been a staple in many makeup bags for years. Today, I’m focusing specifically on the shade “Coral Sunset” – a color that has garnered quite a following among makeup enthusiasts. As a beauty expert who has analyzed hundreds of consumer experiences with this product, I’ll break down everything you need to know before deciding if this two-step lip system deserves a place in your collection.
Product Overview
Covergirl Outlast All-Day Lip Color With Topcoat is a dual-ended lip product featuring a liquid lip color on one end and a clear moisturizing topcoat on the other. The concept is simple yet innovative: apply the liquid color, let it dry, then seal and hydrate with the clear balm. The shade “Coral Sunset” is described as a flattering, subtle coral that adds just a hint of color – making it versatile for various skin tones and occasions.
Color Analysis: Coral Sunset
The Coral Sunset shade has developed something of a cult following, with many users describing it as their go-to color for years. Based on consumer feedback, this particular hue offers:
- A subtle, flattering coral tone that’s not overpowering
- Versatility for everyday wear
- A brightness that complements summer looks particularly well
- Enough color to make a statement without being too bold
Several long-time users mentioned they specifically seek out this shade, with one reviewer noting they’ve been loyal to it for over ten years. This suggests the color has an enduring appeal that transcends changing makeup trends.
Longevity Performance
The most frequently cited benefit of this product is its impressive staying power. Numerous users confirm that it lives up to its “All-Day” promise, with specific mentions of:
- Lasting through entire workdays
- Remaining intact through meals and drinks
- Not transferring to cups, glasses, or napkins
- Some users even report finding color still on their lips the next morning
One particular reviewer who had previously had her lips tattooed (which faded over 30 years) claimed this was the best lip stain she had found since. However, experiences do vary, with a smaller number of users reporting that the product only lasted for a few hours or came off with their first cup of coffee.
The consensus appears to be that when applied correctly (allowing the color to dry completely before adding the topcoat), most users can expect 6-8 hours of wear before needing to touch up.
Application Experience
The application process for this two-step system requires a specific technique for optimal results:
- Apply the liquid color to clean, dry lips
- Wait several seconds (many successful users emphasized this waiting period as crucial)
- Apply the clear topcoat for moisture and shine
Users who followed this protocol generally reported better results than those who rushed the process. The precision applicator for the liquid color was noted to provide good control over placement, allowing users to define their lip line accurately.
Comfort and Feel
The comfort factor of this product receives mixed reviews, with opinions largely divided based on individual lip conditions and application technique:
Positive Experiences:
- Many long-term users find the formula comfortable for all-day wear
- The topcoat provides adequate moisture throughout the day when reapplied as needed
- Users appreciate not having to worry about the color throughout the day
Negative Experiences:
- Some users report the formula can be drying, leading to flaking or cracking
- A few mentioned a sticky feeling that persisted even after application of the topcoat
- The liquid color alone was universally acknowledged as needing the topcoat for comfort
Those with naturally dry lips seem more likely to experience discomfort, with several mentioning that while they loved the color and longevity, they needed to apply the topcoat frequently throughout the day to maintain comfort.
Formula Evolution
Several long-term users noted that the formula has improved over the years. Specific improvements mentioned include:
- Less caking compared to earlier versions
- Better resistance to drying out lips
- Smoother application
- More consistent color payoff
This suggests Covergirl has been actively refining the formula to address consumer feedback, which speaks positively to the brand’s commitment to product quality.
Value Assessment
When evaluating the value proposition of this product, several factors emerge:
Positive Value Factors:
- The longevity means less frequent application and potentially slower product consumption
- The dual-ended design provides both color and moisture in one product
- The price point is reasonable for a long-wearing formula
Negative Value Factors:
- Some users reported getting less product in newer purchases compared to years ago
- A few mentioned running out of the lip color while still having plenty of the topcoat remaining
- The need to replace the entire unit when only one component is depleted
Overall, most loyal users found the value acceptable given the performance, though there were concerns about potentially decreasing product amounts in newer packaging.
Availability Challenges
A recurring theme in customer feedback was difficulty finding this specific shade in physical retail locations. Numerous loyal users expressed gratitude for being able to purchase online after their local stores stopped carrying the Coral Sunset shade. This availability issue appears to have pushed many customers toward online purchasing, with several mentioning setting up subscription deliveries to ensure they never run out.
Removal Process
An often-overlooked aspect of long-wearing lip products is the removal process. Several users commented on this, noting:
- The color requires dedicated makeup remover rather than just water
- Some found it resistant even to makeup removing wipes
- The tenacity of the formula was viewed as both a positive (for wearing) and a negative (for removal)
For those who prioritize easy removal at the end of the day, this may be a consideration worth noting.
Comparison to Similar Products
Some reviewers naturally compared this product to other long-wearing options they had tried:
- Former users of Almay long-wearing lip color (from the same parent company) noted differences in the moisturizing component, with some preferring the previous liquid topcoat to the current stick format
- The product was generally considered superior to standard lipsticks for longevity
- A few mentioned it performed better than similar long-wearing products from other drugstore brands
Who Is This Product Best For?
Based on the collective feedback, this product appears best suited for:
- Those who prioritize longevity over maximum comfort
- People with normal to slightly dry lips (very dry lips may struggle with the formula)
- Individuals seeking a subtle, flattering everyday color
- Anyone who dislikes frequent touch-ups or transfer issues
It may be less ideal for:
- Those with very dry or sensitive lips
- People who prefer to change lip colors throughout the day
- Those who prioritize a glossy finish (though the topcoat provides some shine, it’s not comparable to a true gloss)
Application Tips From Long-Term Users
Loyal users of this product shared several valuable tips for optimal results:
- Allow the color to dry completely (30-60 seconds) before applying the topcoat
- Carry the topcoat for touch-ups throughout the day to maintain moisture
- For a more natural look, apply a thin layer of the color
- For more intensity, apply an additional layer after the first has dried
- Some found success applying the color under regular lipstick for extended wear
- Proper lip preparation (gentle exfoliation and starting with dry lips) improves longevity
Potential Drawbacks
In the interest of providing a balanced assessment, several potential drawbacks emerged from customer feedback:
- The two-step application process requires more time than traditional lipstick
- Some users reported uneven fading, with color remaining on the outer edges while the center faded
- The formula can accentuate lip lines or dryness if not properly maintained with the topcoat
- A few users experienced irritation, burning, or unusual reactions to the formula
- The shade online may appear different than expected in person
Packaging and Design
The dual-ended design receives generally positive feedback for functionality, though some users mentioned challenges:
- The clear cap for the color end can crack over time
- Some reported difficulty removing the topcoat cap
- The slender design makes it easy to carry in smaller makeup bags
Final Assessment
After analyzing hundreds of user experiences with Covergirl Outlast All-Day Lip Color in Coral Sunset, it’s clear this product has earned its loyal following for good reason. The combination of a flattering, versatile color with impressive staying power makes it a standout in the drugstore long-wearing lip color category.
For those who prioritize longevity and minimal transfer, this product delivers excellent performance at an accessible price point. The two-step system requires a bit more effort than traditional lipstick, but the extended wear time compensates for this additional step for many users.
The Coral Sunset shade specifically appears to offer exceptional versatility, explaining why so many users have remained loyal to this particular color for years, even going to considerable lengths to track it down when local availability became limited.
While not perfect—particularly for those with very dry lips or those who prioritize ease of removal—the product fulfills its core promise of all-day color when used as directed, making it a worthy consideration for anyone seeking long-wearing lip color at a drugstore price point.
Rating: 4.2/5 stars
Pros:
- Exceptional longevity when applied correctly
- Flattering, versatile Coral Sunset shade
- Minimal transfer to cups, food, etc.
- Good value for the performance
- Includes moisturizing topcoat
Cons:
- Can be drying for some users
- May flake or wear unevenly without frequent topcoat application
- Removal requires dedicated makeup remover
- Availability of this specific shade can be limited in physical stores
Repurchase Verdict
For those who value long-lasting color over maximum comfort and don’t mind the two-step application process, Covergirl Outlast All-Day Lip Color in Coral Sunset is likely to become a staple in your makeup routine. The passionate loyalty of long-term users speaks volumes about this product’s performance in its category, making it a recommended option for anyone seeking extended wear from their lip color.
Buy on Amazon: Here
