In the ever-evolving world of beauty products, finding a lipstick that truly delivers on its promises can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. As a beauty expert who has tested countless lip products over the years, I’ve developed a keen eye for separating marketing hype from genuine quality. Today, I’m diving deep into one of the most enduring lip products on the market: COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color With Topcoat in the shade Canyon (#626).
Product Overview
COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color is a two-step lip system that consists of a color base and a clear moisturizing topcoat. The product promises all-day wear without transferring, fading, or feathering – ambitious claims that have attracted a dedicated following over nearly two decades on the market. This particular shade, Canyon (#626), is a versatile neutral with subtle orange undertones that has earned a reputation as a universally flattering color.
First Impressions
Upon opening the package, you’re greeted with a dual-ended product: the liquid color on one end and the clear topcoat on the other. The packaging is simple and functional, though not particularly luxurious – a reflection of its drugstore price point. The color applicator is a standard doe-foot, while the moisturizing balm comes in a traditional lipstick form.
The liquid color itself has a slightly sweet scent that some users have compared to cherry chapstick, evoking nostalgic feelings without being overwhelming. The formula appears smooth and pigmented in the tube, promising opaque coverage with minimal product.
Application Experience
When it comes to application, technique matters significantly with this product. After numerous tests and consideration of user feedback, I’ve found the optimal application method involves these steps:
- Start with clean, dry lips (oil or balm residue can prevent proper adhesion)
- Apply the color evenly to lips, keeping them separate while it dries
- Allow the color to dry completely (approximately 60 seconds) before closing your mouth
- Apply the clear topcoat for comfort and shine
The liquid color applies smoothly and evenly, though you do need to work relatively quickly as it begins to set almost immediately. The precision tip makes it easy to follow your natural lip line, though first-time users might want to take extra care around the cupid’s bow.
One consistent observation from users is that less is definitely more with this product. Applying too thick a layer can lead to crumbling or uneven wear throughout the day. A thin, even layer provides optimal results and longevity.
Color and Finish
Canyon (#626) is described by users as a “nude with very slight orange undertones” that creates a “natural pinky-orange look.” The color is particularly popular among those with fair to medium skin tones and blonde hair, though reviews suggest it’s remarkably versatile across different complexions.
What makes Canyon special is its chameleon-like quality – it enhances your natural lip color rather than masking it completely. As one longtime user noted, “It really doesn’t seem like I’m wearing lipstick at all,” which speaks to its natural-looking finish.
The initial finish of the color alone is matte, and quite flat. However, once the topcoat is applied, you can achieve anything from a subtle satin finish to a more pronounced shine, depending on your preference and how heavily you apply the balm.
Wear Time and Performance
COVERGIRL’s “all-day” claim is where this product truly shines, and user experiences overwhelmingly support this promise. Countless reviews mention applying the product at 7 AM and still having visible, even color at 10 PM. One particularly impressed user noted that it “stayed on during a pool day,” which is truly remarkable for any lip product.
The lipstick demonstrates exceptional resistance to:
- Drinking (no lip marks on glasses or coffee cups)
- Talking extensively
- Light meals
- Kissing
However, there are limitations to its staying power. Foods with high oil content, such as pizza or salad with dressing, can break down the formula. As one user candidly explained, “The olive oil removes it.” In these cases, a quick touch-up may be necessary, but it’s still far more durable than traditional lipsticks.
What makes the Outlast formula particularly impressive is that when it does eventually fade, it tends to do so evenly rather than creating the dreaded “ring” effect common with long-wearing formulas. This is especially true with lighter shades like Canyon, which “blend into your natural color better” as they wear.
Comfort and Moisturization
Long-wearing lip products often sacrifice comfort for longevity, and while COVERGIRL Outlast isn’t immune to this trade-off, the included topcoat significantly mitigates the issue. The color base alone can feel quite drying on the lips – users describe a “pulling feeling” when wearing it without the topcoat. However, regular application of the clear balm keeps lips comfortable throughout the day.
Some dedicated users have developed their own systems to enhance comfort, such as:
- Using the Outlast color as a base and applying a similar, more moisturizing lipstick over it throughout the day
- Applying the topcoat every few hours, especially after eating or drinking
- Using a lip scrub the night before to ensure smooth application
- Applying a heavy-duty lip balm at night to counteract any drying effects
It’s worth noting that those with very dry lips may find even the topcoat insufficient for complete comfort. However, most users find that with proper application and maintenance, the formula remains comfortable for all-day wear.
Removal Process
Given the product’s impressive staying power, removal requires more effort than wiping it away with a tissue. Oil-based makeup removers work best, with many users specifically mentioning Neutrogena as an effective option. Some also note that toothpaste can help break down the formula, though this isn’t officially recommended.
For those who forget to remove it before bed, you might be surprised to find it’s still there in the morning – a testament to its longevity, but potentially a drawback for those who prefer easy removal.
Value and Longevity of Product
At a drugstore price point (typically ranging from $7-12 depending on retailer), COVERGIRL Outlast offers exceptional value compared to high-end long-wearing lip products that can cost three to four times as much. Many users emphatically state that it outperforms luxury brands they’ve tried, with one saying, “I have tried some top of the line lipstick brands that cannot come close to this. Don’t waste your money on more expensive make-up, Cover Girl outlasts them all.”
As for how long a single tube lasts, experiences vary depending on frequency of use. Daily users typically report needing to replace it every 2-3 months, though some mention the product seems to have less product volume than in years past. A small minority of reviews mention receiving tubes that appeared partially filled or dried out, suggesting occasional quality control issues.
Comparison to Competitors
The long-wearing lip color category has expanded significantly since COVERGIRL Outlast was first introduced, with numerous competitors at various price points. Based on direct comparisons from those who have tried multiple brands:
- vs. Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour: Users generally preferred COVERGIRL’s formula for smoother application and less flaking
- vs. Revlon Colorstay Overtime: Mixed reviews, with some preferring Revlon’s moisturizing feel but most giving the edge to COVERGIRL for longevity
- vs. Jeffree Star: COVERGIRL was favored for more consistent wear and better value
Notably, several users mentioned they tried COVERGIRL Outlast after disappointment with a “popular brand of all day color introduced in 1999” that was “$40” and caused “blisters, super dry lips and other issues” – likely referring to the original Lipfinity formula.
Perfect For Specific Scenarios
This product particularly shines in certain situations:
- Professional settings: The need for a lip color that lasts through presentations, meetings, and networking events without requiring frequent touch-ups
- Special occasions: Weddings, graduations, and other events where photographs will be taken throughout the day
- Travel: When you don’t want to pack multiple lip products or worry about touch-ups while exploring
- Mask wearing: Many recent reviews specifically mention its effectiveness under face masks, with minimal transfer
- Hot weather activities: The formula holds up admirably to sweating and swimming
The Canyon Color Experience
While this review focuses on the overall performance of the COVERGIRL Outlast formula, the Canyon shade deserves special attention. This particular color has developed a devoted following over more than a decade, with many users describing it as their “holy grail” lip color that they’ve used consistently for 5, 10, or even 15+ years.
What makes Canyon so special? Users describe it as:
- “A perfect neutral” that “coordinates with most colors”
- Natural-looking with “just a hint of coral to brighten your face”
- Versatile for both daytime and evening wear
- Particularly flattering for those with fair complexions and blonde hair, though adaptable to multiple skin tones
This explains why many users express anxiety about potentially discontinued shades, with many turning to Amazon specifically because they can no longer find Canyon in local stores.
Who Should Use This Product
COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color in Canyon is ideal for:
- Those who prioritize longevity over all other aspects in a lip product
- People who dislike frequent touch-ups or reapplication
- Individuals with busy lifestyles who need makeup that keeps up with them
- Anyone looking for a natural-looking neutral that enhances rather than masks their lips
- Those who like to apply their makeup once and forget about it for the rest of the day
Who Should Pass
This product may not be suitable for:
- Those with extremely dry or chapped lips who prioritize comfort above all else
- People who prefer a single-step application process
- Individuals looking for bold, dramatic lip colors (though other shades in the line may suit this purpose)
- Those who frequently change their lip color throughout the day
- People who prefer easy removal with just a tissue
Tips for Best Results
After analyzing hundreds of user experiences, these tips emerge for getting the most out of this product:
- Apply to completely clean, dry lips (no balm underneath)
- Use a very thin layer of the color – less is definitely more
- Keep lips separated while the color dries completely
- Apply the topcoat immediately after the color dries, and reapply throughout the day as needed
- For removal, use an oil-based makeup remover
- Consider using a lip scrub the night before application for the smoothest result
- Pair with a lip liner if you desire extra definition
The Test of Time
Perhaps the most telling aspect of COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color is its remarkable staying power in the market. In an industry where products come and go constantly, this formula has maintained a dedicated following for nearly two decades. Many users report using it consistently for 5, 10, 15, or even 20+ years – a testament to its reliability in delivering on its promises.
As one user who has used it for 14 years stated, “I have been wearing this product for 14 years. At first I loved it and I recommended it to everyone I knew.” While this particular user noted a change in formula over time, the vast majority of long-term users remain satisfied with the performance.
Final Verdict
After thorough analysis of user experiences and performance metrics, COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color With Topcoat in Canyon earns a strong recommendation for those seeking long-lasting lip color at an affordable price point. It delivers exceptionally well on its core promise of all-day wear with minimal transfer, though with the expected trade-offs in terms of potential drying effects and more involved removal.
The Canyon shade specifically has earned its cult following through its versatility and natural-enhancing qualities. For those new to long-wearing lip formulas, this particular shade offers an approachable entry point that’s forgiving in application and flattering on a wide range of skin tones.
Is it perfect? No – the formula can be drying without diligent application of the topcoat, and some users note inconsistency in product volume. However, its strengths far outweigh its weaknesses, particularly when considering its accessible price point compared to high-end competitors.
For those searching for a reliable lip color that truly stays put from morning coffee to evening dinner, COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color in Canyon remains a standout choice that has stood the test of time in a crowded and constantly evolving market.
Rating: 4.5/5 stars
Buy on Amazon: Here
