Hey everyone! Today I’m sharing my COMPLETE thoughts on the Covergirl & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation in shade #225 Buff Beige. I’ve been using this product for a while now, and I’ve got some real-world feedback to share with you all – the good, the bad, and everything in between!
QUICK OVERVIEW
Covergirl & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation has been around for years as part of their mature skin line. The #225 Buff Beige shade specifically has become a go-to for many fair to light-skinned people who need something with neutral to slightly warm undertones. Let’s dive into what makes this foundation worth talking about!
THE FORMULA: WHAT’S INSIDE?
The Simply Ageless line is specifically designed for mature skin (hello, 40+ crowd!) and combines Covergirl’s foundation expertise with Olay’s skincare benefits. The collaboration aims to create a product that doesn’t just cover but actually improves skin appearance over time.
What makes this foundation unique is its focus on:
- Hydration for drier, mature skin
- Light to medium coverage that doesn’t cake
- A natural, skin-like finish
- Anti-aging ingredients courtesy of the Olay collaboration
APPLICATION EXPERIENCE
One thing that immediately stands out about this foundation is how SMOOTHLY it applies! Multiple reviewers mention this specifically – it glides on without dragging or pulling at the skin, which is super important for mature skin types.
The product comes with an application pad, which is actually a key part of the experience. One reviewer specifically mentioned being upset when their product arrived WITHOUT the applicator! For the price point, they expected the complete package, and honestly, I agree. That applicator isn’t just a bonus – it’s part of what makes the foundation work so well.
Application tips based on reviews:
- Apply after moisturizer has fully absorbed
- Use the included applicator pad for best results
- A little goes a long way – start with a small amount
- Can be built up in areas needing more coverage
- Sets beautifully with a light dusting of powder
COVERAGE & FINISH
This is definitely not a full-coverage foundation, and that’s actually part of its charm. It provides light to medium coverage that can be built up slightly where needed. The finish is natural and skin-like – not matte, not dewy, just natural skin.
For those over 70, one reviewer mentions that it provides just the right amount of coverage when they need “a bit more coverage than that provided by Physician’s Formula translucent multi-color pressed powder.” This suggests it’s perfect for those days when you want something more than powder but less than heavy foundation.
The foundation looks INCREDIBLY natural once applied – multiple reviewers emphasize this. It doesn’t look like you’re wearing makeup, just that your skin looks better. That’s exactly what most of us want from a foundation!
SHADE RANGE CONSIDERATIONS
Let’s talk specifically about the #225 Buff Beige shade. Based on reviewer comments:
- It works well for fair-skinned people who have some rosiness to their complexion
- It’s slightly warmer than the Creamy Natural shade
- It’s particularly good for fair-skinned people who find most beige foundations too yellow
- It seems to work especially well for those with Scandinavian/Irish heritage
One reviewer specifically mentioned that Buff Beige worked well for them as they aged and their skin tone changed: “The Creamy Natural is just a tad too light at this point in my life (my face got a little rosier as my hair got whiter), so the Buff Beige worked well.”
PERFORMANCE ON MATURE SKIN
This is where the foundation really shines! It’s specifically formulated for older skin, and the reviews reflect this. Key benefits for mature skin include:
- Doesn’t settle into fine lines and wrinkles
- Doesn’t accentuate texture issues
- Provides enough coverage without looking heavy
- Hydrating without being greasy
- Works well over face creams (one reviewer mentions using it over Bee Friendly face and eye cream)
One 70+ reviewer mentions incorporating this foundation into their routine specifically for when they need more coverage than just powder, which suggests it’s light enough for older skin while still providing enough coverage to be worth using.
LONGEVITY & WEAR TIME
While the reviews don’t specifically mention wear time, the fact that multiple long-time users keep coming back to this product suggests it performs well throughout the day. One reviewer mentions they’ve been using this product for 10 YEARS! That kind of loyalty doesn’t happen with products that fade, oxidize, or break down easily.
The foundation also seems to layer well with other products. Several reviewers mention using it as part of a makeup routine that includes:
- Facial moisturizer underneath
- Pressed powder on top
- Blush layered over it
This versatility in a makeup routine is critical for a foundation’s success.
SEASONAL ADAPTABILITY
One interesting point from the reviews is how this foundation works across seasons. A reviewer mentions: “I’ve used a couple different shades. One shade I use during the fall and winter and the other mainly in the summer.”
This suggests the foundation works well year-round, with users simply adjusting shades seasonally rather than switching to entirely different products. This speaks to the formula’s consistency and reliability across different weather conditions and skin states.
PACKAGING QUALITY & ISSUES
The packaging seems to generally be good, but there are some inconsistencies. One reviewer received their product with the case in perfect condition but “the product was a mess” inside. This suggests potential quality control issues in shipping or handling.
Another reviewer specifically complained about receiving the product without the applicator pad, which they considered an essential part of the product given its price point.
The compact design with the built-in applicator makes this foundation convenient for on-the-go touch-ups, which is a plus for many users.
VALUE FOR MONEY
The foundation seems to provide good value for money overall, though some reviewers expressed frustration about paying full price but receiving products with issues (like missing applicators or broken product).
Long-time users clearly find the value proposition strong enough to continue purchasing it for years or even decades, suggesting the performance justifies the price point.
AVAILABILITY CONCERNS
A MAJOR issue mentioned by multiple reviewers is that this foundation appears to be discontinued in certain shades or regions. One reviewer expressed being “Really NOT happy” about the Buff Beige shade being discontinued. Another mentioned: “been looking for this make for a month now because it’s been discontinued in the shop in my Area.”
This discontinuation issue is creating real frustration among loyal customers who have used and loved this product for years. For makeup that people rely on daily, discontinuation is more than just an inconvenience – it forces them to start the often challenging process of finding a new foundation match.
Some reviewers are turning to online purchases to find their preferred shade when local stores no longer carry it.
EXPIRATION CONCERNS
One reviewer mentioned receiving the product with an expiration date that had already passed: “I just received this today and the expiry date is Nov 2018.” This is obviously concerning for any beauty product, but especially for something applied to the face daily.
This highlights the importance of checking expiration dates when purchasing this foundation, especially from third-party sellers or online marketplaces where inventory might move more slowly.
WHO IS THIS FOUNDATION BEST FOR?
Based on the reviews, this foundation seems ideal for:
- Mature skin (40+)
- Fair to light skin tones, especially those with slight rosiness
- People who prefer light to medium coverage
- Those who want a natural, skin-like finish
- Anyone who finds most foundations too heavy or cakey
- People who want makeup with skincare benefits
WHO SHOULD LOOK ELSEWHERE?
This foundation might not be the best fit for:
- Those seeking full coverage
- Oily skin types (reviews mostly mention it working well for normal to dry skin)
- People who prefer a very dewy or very matte finish
- Those with very deep skin tones (the reviews don’t mention how inclusive the shade range is)
THE VERDICT: IS IT WORTH IT?
The Covergirl & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation in #225 Buff Beige has clearly developed a loyal following for good reason. Despite some availability issues and occasional quality control problems, the foundation itself performs exceptionally well for its target audience.
The combination of easy application, natural finish, and skin-friendly formula makes it a standout option for mature skin. The fact that users have remained loyal for up to 10 years speaks volumes about its consistent performance.
If you’re looking for a foundation that enhances rather than masks your skin, and you can find your shade, this product is definitely worth trying!
PROS:
- Smooth, easy application
- Natural, skin-like finish
- Works well on mature skin
- Doesn’t settle into lines or wrinkles
- Layers well with other products
- Long-time user loyalty
CONS:
- Availability/discontinuation issues
- Occasional quality control problems
- Limited coverage (though this is a pro for some)
- Potential expiration date concerns with some sellers
FINAL THOUGHTS
The Covergirl & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation in #225 Buff Beige is clearly a product that inspires loyalty among its users. The frustration expressed when it’s discontinued or hard to find shows just how much people have come to rely on it as part of their beauty routine.
If Covergirl is indeed discontinuing certain shades of this product, they might want to reconsider given the passionate customer base that has developed over the years. In today’s beauty market where brands are constantly expanding shade ranges rather than reducing them, moving in the opposite direction seems shortsighted.
For those who can still find their shade, this foundation remains a solid option that delivers on its promises of natural coverage and skin-friendly wear. Just be sure to check those expiration dates!
Have you tried the Covergirl & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation? I’d love to hear YOUR experiences with it, especially if you’ve found good alternatives for discontinued shades!
Buy on Amazon: Here
