In the ever-evolving world of cosmetics, finding the perfect foundation—one that offers coverage without feeling heavy, matches your skin tone beautifully, and actually benefits your skin—can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. The CoverGirl & Olay Simply Ageless 3-in-1 Liquid Foundation promises to check all these boxes and more, combining the coverage expertise of CoverGirl with the skincare knowledge of Olay. But does it deliver? I’ve analyzed hundreds of customer experiences to bring you this in-depth review.
Product Overview
The CoverGirl & Olay Simply Ageless 3-in-1 Liquid Foundation is designed specifically with mature skin in mind, though users of all ages have found benefits in its formula. This foundation comes in a pump bottle and features:
- Hyaluronic acid and vitamin complex for hydration
- A lightweight, buildable formula
- Multiple shade options to match various skin tones
- Anti-aging benefits from the Olay component
- Cruelty-free certification
Priced generally between $10-17 depending on retailer, this foundation positions itself as an affordable option that promises premium results.
Performance Analysis
Coverage and Finish
The foundation offers medium coverage that most users find buildable without becoming cakey. The finish is described as natural—neither too matte nor too dewy—creating what many call a “your skin but better” effect.
One 63-year-old user with combination skin noted: “It only takes a small amount, and the finished product still looks like skin, only more even. It feels like I’m not wearing anything on my face, and does not settle into my pores or wrinkles.”
The foundation excels at evening out skin tone and covering minor imperfections. Those with more significant discoloration or hyperpigmentation may need to supplement with concealer, though some users report success in building up coverage on problem areas without the foundation becoming heavy.
Texture and Application
The texture is consistently described as smooth, silky, and creamy. It blends effortlessly using fingers, makeup sponges, or brushes. The foundation doesn’t dry down too quickly, giving users adequate time to blend, but sets well enough to create a lasting base.
Application is straightforward—a little goes a long way, with many users mentioning they need just a few dabs to cover their entire face. The pump dispenser generally receives positive feedback for delivering an appropriate amount of product, though there were some shipping issues with missing caps and damaged pumps.
Longevity
For a drugstore foundation, the Simply Ageless demonstrates impressive staying power. Most users report that it lasts throughout a standard workday with minimal fading. Some mention that it performs well even during 12+ hour wear without touch-ups.
A user in her early 20s shared: “When I say this foundation lasts and has minimal fading, it’s over a really long amount of time.”
Touch-ups are generally not required, though those with very oily skin may want to blot or use a setting powder in their T-zone throughout the day. The foundation doesn’t tend to transfer significantly once set, though some users recommend setting with powder to minimize transfer completely.
Skin Benefits and Comfort
Where this foundation truly stands out is in its comfort and skin benefits. The hyaluronic acid and vitamin complex don’t just sound good on the label—users repeatedly mention improved skin texture with continued use.
“Every time I wear this foundation, not only does it actually stay of my face (doesn’t break apart, minimal fading) but it doesn’t cling and make me look scaley either! Whenever I wear this foundation, my skin actually gets smoother and softer! I’ve noticed the more I wear it, the better my skin looks without makeup at all!”
For those with mature skin, the foundation receives particularly high praise for not settling into fine lines and wrinkles. Multiple users in their 70s and 80s express delight at finding a foundation that doesn’t accentuate their lines.
An 80-year-old user commented: “I stopped wearing foundation since I thought any product would settle in my wrinkles and emphasize them. I had a little left in an old bottle I’d forgotten about so I used it. No caking, no settling into wrinkles. It was amazing!!”
The moisturizing properties make it suitable for dry and combination skin, though it manages to avoid feeling heavy or greasy on oilier skin types as well.
Performance Across Skin Types
Mature Skin
For mature skin, this foundation is consistently rated as exceptional. Users appreciate that it:
- Doesn’t settle into fine lines and wrinkles
- Provides hydration without heaviness
- Creates a natural, skin-like finish
- Offers adequate coverage without looking mask-like
An 81-year-old user enthusiastically shared: “I’ll never look really OLD! I’M 81 YEARS OLD!”
Dry Skin
Those with dry skin report that the foundation:
- Doesn’t cling to dry patches
- Provides lasting hydration
- Creates a smooth finish without flaking
- Feels comfortable throughout the day
“It is super easy to apply and blend and provides great coverage. It does not dry out my skin and holds up for all day wear.”
Combination Skin
Users with combination skin appreciate:
- The balanced finish that doesn’t exacerbate oiliness or dryness
- How it adapts to different areas of the face
- The way it stays put on oilier areas without clinging to dry spots
Oily Skin
While fewer reviews specifically address very oily skin, those that do mention:
- Reasonable oil control
- A natural rather than overly matte finish
- The need for occasional blotting but good overall wear
“I have very oily skin, large pores, and battle both wrinkles and acne. I do not set with a powder, and I find that blush sticks to this foundation quite well without fading away after a few hours.”
Sensitive Skin
Those with sensitive skin generally report good experiences:
- Minimal irritation or breakouts
- Comfortable wear
- No strong reaction to the fragrance (though the fragrance is mentioned as a potential concern)
“I have sensitive, combo skin and now am in my 40s. Still looks great and my skin never reacts to it.”
Shade Range and Matching
The foundation comes in multiple shades, though the exact number varies by retailer. Finding the right match receives mixed reviews:
- Some users report perfect matches on their first attempt
- Others mention difficulty with online color selection
- Some shades are described as running slightly light or dark
- The undertone descriptions (cool, warm, neutral) generally seem accurate
One user with olive undertones shared: “I have a tough time matching my olive skintone to over-the-counter makeup foundations but this is a really great match. Once it’s on, you can’t tell I’m wearing foundation which is how it should be.”
Several users recommend testing in-store before purchasing online if possible, particularly if you have a hard-to-match skin tone.
Value and Packaging
The product is widely considered to provide excellent value, with many comparing it favorably to high-end foundations:
“I’ve used expensive department store products that do not even compare to this.”
“Much better than far more expensive foundations, cost effective and most of all, no harm to animals.”
The packaging receives mixed reviews:
- The pump mechanism is generally appreciated for ease of use and hygiene
- The bottle design allows for easy dispensing
- Many users reported receiving products without caps, seals broken, or with damaged pumps through online ordering
- Some mention the bottle is smaller than expected
Fragrance and Sensory Experience
The foundation has a mild scent that most describe as pleasant or neutral. A few users with fragrance sensitivities mention this as a drawback:
“The first thing I noticed about this foundation was its fragrance. Why so strong??!! I don’t need perfume on my face, and my skin doesn’t like it.”
However, most describe the scent as subtle:
“No smell! It has the slightest scent of Olay, but nothing crazy.”
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent for mature skin and doesn’t settle into fine lines
- Buildable, natural-looking coverage
- Skincare benefits with continued use
- Comfortable, lightweight feel
- Good longevity and wear
- Affordable price point
- Cruelty-free
- Wide shade range with options for very fair skin
- Pump dispenser for hygienic application
Cons:
- Fragrance may bother those with sensitivities
- Online color matching can be challenging
- Packaging issues with online orders (missing caps, leakage)
- May not provide enough coverage for those with significant discoloration
- No SPF protection
Who Should Try This Foundation
This foundation is particularly well-suited for:
- Those with mature skin looking for a foundation that doesn’t emphasize fine lines
- People with dry or combination skin seeking hydration without heaviness
- Anyone wanting a natural, skin-like finish with medium coverage
- Budget-conscious shoppers looking for high performance at a drugstore price
- Those seeking additional skincare benefits in their makeup
Who Might Want to Look Elsewhere
This may not be the best option for:
- Those with very oily skin who need significant oil control
- People seeking full, opaque coverage
- Those with strong fragrance sensitivities
- Anyone who requires their foundation to include SPF protection
Application Tips from Users
Based on user experiences, these application techniques yield the best results:
- Less is more: Start with a small amount and build up as needed. Most users find they need less than expected.
- Fingers work well: Many users mention that fingers provide excellent application, warming the product for seamless blending.
- For dry skin: Apply directly after moisturizer while skin is still slightly damp.
- For combination/oily skin: Consider using a primer in the T-zone and applying the foundation with a damp sponge.
- Setting: While many users skip powder, a light dusting of translucent powder helps minimize transfer and increase longevity.
- Color adaptation: Several users mention that the color adjusts slightly after application, so give it 15-20 minutes before deciding on the match.
- Mixing technique: Some users mix a small amount with their moisturizer for even lighter coverage on good skin days.
- Layering for problem areas: Rather than applying heavily everywhere, build up coverage only where needed.
Comparison to Similar Products
Many users directly compared this foundation to other products:
- Versus high-end foundations: Frequently compared favorably to department store brands costing 3-5 times as much.
- Versus other CoverGirl foundations: Generally considered superior to other CoverGirl offerings, particularly for mature skin.
- Versus other drugstore foundations: Often rated better than competitors like L’Oreal and Maybelline for hydration and wear on mature skin.
- Versus previous formulations: Some long-time users note that this formula performs better than previous iterations of Simply Ageless.
Final Verdict
The CoverGirl & Olay Simply Ageless 3-in-1 Liquid Foundation earns its reputation as an exceptional drugstore foundation, particularly for those with mature or dry skin. Its ability to provide natural-looking coverage while delivering skincare benefits makes it stand out in an overcrowded market.
While no foundation works perfectly for everyone, the overwhelmingly positive feedback across different age groups and skin types suggests this is a versatile option worth trying. The price point makes it an accessible choice, allowing users to experiment without significant investment.
If you’re seeking a foundation that marries makeup with skincare and creates a natural, enhancing finish, the CoverGirl & Olay Simply Ageless 3-in-1 Liquid Foundation deserves serious consideration. Just be sure to purchase from a reputable source to avoid packaging issues, and when possible, test shades in-store before committing to ensure your perfect match.
For its combination of performance, skin benefits, and value, this foundation earns a strong recommendation, especially for those embracing the beauty of aging skin with grace and confidence.
Buy on Amazon: Here
