After spending WEEKS testing out CoverGirl’s Lash Blast Cleantopia Waterproof Mascara, I’m ready to spill ALL the details! This isn’t your average mascara review – I’ve compiled feedback from dozens of real users plus my own experience to give you the complete picture.
CoverGirl markets this as part of their “clean” beauty line, featuring:
- Aloe leaf extract, Vitamin E, and ceramides
- Gentle, plant-based formula
- Extreme black pigment
- Waterproof, transfer-proof, and long-wearing
- Volumizing effect
The tube is classic CoverGirl – sturdy plastic with that recognizable orange-yellow branding that’s become iconic for their Lash Blast line. But what REALLY matters is what’s inside!
APPLICATION: A Mixed Bag
Let me be straight with you – the application experience varies quite a bit depending on what you’re used to!
The wand is uniquely shaped (almost like higher-end mascaras) and provides good separation when used correctly. BUT it takes some getting used to! The bristles are designed to catch every lash, but the top part is pretty bulky, making it tricky to reach inner corner lashes without smudging.
Several users (myself included) noticed the formula can be on the wetter side. This means:
- You need to wait between coats to avoid clumping
- It can transfer to your lid during application if you’re not careful
- Some users found it “goopy” when first opening
For best results, I found that wiping excess product from the brush and applying in thin layers works MUCH better than trying to load it all on at once.
FORMULA: The Good & The Bad
The formula is where opinions really split! Here’s what I discovered:
What’s GREAT about it:
- The plant-based formula is genuinely gentler for sensitive eyes
- No weird chemical smell (a BIG plus for those with sensitivities!)
- The extreme black color is truly intense
- Does a fantastic job holding curl for stubborn straight lashes
- Many users with fine, light lashes saw dramatic improvement
One reviewer noted: “I have always had fine, light coloured lashes, due to my blond hair. With this product, I do not feel any irritation, I honestly forget that I am wearing mascara.”
What’s NOT so great:
- Some tubes seem inconsistent – a few users got dried-out product
- The thick formula can clump if you’re not careful with application
- Some users experienced brush bristles coming loose (yikes!)
- Several people reported allergic reactions despite the “clean” formula
The consistency reminds me of a wet texture rather than a cream mascara. This makes it great for building, but requires patience between coats.
WEAR TEST: Does It Really Last All Day?
This is where things get INTERESTING! The waterproof claims are legitimate – this mascara can handle:
- Crying (several emotional testers confirmed!)
- Sweating through workouts
- Light rain exposure
- Watery eyes from allergies
One enthusiastic user shared: “Very good, creates a beautiful look. It’s very very very waterproof. Hard to get it off. I suppose that’s a good problem to have.”
However, the “transfer-proof” claim wasn’t as consistent. While many users (including me) found it stayed put all day, others experienced:
- Smudging under eyes after a few hours
- Flaking throughout the day
- The dreaded “raccoon eyes” by end of workday
My personal experience? It lasted through a 10-hour workday with minimal smudging, but I have relatively non-oily skin. If you’re oilier, you might see more transfer.
THE LOOK: Volume, Length & Definition
What kind of look can you expect? Based on all feedback:
- EXCELLENT volume (nearly everyone agreed on this point)
- Good length, though not as dramatic as some specialized lengthening mascaras
- Nice definition and separation when applied properly
- Natural-looking lash boost for everyday wear
- Works best on people with already decent lashes
One reviewer summed it up perfectly: “Gives great lash boots and definition but doesn’t stay put on my lashes very long.”
Another noted: “if you have stubborn lashes like me and they don’t like staying curled up, this mascara is definitely for you.”
For those with sparse lashes, you might need multiple coats to get a dramatic effect, but be careful – layering too quickly can cause clumping.
THE REMOVAL PROCESS: The Biggest Controversy!
This is the most polarizing aspect of this mascara! The reviews were COMPLETELY split:
Camp 1: “It comes off easily!”
Many users found it removed well with:
- Regular face wash
- Makeup wipes
- Water-based removers
One happy user shared: “It comes off easily with water based remover, wipes, or face wash.”
Camp 2: “IT WILL NOT COME OFF!”
Others had a completely different experience:
- “It applies very easily but stays on like permanent glue!”
- “I tried mascara remover pads and liquid remover, finally soap and water was the only thing that could loose my lashes from its grip.”
- Some even reported losing lashes trying to remove it!
My personal experience was somewhere in the middle. It takes dedicated oil-based remover and some patience, but it’s not impossible to remove. I recommend:
- Using a dedicated oil-based eye makeup remover
- Letting the remover sit on lashes for 30+ seconds
- Gently wiping away (don’t rub aggressively!)
- Following with a second cleanse
WHO SHOULD BUY THIS MASCARA?
Based on ALL the feedback and my testing, this mascara is PERFECT for:
- People with sensitive eyes looking for a gentler formula
- Those with straight, stubborn lashes that won’t hold a curl
- Anyone needing truly waterproof mascara for active lifestyles
- People with fine, light lashes who want more definition
- Those who prefer a clean, plant-based formula without sacrificing performance
WHO SHOULD SKIP IT?
This mascara probably ISN’T right for you if:
- You have very sparse lashes (the formula can be too heavy)
- You’re prone to allergic reactions (despite being “clean,” some still experienced sensitivity)
- You prefer mascaras that remove easily at the end of the day
- You need something that’s 100% smudge-proof for very oily skin
- You prefer a drier formula that’s less prone to clumping
VALUE FOR MONEY?
At its price point (around $13-15), it’s more expensive than some drugstore options but significantly cheaper than high-end brands. Is it worth it?
- YES if you need the waterproof qualities and clean formula
- NO if you’re looking for the easiest application and removal
One reviewer mentioned: “It is more expensive than previous products that I have purchased, but I will definitely continue to buy.”
FINAL VERDICT
After weighing ALL the feedback and my personal experience, I give CoverGirl Lash Blast Cleantopia Waterproof Mascara a solid 7/10!
The PROS:
- Truly waterproof performance
- Clean, plant-based formula good for sensitive eyes
- Great volume and curl-holding ability
- Nice black pigmentation
- Good separation when applied correctly
The CONS:
- Inconsistent removal experience
- Potential for clumping if not careful
- Some quality control issues (dried product, loose bristles)
- Can transfer throughout the day for some users
Would I buy it again? YES – but I’d keep an oil-based remover on hand and take my time with application!
Have you tried CoverGirl Lash Blast Cleantopia? I’d LOVE to hear your experience in the comments below!
Disclaimer: Individual experiences may vary based on skin type, lash type, and application technique. This review combines my personal testing with feedback from numerous real users to provide the most comprehensive overview possible.
Buy on Amazon: Here
