Hey there! I’ve been testing the Covergirl Lash Blast Cleantopia Mascara in 820 Ultramarine Black, and I’m EXCITED to share my honest thoughts with you! This isn’t just any ordinary mascara – it’s a unique blue-black formula that’s creating quite a buzz in the beauty community. Let’s dive into everything you need to know about this product!
First Impressions: The Color Situation
Let’s address the elephant in the room right away – the COLOR! This mascara is marketed as “Ultramarine Black,” which suggests a black mascara with blue undertones. What I’ve found (and what many reviewers agree with) is that it’s definitely more blue than you might expect from the name.
The blue is a deep navy tone – not an electric or bright blue that would look costume-ish. On the brush and in the tube, it looks quite blue, but once applied to your lashes, it reads as a softer alternative to pure black. If you’re looking for something that’s obviously blue, this isn’t it. It’s subtle but distinct.
Many reviewers with blue or green eyes particularly love how this color makes their eyes POP! One reviewer mentioned, “The dark blue is so flattering on green or blue eyes,” while another said, “I wore it for the first time with no eyeshadow just the mascara and chapstick and had people commenting on how nice I looked and that my eyes were popping.
For brown-eyed folks, don’t feel left out! Several reviewers mentioned that this mascara made their brown eyes stand out beautifully too.
Application & Brush Design
The brush is definitely a conversation starter. It’s:
- Large with long bristles
- Has an hourglass or “peanut” shape
- Quite thick compared to many other mascara wands
This brush design has VERY mixed reviews. Some love how it covers a large area of lashes at once, while others find it awkward to use, especially for inner corner lashes or bottom lashes.
One reviewer summarized it perfectly: “The spoolie is ok, not great not awful. Shape has a smaller middle which probably serves a purpose but I don’t know what that would be.”
The brush shape means that product sometimes accumulates at the tip, which can lead to clumping if you don’t wipe excess off before applying. A common recommendation is to scrape the wand against the tube opening to remove excess product before application.
Formula & Performance
Let’s talk about what this mascara actually DOES for your lashes:
Strengths:
- Adds good length to lashes
- Separates lashes nicely
- Generally not too clumpy once you get the hang of application
- Works well for sensitive eyes (many reviewers mentioned this specifically!)
- Buildable formula that allows for multiple coats
- Creates a softer look than harsh black mascaras
Some reviewers mentioned impressive length results: “I love how long and thick my lashes become with this mascara. I only need 1 coat if using primer.”
Weaknesses:
- Some report flaking issues after several hours of wear
- Not waterproof (several reviewers wished for a waterproof version)
- Formula can be a bit thick/clumpy for some users
- May need reapplication for all-day wear
- Not the most dramatic volume enhancer
One common complaint was around longevity: “By afternoon, lashes had that ‘no mascara’ look” and “I put on 2 coats (anymore than that is too heavy). By the end of day there’s little left to wipe off.”
The “Clean” Formula Factor
This mascara is marketed as part of Covergirl’s “Cleantopia” line, meaning it has a vegan, plant-based formula. For many reviewers, this was a HUGE selling point!
People with sensitive eyes particularly appreciated this aspect: “I have terribly sensitive eyes but I love my mascara, so wanted to give this one a try. So far I’m loving it! Typically my eyes are bothered almost right away when I put mascara on and I can’t wait to wash it back off, but I’ve worn this several times all day with no complaints or issues.”
Another reviewer shared: “Best thing I’ve ever used. My eyes are very sensitive, dry and itchy. This mascara does not make my eyes burn.”
However, a few people did still experience sensitivity: “This ‘clean’ mascara caused burning to my eyes!!!”
The clean formula also means it’s very easy to remove – just soap and water will do the trick for most people. No harsh makeup removers needed!
Value for Money
At around half the price of high-end mascaras, many reviewers felt this was an excellent value. One reviewer who had tried $50 mascaras said this one performed comparably for a fraction of the cost.
The price point makes it a low-risk purchase if you’re curious about trying a blue-black mascara for the first time.
Who Would Love This Mascara?
Based on the reviews, this mascara would be PERFECT for:
- People with sensitive eyes looking for a gentler formula
- Anyone who wants a softer alternative to harsh black mascara
- Blue or green-eyed folks looking to make their eye color pop
- Those who prefer a more natural, everyday look rather than dramatic volume
- People who want to try something a little different without going full-on colored mascara
Who Should Skip It?
You might want to look elsewhere if:
- You need truly waterproof, all-day wear
- You want dramatic volume and length (this is more subtle)
- You’re looking for a mascara that’s obviously blue (this is more of a hint)
- You have very short lashes and struggle with thick brushes
- You’re prone to mascara flaking and it drives you crazy
The Verdict
After analyzing all the reviews, this mascara seems to be a SOLID 4/5 stars product. It’s not perfect, but it offers something unique in the drugstore mascara market with its navy blue tint and clean formula.
The biggest positives are the flattering color that enhances eye color without being obvious, the gentle formula for sensitive eyes, and the good length it provides. The main drawbacks are the potential for flaking after extended wear and the divisive brush design.
Application Tips From Reviewers
If you decide to try this mascara, here are some helpful tips from reviewers who’ve mastered using it:
- Wipe excess product from the brush before applying, especially from the tip
- Use the middle part of the brush for bottom lashes to avoid smudging
- Apply in thin layers rather than trying to build volume with one heavy coat
- Try using it on top of a lash primer for extra staying power
- Some found it works well layered over other mascaras for a color boost
- No need for makeup remover – just warm water and gentle soap will remove it
Final Thoughts
What makes the Covergirl Lash Blast Cleantopia Mascara in Ultramarine Black stand out is its unique position in the market. It’s not often you find a navy-tinted mascara that’s subtle enough for everyday wear while still offering something different from standard black.
The clean, vegan formula is definitely a huge selling point for those with sensitive eyes or those looking to make more conscious beauty choices. While it may not be the most dramatic or long-lasting mascara on the market, it offers something different at an affordable price point.
I think one reviewer summed it up perfectly: “I had a mascara that had hints of blue years ago and I loved it. This is almost the same. I don’t like dark black, but this blue goes well with my blue eyes and doesn’t look majorly blue.”
If you’ve been curious about trying a blue-tinted mascara but have been hesitant about going too bold, this might be the perfect gateway product! The subtle navy hint is just enough to freshen up your look without screaming “I’M WEARING BLUE MASCARA!” 😊
Would I recommend it? YES – especially if you’re looking to try something a little different from your regular black mascara routine. Just keep your expectations realistic about its staying power and you’ll likely be pleasantly surprised by this affordable gem!
Buy on Amazon: Here
