As a beauty expert who has analyzed countless cosmetic products over the years, I’m excited to share my comprehensive review of COVERGIRL’s Eye Enhancers 3-Kit Eyeshadow in the shade Café Au Lait. This neutral palette has been a staple in many makeup collections for years, and I’ve gathered insights from both personal experience and consumer feedback to provide you with the most accurate assessment possible.
COVERGIRL has positioned this product as an everyday eyeshadow option with its “silky, sheer formula” and “double ended applicator.” The brand also highlights that this product is “100% Cruelty-free,” appealing to the increasingly conscious beauty consumer. But does this affordable drugstore option truly deliver on its promises? Let’s dive into the details.
Product Specifications
- Brand: COVERGIRL
- Product: Eye Enhancers 3-Kit Eyeshadow
- Shade: Café Au Lait
- Formula: Silky, sheer
- Applicator: Double-ended
- Ethics: 100% Cruelty-free
- Price Point: Budget-friendly drugstore option
Color Analysis
The Café Au Lait palette features three complementary neutral shades that work together to create a cohesive eye look:
- Light Shade: A pale, slightly shimmery highlight color, ideal for the brow bone and inner corner
- Medium Shade: A soft, neutral mid-tone that works well as a transition or all-over lid color
- Dark Shade: A deeper brown shade for definition and depth
Based on consumer feedback, it’s worth noting that the colors appear slightly lighter in person than they do in product photos. Many users with fair to medium skin tones find this palette particularly flattering, especially those with blue, green, or hazel eyes.
One consistent observation from reviewers is that the pigmentation is on the sheerer side. As one user noted, “I was hoping for the colors to be a little more pigmented, but they’re somewhat lackluster once applied.” Another mentioned, “Very light coverage, almost sheer. Even with a good eyeshadow primer, you have to cake it on to get any color.”
This sheerness can be either a pro or con depending on your preferences. For those seeking a subtle, natural look for everyday wear, this palette delivers exactly that. As one reviewer stated, “Perfect for a no-drama look. Easy to apply, easy to remove. Looks natural. What’s not to like?” However, if you’re looking for bold, intense color payoff, you might find yourself disappointed.
Texture and Formula
COVERGIRL describes this formula as “silky” and “sheer,” which appears to be an accurate description based on user experiences. The shadows have a soft texture that makes them easy to pick up with a brush and blend across the lid.
The formula does contain some shimmer, which several reviewers mentioned: “All three neutrals have a slight shimmer to them.” This effect creates a subtle luminosity rather than an intense glitter, making it appropriate for various settings from office wear to casual outings.
The sheerness of the formula makes it particularly forgiving for makeup beginners or those who prefer a more subdued look. As one user with pale skin noted, “This color combination works wonders with my eyes and shows through my darker brown glasses. Easy to apply and I don’t apply any primer and it stays on all day.”
However, this sheerness does mean you’ll need to build up the product for more noticeable color payoff: “I find the need to layer quite a bit to even notice the middle shade.” Some users also reported that the shadows can be somewhat “dusty” during application.
Application and Blendability
The Café Au Lait shadows blend easily, which is a significant advantage for creating seamless eye looks. Many reviewers praised how well the colors work together and how simple they are to apply: “This is easy to blend (with a makeup brush) and doesn’t look cakey.”
The palette comes with a double-ended applicator, but the general consensus among users is that this tool is subpar. As one reviewer candidly stated, “don’t bother with the dumb little wand it comes with it’s useless.” For best results, most recommend using proper eyeshadow brushes instead.
For those new to eyeshadow application, this palette is forgiving enough to allow for experimentation without dramatic mistakes. The buildable nature of the formula means you can start light and gradually intensify the look if desired.
Longevity and Wear Time
Opinions on the staying power of the Café Au Lait shadows are mixed. Some reviewers report satisfactory wear time: “I love that they last a long time, I don’t get a crease but I use a good shadow application brush also.” Another mentioned, “it stays on all day.”
However, others have experienced less impressive longevity: “The colors do not stay the whole day.” This discrepancy might be attributed to individual skin types, climate conditions, or the use of eyeshadow primers.
For optimal wear time, many users recommend applying these shadows over a primer. Without primer, you can expect moderate longevity of about 4-6 hours before noticeable fading, particularly with the lighter shades.
Versatility
One of the Café Au Lait palette’s strongest attributes is its versatility. The neutral color scheme makes it appropriate for virtually any occasion, from professional settings to casual outings. As one reviewer noted, “These are lovely colors that are truly natural and enhance the look of your eyes during the day or night. For evening wear, just apply a bit heavier color and a bit more shine.”
The palette works exceptionally well for creating subtle day looks but can be built up or paired with other products for evening wear. Several users mentioned its compatibility with various skin tones and eye colors: “These colors go well with my green eyes… it is hard to find something that will match green eyes AND go along with all of your outfit color choices!”
Another user with different coloring shared, “I have red hair and pale skin, and this is my go-to daily eyeshadow. Great value, defines my eyes without looking too harsh, and the colors are complementary and natural looking.”
Packaging and Durability
The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers comes in a compact plastic case with a transparent lid that allows you to see the colors without opening the product. While functional, the packaging isn’t particularly luxurious or sturdy.
Multiple reviewers reported receiving broken products, suggesting that the packaging may not provide adequate protection during shipping: “It banged it’s way to my house and arrived, not completely broken up, but definitely not as good as new.” Another mentioned, “Good colors, very soft. I wear it often. It arrived cracked, or I would have given it 5 stars.”
This appears to be particularly problematic when ordered online without protective packaging: “The package wasn’t properly packaged & thrown on the box along with other items. The white portion was chipped & broke to other color.”
For those purchasing in-store, this issue would likely be less of a concern. However, the somewhat fragile nature of the product is worth noting, especially for travel purposes.
Value for Money
At its budget-friendly price point, the Café Au Lait palette offers reasonable value, particularly for those seeking an everyday neutral option. As one reviewer succinctly put it, “The price is great, I hate spending tons of money on shadow.”
While the pigmentation isn’t as intense as higher-end alternatives, many users find the quality acceptable given the cost: “An old time favorite is back again. This is a great neutral daytime palette. I do wish the middle color was a bit more pigmented but, for the price, I can’t complain!”
The product also seems to last a reasonable amount of time with regular use, further enhancing its value proposition. However, some longstanding users have noted changes in the formula over time: “I have been using this eyeshadow a long time. It is a go to easy palette, but I did notice it is getting lighter and more shimmering. Not sure what is up with that.”
Suitability for Different Skin Tones and Eye Colors
The Café Au Lait palette appears to be most flattering on fair to medium skin tones, with many positive reviews coming from those with lighter complexions: “This color pallet is great for my pale complexion. I don’t wear heavy eye shadow, I just want a little color to brighten my face and make my eyes pop and this combo is great for that.”
The neutral brown tones complement various eye colors, with specific mentions of their effectiveness for blue and green eyes: “I have light blue eyes and this color combination works wonders with my eyes.” Another reviewer stated, “These colors go well with my green eyes.”
For those with deeper skin tones, the sheerness of the formula might be a limitation, as the colors may not show up as effectively without significant building.
Potential Skin Sensitivity
While most reviewers didn’t report any adverse reactions, one user mentioned developing an allergy: “The colour are beautiful. But I got an allergy.” As with any cosmetic product, individual sensitivities can vary, and patch testing is recommended if you have sensitive skin.
COVERGIRL doesn’t specifically market this product as hypoallergenic, but several reviewers with sensitive eyes reported no issues: “Non-irritating, pretty colors, awesome price…so, I’d call this a win!”
Ethical Considerations
COVERGIRL highlights that this product is “100% Cruelty-free,” which aligns with the increasing consumer demand for ethically produced cosmetics. In 2018, COVERGIRL became the largest makeup brand to achieve Leaping Bunny certification from Cruelty Free International, signifying their commitment to eliminating animal testing throughout their supply chain.
This cruelty-free status is a significant positive for conscious consumers looking to make more ethical beauty purchases without the higher price tags that often accompany prestige cruelty-free brands.
Comparison to Similar Products
In the drugstore price range, the COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 3-Kit competes with options like Maybelline’s The Nudes palette (which offers more shades but similar formula quality) and Neutrogena’s Nourishing Eye Quad (which typically has a creamier formula but fewer color options).
Compared to higher-end options like Urban Decay’s Naked palettes or Too Faced Natural Eyes, the COVERGIRL option offers significantly less pigmentation and staying power but at a fraction of the price.
For those seeking a budget-friendly everyday option, the Café Au Lait palette holds its own in the drugstore category, particularly for those who prefer subtle eye looks.
Product Evolution
Several long-term users noted changes in the formula over time: “The quality has decreased exponentially.” Another mentioned, “I have been using this eyeshadow a long time. It is a go to easy palette, but I did notice it is getting lighter and more shimmering.”
This suggests that COVERGIRL may have reformulated the product over the years, potentially affecting its performance. For those who have used and loved this palette in the past, it might be worth noting that the current version may differ somewhat from previous iterations.
Recommendations for Use
Based on the collective feedback, here are some tips for getting the most out of the Café Au Lait palette:
- Use proper eyeshadow brushes rather than the included applicator for better application and blending
- Apply over an eyeshadow primer to enhance color payoff and longevity
- Consider wetting your brush for more intense pigmentation, especially with the darker shade
- Layer the colors to build up intensity gradually
- Use the lightest shade as a brow bone highlight and inner corner brightener
- The middle shade works well as an all-over lid color or transition shade
- The darkest shade can be used to define the crease or as a soft liner
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Natural, flattering neutral colors
- Easy to blend and forgiving formula
- Suitable for everyday wear
- Appropriate for makeup beginners
- Budget-friendly price point
- Cruelty-free certification
- Versatile for various occasions
- Complements multiple eye colors
- Not cakey or heavy-looking
Cons:
- Limited pigmentation/sheer color payoff
- Some shimmer in all shades (not truly matte)
- Subpar included applicator
- Fragile packaging prone to breakage
- Moderate staying power without primer
- May require significant building for noticeable effect
- Potential formula inconsistency over time
- Some reports of dusty texture
Final Verdict
The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 3-Kit Eyeshadow in Café Au Lait is a solid, budget-friendly option for those seeking subtle, natural eye enhancement. It particularly excels as an everyday palette for office wear, casual outings, or situations where a more subdued makeup look is appropriate.
The palette’s greatest strengths lie in its user-friendly application, versatile neutral color scheme, and affordable price point. Its biggest limitations are the sheer pigmentation and potentially fragile packaging.
I would recommend this palette for:
- Makeup beginners looking for an easy-to-use starter palette
- Those with fair to medium skin tones
- People who prefer subtle, natural-looking eye makeup
- Budget-conscious shoppers
- Consumers prioritizing cruelty-free products
I would not recommend this palette for:
- Those seeking bold, intense eye looks
- People who prefer one-swipe, high-pigment formulas
- Those with deeper skin tones who may find the colors too sheer
- Makeup enthusiasts looking for a primarily matte finish
With an overall rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, the COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 3-Kit in Café Au Lait represents a reliable, if not revolutionary, addition to your everyday makeup collection. While it won’t replace your high-end palettes for special occasions, it serves its purpose as an affordable, versatile option for creating subtle eye looks with minimal effort.
In the world of beauty where trends come and go, this unassuming little trio has maintained its place in many makeup collections for good reason – sometimes, simple and subtle is exactly what you need.
Buy on Amazon: Here
