As a beauty professional who has spent years evaluating cosmetics across all price points, I’m thrilled to share my comprehensive review of COVERGIRL’s Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow in the shade Cranberry. This iconic single eyeshadow has maintained a loyal following for decades, and today I’ll examine whether it still deserves a place in your makeup collection in 2025.
Product Overview
Product: COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow
Shade: Cranberry
Price Point: Budget-friendly drugstore ($4-8 depending on retailer)
Key Features:
- Silky, sheer formula that can be built up
- Double-ended applicator included
- 100% Cruelty-free certification
- Matte finish (according to most reviewers)
Packaging & Presentation
The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers come in the brand’s signature square compact with a clear lid that allows you to see the shade inside. The packaging is practical rather than luxurious—lightweight plastic that’s travel-friendly but not particularly premium feeling. It’s worth noting that some reviewers mentioned COVERGIRL has recently changed the packaging from the traditional black container to a pale pink one, which apparently coincided with a formula change that some longtime users were disappointed by.
The compact includes a double-ended applicator—one end features a sponge-tip for application, and the other provides a small brush for blending. While most makeup enthusiasts prefer their own brushes, the included applicator is surprisingly functional for on-the-go touch-ups.
Color & Pigmentation
Despite the name “Cranberry,” according to the information provided, this shade appears to be an ivory/off-white color rather than a red or berry tone. This discrepancy between the name and actual color is important to note for online purchasers who can’t see the product in person.
The pigmentation receives mixed reviews. Many users praise its ability to provide subtle highlighting and brightness, while others note that it has “zero pigment” or requires significant building for color payoff. This sheer quality can be either a pro or con depending on your preferences—ideal for those seeking subtle enhancement but potentially disappointing for those wanting bold color.
Texture & Application
The texture is described as “silky” and “smooth” by many reviewers, allowing for easy blending. The shadow applies evenly on the lid without much effort. Several reviewers specifically mentioned that the product works better when applied with the included sponge applicator rather than a brush—an unusual recommendation that’s worth considering.
The formula appears to be on the drier side, with some reviewers describing it as “chalky” or “crumbly.” This texture contributes to minimal fallout during application for most users, though some mentioned the product arriving broken or crumbling easily.
Finish & Appearance
There seems to be some confusion among reviewers about whether this shadow has a matte or shimmer finish. While the product description mentions a “silky, sheer formula,” some reviewers specifically praise it for being matte (“I like matt finishes and this eye shadow is perfect”), while others describe it as having a “soft, shimmery sheen” or containing “glitter pieces.” This inconsistency might be due to the formula change mentioned by some longtime users.
When applied, the shadow provides a subtle brightness that enhances the eye area without looking overdone. Many reviewers specifically mentioned using it as a brow bone highlight or inner corner brightener rather than an all-over lid color.
Longevity & Wear
The wear time of this eyeshadow receives consistently positive feedback. Multiple reviewers mentioned that it “stays on all day” and “doesn’t crease” when applied over a base or primer. The shadow maintains its appearance throughout a normal day without significant fading or smudging.
Several reviewers specifically mentioned that it “doesn’t settle in the creases of the eyelid,” which is particularly important for mature skin or hooded eyes. This crease-resistant quality makes it a reliable option for all-day wear.
Versatility & Uses
What makes this eyeshadow particularly popular is its versatility. Reviewers mentioned using it for various purposes:
- Brow bone highlight: “Add under eyebrow for subtle highlighting”
- Base shadow: “Great base color”
- Under-eye brightener: “Brightens the eyes perfectly”
- All-over lid color: “For days I want a more natural look”
This multi-functional aspect provides excellent value, allowing you to achieve several effects with a single product.
Special Considerations
For Mature Skin
Several reviewers over 40 specifically mentioned this eyeshadow works well for mature skin, especially appreciating the presumably matte version: “Love this shadow and it’s a matte so even better, no glitter if over age of 40 years old is hard to find.”
For Sensitive Eyes
There were very few mentions of irritation in the reviews, with just one reviewer noting: “It made my eyes itchy and watery.” This suggests the formula is generally well-tolerated, but as with any eye product, those with sensitivities should patch test first.
Formula Changes
A significant concern raised by multiple reviewers is an apparent formula change. Some longtime users mentioned that COVERGIRL has altered the formula, resulting in “zero pigment or retention” and more glitter than the original version. This is important for those who have used and loved this product in the past.
Value & Availability
This eyeshadow provides excellent value for its price point. Many reviewers mentioned purchasing it when it was on sale or with coupons, sometimes for as little as $0.50. Even at full price, the pan size is generous: “I like that the pan size is big enough that I’m not struggling to get the shadow onto the brush.”
Several reviewers mentioned difficulty finding this product in physical stores, suggesting COVERGIRL might be phasing out this particular packaging or formulation. This has led many loyal users to purchase online to ensure they can continue using their favorite shade.
Shipping & Handling Concerns
A recurring issue mentioned in numerous reviews is the product arriving broken or “smashed to smithereens.” This appears to be a packaging problem during shipping rather than a product flaw. Several reviewers recommended purchasing from sellers who package the item properly to avoid receiving a compact full of loose powder.
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Budget-friendly price point
- Versatile usage (highlight, base, all-over color)
- Long-wearing formula that resists creasing
- Subtle, natural-looking enhancement
- Cruelty-free certification
- Generous pan size
Cons:
- Inconsistent packaging and possible formula changes
- Shipping issues resulting in broken product
- Sheer pigmentation may disappoint those wanting bold color
- Some find the texture too dry or chalky
- Confusion about whether the finish is matte or shimmery
Who Should Buy This Eyeshadow?
This COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers eyeshadow in Cranberry is ideal for:
- Makeup minimalists seeking subtle enhancement
- Budget-conscious beauty enthusiasts who want quality without high cost
- Mature makeup wearers looking for age-appropriate highlighting
- Beginners who appreciate forgiving, easy-to-blend formulas
- Longtime fans of the original formula (though be aware of potential formula changes)
Who Should Skip It?
This product might not satisfy:
- Bold color enthusiasts seeking high-impact pigmentation
- Those who dislike shimmer (if the current formulation indeed has shimmer)
- Luxury makeup users accustomed to creamier, more buttery textures
Final Verdict
The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow in Cranberry offers exceptional value for its modest price point. While it won’t compete with high-end luxury eyeshadows in terms of packaging or intensity, it excels at providing subtle, foolproof enhancement that works for everyday wear.
The product’s greatest strengths lie in its versatility, longevity, and user-friendly application. Its greatest weaknesses include inconsistent formulation and shipping vulnerability.
For those seeking a reliable, budget-friendly eyeshadow that enhances rather than overpowers, this COVERGIRL classic deserves consideration—particularly if you can find a reliable seller who packages it properly for shipping.
Rating: 4/5 stars
The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow in Cranberry earns 4 out of 5 stars for delivering consistent performance and versatility at an accessible price point. While formula changes and packaging issues prevent a perfect score, the product’s enduring popularity over decades speaks to its effectiveness for everyday enhancement.
This review is based on accumulated customer feedback and professional assessment of the COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow in Cranberry. Individual experiences may vary depending on skin type, application technique, and specific product batch.
Buy on Amazon: Here
