Let me just start by saying what we’re ALL thinking – finding the perfect eyebrow pencil is SERIOUSLY like finding a needle in a haystack! Especially for those of us blessed (cursed?) with lighter brows. So when I got my hands on the COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil in Soft Blonde, I was both hopeful and skeptical. After extensive testing, I’ve got THOUGHTS. Buckle up, because I’m giving you the unfiltered truth about this product!
First Impressions & Packaging
The pencil comes in typical COVERGIRL packaging – nothing fancy, just practical. It has a twist-up mechanism so NO SHARPENING REQUIRED (thank goodness) and includes a built-in spoolie brush on the opposite end. Pretty standard stuff.
BUT HERE’S MY FIRST GRIPE – and you’ll see this complaint come up A LOT. The actual product amount is TINY. We’re talking less than an inch of actual product inside this pencil. The first time I twisted it up, I was honestly shocked at how little product was in there compared to all the plastic packaging. Major environmental fail, if you ask me! If you’re someone who does their brows daily, prepare to repurchase this OFTEN.
The Perfect Blonde? FINALLY!
Okay, on to the good stuff. The color “Soft Blonde” is an absolute GAME CHANGER for light-haired folks. If you’ve ever struggled with finding a blonde eyebrow product that doesn’t pull orange or reddish (WHY do companies think all blondes have reddish brows?!), this might be your holy grail.
The color is a neutral taupe that works amazingly well for:
- Natural blondes
- Light brown hair
- Even platinum blondes
- People with gray hair
- Those with very sparse brows wanting a natural fill
Multiple reviewers (myself included) who have tried high-end products like Anastasia Beverly Hills and Benefit have found this color to be SUPERIOR for blonde brows. Several makeup artists have even mentioned using this shade on clients with varying hair colors because it’s so versatile.
One genius tip I discovered: If you have darker hair but want a more natural look, the blonde shade can actually work better than a brunette pencil! Just build it up with a few more layers.
Application & Performance
The micro-fine tip is what makes this pencil stand out. It creates those fine, hair-like strokes that make your brows look NATURAL rather than drawn-on. The pencil has a somewhat waxy consistency which has pros and cons:
PROS:
- Glides on smoothly without tugging
- Buildable color (go light for subtle or layer for bold)
- Creates a blended, natural look
- Easy to control the application
- Works well even on bare skin with no brow hairs
- You can easily tone down with a quick press of your hand if you go too heavy
CONS:
- Not the best for super precise, defined strokes
- The tip breaks EASILY if extended too far (seriously, keep it short!)
- The waxy formula means it’s not completely smudge-proof
- Doesn’t stand up well to heat, humidity, or sweat
- Needs to be set with a brow gel or setting spray for all-day wear
For longevity, it’s middle-of-the-road. Many users report it lasting all day with normal wear, but if you’re sweating or in humid conditions, expect some fading. The good news is it’s easy to touch up if needed.
Actual Real-Life Scenarios Where This Pencil SHINES
- Post-chemo brow regrowth: Multiple reviewers mentioned this pencil was a lifesaver during cancer recovery when their brows were sparse or nonexistent
- Aging brows: As we get older, our brows naturally thin out and can gray – this pencil covers grays and fills in gaps seamlessly
- Naturally blonde/invisible brows: If you have those super light, barely-there blonde brows that disappear in photos, this gives definition without looking harsh
- Makeup beginners: The forgiving formula means no harsh lines or “Sharpie brow” effect that’s common with stiffer pencils
Price vs. Value
Here’s where things get complicated. The pencil is INCREDIBLY affordable compared to high-end alternatives – usually around $7-10 depending on where you buy it. That’s one-third the price of Benefit or Anastasia!
BUT…and this is a BIG but…it runs out EXTREMELY quickly. Numerous users (myself included) report finishing a pencil in 1-2 weeks of daily use. When you do the math on cost-per-use, it’s not as budget-friendly as it initially seems.
Some users mentioned that they previously thought they were getting two pencils in a package based on the product images, but it’s just one pencil. That’s something to be aware of when ordering.
Comparisons to Higher-End Products
I’ve tried it all – Benefit Precisely My Brow, Anastasia Brow Wiz, Lancôme Le Crayon, and honestly, this COVERGIRL pencil holds its own in terms of color and application. Where it falls short is:
- Product amount (high-end brands give you more product)
- Longevity (higher-end products tend to be more waterproof/sweatproof)
- Precision (some high-end pencils create more defined hair strokes)
But for the color match alone, especially for blondes, many reviewers (including me) actually PREFER this over the expensive options! Several people mentioned ditching their $20+ pencils for this one.
The Breakage Issue: IMPORTANT WARNING!
I can’t stress this enough – this pencil breaks EASILY. To avoid wasting product:
- Never twist up more than 1-2mm of product
- Apply with a light hand
- Store it in a cool place (heat makes it even more fragile)
Many users report receiving the product already broken or having the entire pencil lead fall out upon first use. This seems to be a quality control issue that COVERGIRL needs to address.
Who Should Buy This?
YOU’LL LOVE THIS IF:
- You have blonde, light brown, or gray hair and struggle to find the right shade
- You want a natural, blended brow look rather than sharp, Instagram-perfect brows
- You’re on a budget (but willing to repurchase often)
- You have sparse or thin brows that need filling
- You’re new to brow products and want something forgiving
SKIP THIS IF:
- You need waterproof, all-day wear without touch-ups
- You want very precise, defined brows with clear hair strokes
- You’re looking for value in terms of product amount
- You have very dark hair (though some brunettes do use it for a softer look)
My Personal Experience & Final Verdict
After using this pencil daily for three weeks, I’m honestly conflicted. The color is PERFECT for my light brown hair – no reddish tones, just a beautiful taupe that looks completely natural. The application is smooth and easy, and I can create natural-looking brows in under a minute.
BUT I’ve already gone through almost two pencils! And yes, the breaking issue is REAL. I lost about 1/4 of my first pencil to breakage before I learned to barely extend the tip.
Would I repurchase? Reluctantly, YES. Despite the flaws, the color match and natural finish keep me coming back. But I’m definitely stocking up when there’s a sale, and I’m still on the hunt for a longer-lasting alternative with this exact color.
OVERALL RATING: 3.5/5 stars
PROS:
- Perfect neutral blonde color without red/orange tones
- Creates natural-looking brows
- Affordable price point
- Easy application with micro-fine tip
- Built-in spoolie works well for blending
- Cruelty-free (COVERGIRL is 100% cruelty-free now!)
CONS:
- Minimal product amount (less than an inch of actual product!)
- Breaks easily, leading to waste
- Not long-wearing in hot/humid conditions
- Excessive plastic packaging for tiny amount of product
THE BOTTOM LINE: It’s the Goldilocks of blonde brow pencils – the color is JUST RIGHT, but you’ll be replacing it constantly. Worth it for the perfect shade? For me, grudgingly, yes!
Has anyone else found a dupe with this exact color but more product? Let me know in the comments!
Buy on Amazon: Here
