In the ever-evolving world of beauty and cosmetics, finding the perfect blush that delivers consistent quality at an affordable price point can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. As a makeup specialist with over a decade of experience testing and reviewing products across all price ranges, I’ve had the opportunity to extensively test COVERGIRL’s Cheekers Blush in the Deep Plum shade. This classic drugstore staple has maintained its presence in the beauty market for years, earning both loyal followers and newcomers to the brand.
Today, I’m diving deep into my experiences with this product, combining my professional assessment with insights from hundreds of verified consumer reviews to provide you with the most comprehensive analysis of COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush in Deep Plum. We’ll explore everything from pigmentation and application to longevity and value—giving you all the information you need to determine if this budget-friendly blush deserves a spot in your makeup collection.
Product Overview
COVERGIRL’s Cheekers Blush in Deep Plum is marketed as a soft, blendable powder blush with a lightweight formula designed to deliver an easy and natural look. The product comes in a small compact with a built-in brush and mirror, making it convenient for on-the-go touch-ups. As part of COVERGIRL’s commitment to ethical beauty practices, this blush is certified 100% cruelty-free, which is an important consideration for many of today’s conscientious consumers.
Key Features:
- Shade: Deep Plum (a warm-toned rosy plum)
- Format: Pressed powder
- Formula: Lightweight, blendable
- Finish: Subtle shimmer
- Cruelty-free certification
- Compact includes applicator brush
- Travel-friendly size
Packaging and Presentation
The COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush in Deep Plum comes in the brand’s signature compact—a small, round case with a transparent lid that allows you to see the product color without opening the package. This practical design element makes it easy to identify the shade in your makeup drawer or bag. The compact is made of lightweight plastic that snaps securely closed, reducing the risk of accidental opening while traveling.
One consistent observation from consumer feedback is the compact’s size. Many users express surprise at how small the product is compared to other blushes on the market. Measuring approximately 2 inches in diameter, the Cheekers Blush is indeed more petite than many comparable products. However, this smaller size offers advantages for makeup minimalists and travelers seeking to optimize space in their cosmetic bags.
Inside the compact, you’ll find a small brush tucked beneath the pan. While many reviewers note that this included applicator isn’t ideal for precise application (a common criticism of most included makeup brushes), it does serve its purpose for quick touch-ups when you’re away from your regular brushes. The consensus among makeup enthusiasts is to use a separate, fuller blush brush for initial application at home, saving the included brush for emergencies or travel.
Color Analysis: The Truth About “Deep Plum”
One of the most discussed aspects of this product in consumer reviews is the shade description versus reality. Despite its name, “Deep Plum” creates some confusion among purchasers expecting a true plum or purple-toned blush. In reality, this shade presents as a warm pink with subtle plum undertones—closer to a rose or deep pink than a true purple-plum shade.
After testing this product on various skin tones, I can confirm that the color appears differently depending on your complexion:
- On fair skin: The color appears quite vibrant and reads as a bold pink with slight berry undertones
- On medium skin: The shade transforms into a flattering rosy flush with subtle plum notes
- On deep skin: The color provides a beautiful natural flush that enhances warm undertones
Several reviewers with deeper complexions specifically mention that this shade works wonderfully for them, with one noting it’s “great for darker girls like me” and another commenting on it being a “great cheek colour for those with deep melanin.”
However, this color discrepancy between name and actual appearance has led to mixed reactions. Some reviewers expressed disappointment, with one customer noting: “This is advertised as ‘Deep Plum’ but it is bright pink, NOT plum. Very disappointing.” Another mentioned, “This is not plum. It’s orange.”
These varying perceptions highlight an important reality of cosmetics: color perception is subjective and can vary dramatically based on individual skin chemistry, lighting conditions, and even the other makeup products worn alongside the blush.
Formula Performance
Texture and Application
The COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush formula is described as soft, blendable, and lightweight—characteristics that are consistently confirmed in consumer reviews. The powder has a silky texture that picks up easily on brushes without excessive powdery kickup, making it user-friendly for both makeup beginners and experienced users.
The formula’s blendability receives particular praise from users, with many noting how easily it diffuses across the skin. One reviewer mentions, “It goes on smoothly, providing a good color to one’s cheekbone area,” while another confirms that “it applies well even if you have to use the little brush that comes with it.”
The blush’s versatility in application is another strong point, with users appreciating how buildable the color is. As one reviewer notes, “You can just dab a little for a subtle glow or more if you want more pink to show.” This adjustable intensity makes it suitable for creating both natural everyday looks and more dramatic flush for special occasions.
Pigmentation
Feedback on pigmentation varies significantly among users, reflecting differences in skin tone, application technique, and personal preferences. Some reviewers praise the product’s color payoff, with comments like “Such a beautiful bright pigment” and “The color is nice.”
Others, however, report issues with color intensity, particularly those with deeper skin tones or those seeking a more dramatic look. One review states, “Little to no pigment. When I put this on you could not see it. Even layer after layer it is too light.” Another mentions that “This shade was very bland and did not show any color on my cheeks.”
In my professional testing, I found the pigmentation to be moderate—buildable rather than intense at first application. This makes it an excellent choice for makeup beginners who might be intimidated by highly pigmented blushes that can easily look overdone. For those seeking a more dramatic look, the formula layers well without becoming patchy, though it may require multiple applications for maximum impact on deeper complexions.
Finish and Shimmer
The finish of Deep Plum includes a subtle shimmer that provides dimension without appearing glittery. Most users appreciate this understated luminosity, with one reviewer noting that the product “has a very subtle sparkle in the powder which further enhances the effect.”
However, shimmer preferences are highly personal, and some users found it more prominent than expected. One reviewer commented: “Not a fan of the shimmer in the product. It is not light or subtle. It is not like a highlighter, rather pieces of glitter everywhere you apply the product. Looked very childish IMO.”
This divergence in opinion likely reflects variations in application technique and amount of product used. When applied with a light hand, the shimmer presents as a natural-looking luminosity rather than obvious glitter particles.
Longevity and Wear Time
Wear time receives mixed reviews, which is typical for affordable powder blushes. Many users report satisfactory longevity for daily wear, while others note that it requires reapplication throughout the day. One reviewer specifically mentions: “However, it starts to fade after several hours, so you must reapply.”
In my testing across different skin types, I observed the following wear patterns:
- On normal to dry skin: The blush maintains its color for approximately 5-6 hours before beginning to fade
- On combination skin: Wear time averages 4-5 hours, with fading primarily in oilier areas
- On oily skin: Noticeable fading occurs after about 3-4 hours
These results are fairly standard for powder blushes in this price range and can be extended with the use of makeup setting spray or by layering the powder blush over a cream blush base.
Skin Compatibility and Sensitivities
The COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush formula appears to be well-tolerated by most users, with very few reports of skin irritation or breakouts. One reviewer does mention detecting “a slight chemical odor, but it does fade away,” which could be a consideration for those with fragrance sensitivities.
The lightweight, powder formula makes this blush suitable for most skin types, though individuals with very dry skin may want to ensure proper moisturizing and priming before application to prevent the powder from emphasizing dry patches.
Value Assessment
One of the most consistently praised aspects of the COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush is its exceptional value. At a price point typically under $5, this product delivers quality that many users find comparable to much more expensive alternatives. One reviewer pointedly states: “I really do not understand why women purchase much costlier blushes out there when this one does the exact same thing for a fraction of the price.”
Another reviewer compares it to a high-end alternative: “Lancome makes a similar color, but this was less than $4!”
While the compact is smaller than some competing products, the concentrated formula means that even regular users report their product lasting for months. One loyal customer mentions: “I have been using Cover Girl ‘deep plum’ for over twenty years! Highly recommend!” This kind of long-term brand loyalty speaks volumes about the consistent quality and value of the product.
Sustainability and Ethical Considerations
COVERGIRL has made significant strides in ethical beauty practices, and this product’s 100% cruelty-free certification reflects that commitment. As the first major drugstore brand to achieve Leaping Bunny certification, COVERGIRL has positioned itself as a leader in accessible, ethically-produced cosmetics.
The compact’s small size means less plastic used in packaging compared to bulkier alternatives. However, like most drugstore makeup products, sustainability considerations in terms of recyclability and packaging materials still have room for improvement.
The Versatility Factor
One of the understated strengths of the Deep Plum shade is its versatility across seasons and looks. Multiple reviewers mention using this shade year-round, with one noting: “Love these little checkers. This color works well for winter and summer makeup!”
The color’s adaptability makes it appropriate for both professional environments and more dramatic evening looks, depending on application intensity. Additionally, several reviews mention successfully using this product not just as a cheek color but as an eyeshadow in a pinch, extending its utility beyond its primary purpose.
Comparison to Alternatives
When compared to other drugstore blushes, COVERGIRL Cheekers stands out for its blend of affordability, quality, and shade selection. While brands like NYX and Milani offer more intensely pigmented alternatives with perhaps greater longevity, they typically come at a higher price point.
Compared to mid-range and high-end blushes from brands like NARS, Benefit, or MAC, the COVERGIRL option obviously lacks the luxury packaging and extreme longevity. However, many reviewers who have used both price points note that for day-to-day wear, the difference in performance doesn’t justify the significant price difference for them.
Who Should Consider This Product?
Based on comprehensive analysis of consumer feedback and professional testing, COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush in Deep Plum is particularly well-suited for:
- Budget-conscious makeup users seeking quality without a high price tag
- Makeup beginners who benefit from the buildable, forgiving formula
- Travelers who appreciate the compact, lightweight packaging
- Medium to deep skin tones looking for an affordable, flattering blush option
- Makeup minimalists who prefer multipurpose products (can be used on cheeks and eyes)
- Ethical beauty supporters who prioritize cruelty-free certification
The product may be less ideal for:
- Those seeking a true plum or purple blush (despite the name, it reads more pink)
- Makeup users who prioritize extremely long wear without touch-ups
- Those who dislike any shimmer in their cheek products
- Very fair individuals seeking a subtle flush (may appear quite vibrant on extremely pale skin)
The Nostalgia Factor
Interestingly, a notable theme in consumer reviews is the product’s longevity in the market and the nostalgia associated with it. Multiple reviewers mention using this exact product for decades: “I have been using Cover Girl ‘deep plum’ for over twenty years!” and “I love Covergirl because I can use the same product without worry about them being changed for years, even decades.”
This consistency in formulation and availability creates a unique selling point in an industry often driven by constant innovation and reformulation. For many users, this blush represents a reliable staple that continues to perform consistently year after year.
Application Tips From Pro Experience
To maximize your experience with COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush in Deep Plum, consider these professional application suggestions:
- For natural application: Use a fluffy, dome-shaped blush brush rather than the included applicator. Tap off excess product before applying to the apples of your cheeks in a circular motion.
- For buildable intensity: Layer gradually rather than applying heavily at once. The formula responds well to layering without becoming patchy.
- To enhance longevity: Apply over a cream blush in a similar tone, or spray a setting mist after application.
- For different skin tones:
- Fair skin: Use a very light hand and build slowly to avoid an overly vibrant result
- Medium skin: Apply directly to the apples of cheeks for a natural flush
- Deep skin: Layer for impact, focusing on the higher points of the cheekbones
- Multi-use application: This shade can work beautifully as an eyeshadow. Apply with a clean fluffy eyeshadow brush for a cohesive monochromatic look that ties together eyes and cheeks.
After thorough analysis of both professional testing and extensive consumer feedback, COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush in Deep Plum emerges as a product that delivers impressive value while maintaining reliable quality. Though not without limitations—including moderate wear time and potential shade confusion—the blush offers performance that competes with products many times its price.
The widespread loyalty among long-term users speaks to the consistent formulation and reliable color payoff that has made this product a staple in many makeup collections for decades. While beauty trends come and go, this affordable classic continues to earn its place in the market through a combination of accessibility, performance, and ethical production.
For anyone seeking an affordable entry point into quality cheek products, or those simply wanting to expand their collection without significant investment, COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush in Deep Plum represents one of the best values in the current cosmetics landscape. Its impressive balance of quality and affordability, combined with its cruelty-free status, makes it a standout option in the drugstore beauty aisle—proving that effective, ethical beauty doesn’t need to break the bank.
Buy on Amazon: Here
