Hey beauty lovers! I’ve spent the last few weeks getting up close and personal with COVERGIRL’s Cheekers Blendable Powder Blush in Pretty Peach. This little compact has been a staple in many makeup bags for YEARS, and I wanted to find out if it still holds up in today’s competitive beauty market. Spoiler alert: there’s a reason why this blush has such staying power!
First Impressions & Packaging
When my COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush arrived, it came in proper protective packaging – no crushed makeup drama here! The compact is small and lightweight, making it perfect for travel or tossing in your purse. The size might surprise you if you’re used to larger blush compacts, but don’t let that fool you – there’s plenty of product inside.
The packaging itself is nothing fancy – simple plastic with a clear top so you can see the color. It’s basic but functional, which is exactly what you’d expect at this price point. The compact includes a small brush that tucks underneath the product. Is it the best brush ever? No way. But it’ll get the job done in a pinch!
The Color: Is “Pretty Peach” Actually Peachy?
This is where things get interesting! The color in the pan appears to be a warm peachy shade with a touch of pink and a hint of shimmer. However, once applied, many users (myself included) find it pulls a bit more pink than true peach. This isn’t necessarily bad – it gives a beautiful natural flush that works on multiple skin tones.
For those with fair skin, Pretty Peach adds a perfect “just came in from the cold” natural flush. What surprised me is how well it works on deeper skin tones too! It gives a subtle warm glow without looking ashy or too bright.
One reviewer summed it up perfectly: “The shade is warm and looks great on my skin tone (fair) and my daughter’s (deep).” That versatility is RARE to find in a single shade!
If you’re hunting for a true coral-peach with no pink undertones, you might find this pulls a bit too rosy. But if you want that “sun-kissed” healthy glow, this delivers.
Application & Texture
The texture of the Cheekers blush is on the firmer side, which is actually a GOOD thing for beginners or rushed mornings! It’s practically impossible to overdo it, making it what one reviewer called “mistake proof.” The firmer texture means you don’t get tons of powder kickup or fallout – your other makeup stays intact.
The blush builds up gradually, letting you control the intensity. One light swipe gives a subtle hint of color, while a few more builds it to a more noticeable flush. For those with deeper skin tones, you might need to build it up more, but the color does show up.
The downside to the firmer texture? You have to work a bit harder to pick up product on your brush. The included brush isn’t ideal for this, so I’d recommend using your own fluffy blush brush for the best application.
The Shimmer Factor
Let’s talk about the shimmer! Pretty Peach has what I’d call a satin finish with very subtle shimmer – it’s definitely not matte, but it’s not glittery either. The shimmer translates to a natural-looking glow on the skin rather than visible sparkle particles.
Some reviewers mentioned being surprised by the amount of shimmer, while others barely noticed it. In natural lighting, it gives that “lit from within” effect without emphasizing texture or pores. In more dramatic lighting, you might catch a subtle gleam, but it’s never over the top.
If you absolutely hate ANY shimmer in blush, this might not be for you. But if you’re okay with a touch of radiance, you’ll probably love how it makes your skin look healthy and vibrant.
Staying Power: Will It Last?
For a drugstore blush, the longevity is surprisingly good! Most reviewers (including myself) found it lasts a solid 6-8 hours before fading. It fades evenly rather than patching, which is a huge plus.
Some reviewers mentioned needing to reapply after about 4 hours, particularly those with oilier skin. If you have very oily skin or need it to last through a long day, you might want to set it with a translucent powder or use a primer underneath.
One user in her 70s who’s been using this blush for OVER 50 YEARS(!) commented on its consistent quality and staying power – if that’s not a testament to its reliability, I don’t know what is!
Value for Money
Let’s be real – one of the best things about this blush is the PRICE! At under $6, it’s an absolute steal. You could buy 5-6 of these for the price of one high-end blush, and honestly, the quality rivals products 3-4 times its price.
Yes, the packaging is simple, and yes, the included brush isn’t amazing. But the product itself performs beautifully where it counts. As one reviewer put it, “And the price, it’s a magical unicorn.”
Several reviewers mentioned switching from high-end counter brands to this COVERGIRL blush and being pleasantly surprised by the quality. One reviewer shared: “Years ago I squandered a ton of money on ‘make up counter beauty products’, but no more. I’m finding products just as good at a fraction of the price!”
The Downside (Yes, There Are Some!)
No product is perfect, so let’s talk about the cons:
- The included brush – It’s small and not the best quality. Many reviewers recommended using your own brush.
- Color accuracy – If you’re expecting a true peach, you might be surprised by how pink it can pull on some skin tones.
- Product firmness – The firmer texture means it can be a bit difficult to pick up product if you’re used to softer, more pigmented blushes.
- Size – Some longtime users mentioned the product seems smaller than it used to be. While this is a common complaint across many beauty products, it’s worth noting.
- Pigmentation inconsistency – A few reviewers found it didn’t show up well on their skin, while others found it plenty pigmented. This likely depends on application technique and skin tone.
Who Is This Perfect For?
This blush is IDEAL for:
- Makeup beginners who want something fool-proof
- Anyone on a budget who doesn’t want to sacrifice quality
- People with fair to medium skin tones (though it works on deeper tones too with more building)
- Those who prefer a natural, “your cheeks but better” look
- Busy people who need quick, reliable makeup
- Anyone who wants a touch of natural-looking glow
One reviewer called it part of her “5 minute makeup staples” for rushed mornings, saying it’s “fast and mistake proof” – I couldn’t agree more!
Final Thoughts: Is It Worth Your Money?
100% YES! The COVERGIRL Cheekers Blendable Powder Blush in Pretty Peach delivers reliable performance at an unbeatable price. It’s not the most exciting or innovative product on the market, but it WORKS, and sometimes that’s exactly what you need.
This blush has stood the test of time for good reason. It gives a natural, healthy flush that enhances your features without looking makeup-y. The subtle shimmer adds dimension without emphasizing texture. And the buildable formula means you can customize the intensity to your preference.
For less than the price of a fancy coffee, you get a quality blush that can hang with products many times its price. Whether you’re a makeup newbie or a seasoned beauty lover looking to save some cash, this little compact deserves a spot in your collection.
The fact that so many reviewers mentioned using this product for DECADES speaks volumes about its consistent quality. As one 55-year-old reviewer with sensitive skin noted: “Been using this brand and color for years. Am light complected, do not tan, and have very sensitive skin. I use Clinique for everything BUT this blush.”
If you’ve been struggling to find Pretty Peach in stores (which many reviewers mentioned), grab it online while you can! This shade seems to have a dedicated following that keeps coming back year after year.
Bottom line: In a world of $30+ blushes, COVERGIRL’s Cheekers in Pretty Peach proves you don’t need to break the bank for beautiful makeup. It’s a true drugstore gem that delivers reliable performance every time!
Rating Breakdown:
- Color/Pigmentation: 4/5 (Pulls pinker than expected but beautiful nonetheless)
- Application: 4.5/5 (Buildable, fool-proof application)
- Longevity: 3.5/5 (Good for the price, may need touch-ups)
- Packaging/Brush: 2.5/5 (Functional but basic; included brush is mediocre)
- Value: 5/5 (Unbeatable price for the quality)
- Overall Score: 4/5 stars
Have you tried this blush? I’d love to hear your experiences in the comments! And if you have any questions about this product, drop them below – I’m happy to help!
Buy on Amazon: Here
