Hey beauty lovers! I’ve been testing the COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil in shade 705 – Rich Brown for a while now, and I’m excited to share my HONEST thoughts with you!
First Impressions & Packaging
When I first got this pencil, I was immediately drawn to its slim, sleek design. The dual-ended feature is super practical – one end has the micro-fine tip for filling in brows, and the other end has a spoolie brush for blending. The Rich Brown shade looks exactly as shown online, which is a major plus since shopping for makeup colors online can be SUCH a gamble!
However, I need to mention something important right away – several users (myself included) have noticed that the actual product amount is surprisingly small. One reviewer even measured the actual liner and found it to be LESS THAN 1 INCH long! That’s a lot of plastic packaging for not much product. Not great for the environment or your wallet in the long run.
Application & Performance
The Good
- The micro-fine tip is PERFECT for creating hair-like strokes that look super natural
- The pencil doesn’t require sharpening (huge time-saver!)
- The color goes on smoothly without too much pressure for most users
- The built-in spoolie brush is actually good quality and helps blend everything beautifully
- It’s great for defining the brow line and adding extra color to sparse areas
- For those with darker brows, the Rich Brown shade is a true brown without any reddish undertones (this is rare in drugstore brow products!)
The Not-So-Good
- Several users mentioned the pencil can break easily if you’re not careful
- Some people found the product to be on the waxy side, which can make it harder to wipe off if you apply too much
- The mechanism that twists up the product doesn’t always stay in place, which can be frustrating
- It’s not waterproof, though it is somewhat smudge and sweat-resistant
- The product runs out VERY quickly for many users – some said it only lasted 2-3 weeks with daily use
Color & Pigmentation
The Rich Brown shade is a true winner for those with dark brown hair. Many reviewers specifically mentioned that unlike other drugstore brow pencils that can have reddish undertones, this one is a true cool brown. This makes it especially great for people with black or cool-toned brown hair.
The pigmentation is moderate – it’s not too intense right away, which actually helps create a more natural look. You can build it up gradually for more definition. This makes it super versatile whether you want a subtle filled-in brow or something more dramatic.
Longevity & Wear
This is where opinions seem to vary the most. Many users report that the pencil stays on all day without smudging, even with sweat. However, a few mentioned it fades more easily than they’d like. It’s definitely not waterproof, but it holds up reasonably well throughout a normal day.
The BIGGEST complaint across reviews is how quickly the product runs out. Many loyal users love the pencil but wish it lasted longer. Some report needing to replace it every 2-3 weeks with daily use, which can add up cost-wise even though the initial price point is affordable.
Value for Money
Speaking of price! At around $7, this pencil is definitely on the more affordable side compared to high-end brow products that can cost $20-30. Many reviewers who previously used more expensive brands like IT Cosmetics or MAC mentioned that this COVERGIRL pencil performs just as well at a fraction of the price.
However, the short lifespan of each pencil means you might end up buying replacements more frequently. Some users recommend keeping a backup on hand since it’s hard to gauge when it’s about to run out completely.
Comparison to Competitors
Several reviews compared this pencil to other brands:
- Some found it comparable to MAC’s brow pencil in the shade “Stud” (which costs significantly more)
- Others mentioned it’s better than Maybelline’s similar product because it doesn’t smudge as easily
- A few compared it favorably to IT Cosmetics’ brow pencil at a much lower price point
The main advantages over competitors seem to be the true brown color without red undertones, the fine tip that creates natural-looking strokes, and the price point.
Special Features
The 100% cruelty-free status is a HUGE plus for many consumers! Several reviewers specifically mentioned this as a deciding factor in their purchase. COVERGIRL has committed to not testing on animals, which is something more and more beauty consumers are looking for.
The no-sharpening-required feature is also a significant convenience factor that many users appreciate. The retractable design means you’re not constantly looking for a sharpener or dealing with pencil shavings.
Who Is This Pencil Best For?
Based on the reviews, this pencil seems particularly well-suited for:
- People with sparse brows who need precise, hair-like strokes
- Those with dark brown to black hair looking for a true brown without reddish tints
- Anyone transitioning between brow tinting appointments
- Makeup users who prefer a natural, defined look rather than a heavy, filled-in brow
- Budget-conscious shoppers who still want quality performance
Tips for Best Use
From my experience and other reviewers’ comments, here are some tips to get the most out of this pencil:
- Be gentle when twisting up the product to avoid breakage
- Only twist up a small amount at a time to prevent the tip from breaking off
- Use light, feathery strokes for the most natural look
- The spoolie brush is key for blending – don’t skip this step!
- Keep a backup on hand since it can be hard to tell when it’s about to run out
- If you find it’s too waxy, try warming it slightly before application (just hold it between your fingers for a few seconds)
The Verdict
OVERALL, the COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil is a solid drugstore option that performs impressively well for its price point. It creates natural-looking brows with precise definition and comes in a true brown shade that works beautifully for many hair colors.
The main drawbacks are its short lifespan and the small amount of product you actually get. However, even with more frequent repurchasing, it still remains more economical than many high-end alternatives.
Would I recommend it? ABSOLUTELY – especially if you’re looking for a budget-friendly brow pencil that delivers results comparable to much more expensive products. Just be prepared to replace it more frequently than you might expect!
Pros:
- Affordable price point (~$7)
- Creates natural-looking, hair-like strokes
- True brown color without reddish undertones
- Built-in quality spoolie brush
- No sharpening required
- 100% cruelty-free
- Easy to apply and blend
- Good for sparse brows
Cons:
- Runs out quickly (2-3 weeks for many daily users)
- Very small amount of actual product
- Can break easily if not careful
- Not waterproof
- Twisting mechanism can be unreliable
If you’ve been curious about trying this brow pencil, I say go for it! Just grab a couple at once so you don’t run out unexpectedly. At this price point, it’s definitely worth trying, especially if you’ve been spending more on high-end brow products without seeing significantly better results.
Have you tried this COVERGIRL brow pencil? What’s YOUR go-to brow product? I’d love to hear your thoughts!
Buy on Amazon: Here
