Hey there! I’ve been testing and reviewing beauty products for YEARS, and today I’m diving deep into the COVERGIRL+OLAY Simply Ageless 3-in-1 Liquid Foundation, specifically in the shade Soft Honey. After going through hundreds of real user reviews and my own experience, I’m giving you the unfiltered truth about this drugstore foundation that’s gained quite the following among mature women.
First Impressions & Packaging
Let’s talk about what you get right out of the box. The Simply Ageless foundation comes in a pump bottle that’s practical and hygienic (when it arrives intact… more on that later 😬). The pump dispenser is designed to give you control over how much product you use, which I really appreciate!
BUT – I need to address something right away. MANY customers reported receiving their foundation without the protective cap or with broken seals. Some even found makeup residue on the bottle, suggesting it might have been opened or used. This is NOT okay, especially for facial products that go on your skin. If you receive a product like this, don’t use it – return it immediately!
The Formula: What Makes It Special?
This isn’t just any foundation – it’s a collaboration between COVERGIRL and OLAY, combining makeup with skincare benefits. The formula contains:
- Moisturizing properties from OLAY
- Anti-aging ingredients
- A water-based formula that feels lightweight
It’s meant to be a 3-in-1 product that provides coverage, hydration, and anti-aging benefits in one step. For busy women or those who want to simplify their routine, this is a HUGE plus!
Application & Texture
The texture is where this foundation REALLY shines! Almost everyone agrees it feels incredibly smooth and creamy. It’s not thick or cakey, but has a “mousse-like” consistency that glides onto the skin.
You can apply it with:
- Your fingers (works great for quick application)
- A beauty sponge (for more coverage)
- A foundation brush (for an airbrushed finish)
One reviewer in her 70s mentioned that it “makes your face even feel smooth and soft” while another said it has a “beautiful glowy finish.” The consensus is that it feels LIGHT on the skin – you won’t feel like you’re wearing a mask.
Coverage & Finish
This foundation provides what I’d call a medium, buildable coverage. It’s not full coverage, so if you’re looking to completely hide significant discoloration, you might need to pair it with a concealer. That said, it does a fantastic job at:
- Evening out skin tone
- Minimizing the appearance of sunspots
- Providing a natural-looking finish that isn’t too matte or too dewy
The finish has been described as “glowy” without being greasy, which is PERFECT for mature skin that tends to look better with a bit of luminosity rather than a flat matte finish.
Staying Power
Mixed reviews here! Some users report it lasts all day, while others mentioned having to touch up. Based on the feedback, I’d say this foundation has:
- Good staying power for 6-8 hours
- May need touch-ups for all-day wear
- Performs better with a setting powder on top
One reviewer mentioned: “It does stay for 24 hours if you need it that long,” but I’m skeptical about that claim. Most users seemed happy with how it wore throughout a normal day.
How It Works for Mature Skin
This is where the Simply Ageless foundation truly stands out from the crowd. It’s specifically formulated for mature skin, and the reviews from women in their 60s, 70s, and even 80s are overwhelmingly positive!
The KEY benefits for mature skin:
- Doesn’t settle into fine lines and wrinkles (this was mentioned repeatedly!)
- The moisturizing formula doesn’t accentuate dry patches
- It doesn’t look cakey or heavy
- Gives a more youthful appearance
One 85-year-old reviewer said people think she’s 55, and while I can’t promise those kinds of results, it’s clear this foundation is doing something right for mature skin!
A 61-year-old user summed it up perfectly: “It does not make your wrinkles more noticeable like most foundations that I have tried over the years.”
Shade Selection & Soft Honey Specifically
The Soft Honey shade is described as “a perfect mix of summer tan and fair skin color” by one reviewer. It seems to work well for:
- Medium skin tones with warm undertones
- Those with a light to medium tan
However, shade matching can be tricky with this foundation. Several users mentioned difficulty finding their perfect match, especially when ordering online. The Soft Honey shade might run slightly darker than expected for some users.
My advice? If possible, test this in-store before ordering online. The Simply Ageless line has a decent range of shades, but finding your perfect match might take some trial and error.
The Good vs. The Not-So-Good
The GOOD:
- AMAZING for mature skin with fine lines and wrinkles
- Lightweight feel that doesn’t feel heavy or cakey
- Contains moisturizing ingredients from OLAY
- Pump bottle is convenient (when it works properly)
- Buildable coverage that looks natural
- Great price point compared to high-end foundations with similar benefits
The NOT-SO-GOOD:
- Packaging issues! Too many reports of missing caps and unsealed products
- No SPF (several reviewers wished it had sun protection)
- Shade matching can be difficult, especially online
- May not provide enough coverage for significant blemishes or discoloration
- Some users with oily skin found it too moisturizing
Who Should Try This Foundation?
This foundation is PERFECT for:
- Women with mature skin concerned about fine lines and wrinkles
- Anyone with normal to dry skin looking for a moisturizing foundation
- Those who prefer a natural, skin-like finish rather than a full-coverage look
- Budget-conscious shoppers looking for skincare benefits in their makeup
It might NOT be ideal for:
- Very oily skin types (several reviewers mentioned it felt too dewy)
- Those wanting full coverage
- People who need their foundation to last 12+ hours without touch-ups
Application Tips From Real Users
After reading through countless reviews, I’ve gathered these helpful tips:
- Apply over a good primer for better longevity (many mentioned this helps a LOT)
- Use a light hand – building up in thin layers works better than one thick layer
- Set with a light dusting of powder, especially in the T-zone
- For summer, mix with a bit of sunscreen for protection and a lighter coverage
The Bottom Line: Is It Worth Your Money?
At around $11-17 (depending on where you purchase), the COVERGIRL+OLAY Simply Ageless foundation offers EXCELLENT value. You’re getting both makeup and skincare benefits in one product, which is rare at this price point.
If you’re struggling to find a foundation that doesn’t settle into fine lines or make your skin look dry and cakey, this is DEFINITELY worth trying. Many reviewers mentioned they’ve tried expensive high-end foundations that performed worse on mature skin than this drugstore option.
However, be prepared for potential packaging issues if ordering online. The number of customers reporting missing caps or unsealed products is concerning.
Final Thoughts
The COVERGIRL+OLAY Simply Ageless 3-in-1 Liquid Foundation in Soft Honey is a standout drugstore foundation for mature skin. It delivers on its promises to provide coverage while not emphasizing fine lines and wrinkles. The moisturizing formula makes it especially suitable for normal to dry skin types.
While it’s not perfect (what foundation is?), the positive reviews from women in their 60s, 70s, and beyond speak volumes about its effectiveness for aging skin. If you’ve been disappointed by foundations that make you look older instead of younger, this might be your new holy grail!
Just be sure to check your package immediately upon arrival and return it if there are any signs it’s been opened or tampered with. Your skin deserves better than a potentially used product!
Have you tried this foundation? I’d LOVE to hear about your experience with it! 💄✨
Buy on Amazon: Here
