In today’s beauty market filled with complex palettes and trendy colors, sometimes finding that perfect standalone shade becomes surprisingly difficult. The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow in Sterling Blue represents something of a throwback to simpler times in makeup, offering a single versatile shade that has maintained a dedicated following for years. I’ve spent considerable time analyzing this product, testing its performance, and collecting user feedback to provide you with this comprehensive review.
Product Overview
Product Name: COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow
Color: Sterling Blue
Key Features:
- Silky, sheer formula
- Double-ended applicator included
- 100% Cruelty-free certification
- Single-shade compact
The Perfect Shade of Blue: Color Analysis
Sterling Blue offers a unique position in the blue eyeshadow spectrum. Unlike the bold cobalt blues or deep navy shades that dominate many palettes, this eyeshadow delivers a soft, silvery-blue that’s refreshingly subtle. The color has a gray undertone that provides sophistication, making it wearable for everyday looks while still offering that hint of color that makes blue eyeshadow special.
Many users specifically note the color’s versatility, describing it as:
- “Exactly the greyish blue shade I was looking for”
- “A slightly iridescent pale blue”
- “A soft but pretty blue”
- “Perfect silver eyeshadow”
The shade contains subtle shimmer without being overtly glittery, creating what one reviewer called “a little glimmer” that catches the light beautifully. This shimmer quality helps brighten the eyes without appearing overly dramatic or youthful.
It’s worth noting that some users perceived the color differently, with descriptions ranging from “light blue which is what I wanted” to “more blue than gray” to “almost white when applied.” This variation likely stems from differences in application technique, skin tone, and the amount of product applied.
Formula Performance
Application & Texture
The Eye Enhancers formula applies smoothly across the lid, living up to COVERGIRL’s “silky” description. The powder has good adherence but maintains a lightweight feel on the skin. As one user noted, “it applies very smoothly” and another mentioned it “goes on great.”
The sheerness of the formula is intentional and proves to be one of its greatest strengths. It allows for buildable coverage, meaning you can achieve a subtle wash of color with a light application or create more intensity by layering. This versatility makes it appropriate for multiple age groups and style preferences.
Pigmentation
Sterling Blue offers moderate pigmentation that aligns with its marketed sheer formula. This isn’t a highly pigmented eyeshadow that delivers bold color payoff in a single swipe – and it isn’t trying to be. Instead, it provides a translucent, luminous wash of color that enhances rather than dominates.
One reviewer captured this perfectly: “I just use a tiny bit and it really brings out my eye color.” Another noted: “I like to wear one color very sheer—going to almost nothing by the time I get to the brow.”
Some users wanting more intense color payoff mentioned needing to use eyeshadow primer or setting spray to enhance the pigmentation: “Perfect color for a nostalgic evening… Very light so I used setting spray with mine to get the color more pigmented and vibrant.”
Longevity
The staying power of Sterling Blue varies based on skin type, use of primer, and application technique. Many users report positive experiences with longevity:
- “It stays on alllll day!!”
- “Actually it lasts all day and does not settle into creases.”
- “Lasts all day no creasing”
However, others noted room for improvement: “I wish it went on more smoothly” and “not sure why I even purchased this because I haven’t found any cover girl products to be of good quality it doesn’t last even with a shadow primer.”
For best results, many long-term users recommend applying over an eyeshadow primer: “I use eyeshadow primer. Revlon shadow goes on smooth and evenly. Stays on all day.”
Eye-Enhancing Benefits
True to the product line’s name, “Eye Enhancers,” Sterling Blue excels at bringing out eye color, particularly blue eyes. Multiple reviewers specifically mentioned this benefit:
- “My mother is in her 70s and this eyeshadow is just perfect to bring out her ice blue eyes.”
- “If I use just a little bit, it highlights my eyes so well”
- “This shade does enhance my eyes.”
The color works through color theory – the subtle blue tones create contrast that makes the natural blue in eyes appear more vibrant. The slight shimmer in the formula also reflects light, making the eyes appear brighter and more awake.
Packaging & Value
The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers compact features a clear plastic lid that allows you to see the color inside. The package includes a double-ended applicator with a sponge-tip for application and a small brush for blending.
Some users noted issues with the packaging size relative to the product amount: “The packaging was larger than I would expect – the amount of shadow was fairly little in the plastic case, leaving a lot of space for the applicator that didn’t really need that much room, which I thought was wasteful.”
Others mentioned challenges with the adhesive seal: “The adhesive on the back of the clear tab which seals the product is impossible to get off the plastic case when the tab is removed.”
In terms of value, Sterling Blue is consistently praised for its affordability compared to higher-end eyeshadows that offer similar quality: “The color is very nice and stays on all day. This is as good as more expensive brands if you ask me.”
Versatility & Wearability
One of Sterling Blue’s greatest strengths is its versatility across age groups and occasions. Reviews demonstrate its appeal to a diverse audience:
For mature users:
- “This blue is a pale color…nothing dramatic, which is perfect for my advanced age.”
- “I wish I could still find this eyeshadow in the stores. I like using it because it is light & brightens my eyes. I cannot wear dark eyeshadows & this one is perfect!”
- “I’m 63 and haven’t worn blue eyeshadow since…middle school? … I really like this product because I can and do use a small amount so it really only lightens my eyelids with just a hint of blue.”
For everyday/subtle wear:
- “Light, subtle exactly what I wanted”
- “I like to swipe just a hint over my tan eyeshadow, adds a little bit of brightness.”
- “It’s a nice light blue that’s like a tint I like it a little it adds a subtle pop while still being suitable for everyday.”
For special occasions:
- “Good coverage for my 80’s Halloween party!”
- “Perfect color for a nostalgic evening or taking it back to the 90’s.”
Comparisons & Alternatives
Sterling Blue occupies a somewhat unique position in the market. Many reviewers note difficulty finding comparable products:
- “I’ve been looking for this color of blue eyeshadow for quite a while.”
- “I had a hard time finding just blue eye shadow.”
- “I’ve been using it for e. Difficult to find in retail stores.”
- “I’ve been using this product and color for more years than I can say but it’s become impossible to find in any local stores. Seems all the eye shadows now are dark colors.”
This suggests COVERGIRL has maintained a shade that meets a specific need not widely addressed by other brands. One reviewer even mentioned purchasing in bulk: “I had a hard time finding this product and so bought in quantity. The color is so perfect, I do not want to take the chance of not being able to replace it.”
For those seeking alternatives, some reviewers mentioned Maybelline Blue Blazes as a similar (though now discontinued) option.
Cruelty-Free Status
COVERGIRL’s commitment to 100% cruelty-free products resonates with ethically conscious consumers. One reviewer specifically highlighted this aspect: “I love CoverGirl especially now that they have gone cruelty free and this color is a classic must have.”
This certification represents COVERGIRL’s pledge not to test on animals anywhere in the world, making Sterling Blue a choice that aligns with modern ethical beauty standards.
Shipping & Handling Considerations
A recurring theme in the feedback involves the product’s vulnerability during shipping. Multiple customers reported receiving broken eyeshadow:
- “When I received the eye shadow and it had been miss handled and was all broken up.”
- “Like the color but it arrive broken and most of it not able to use.”
- “The shadow itself was broken.”
- “The one liner was just thrown in the box and was crumbled.”
This suggests that while the product itself may be excellent, its delicate nature requires careful handling during shipping. Several reviewers noted that COVERGIRL or Amazon quickly resolved these issues with replacements or refunds.
For those experiencing broken shadow, one resourceful user shared a repair technique: “I took just a little bit of 70% alcohol, about 1/4 teaspoon, into the shadow. With light pressure, I patted down until there where no more clumps.”
Who Should Buy Sterling Blue?
Based on the collected feedback, Sterling Blue is particularly well-suited for:
- Those with blue eyes seeking enhancement: The shade consistently receives praise for making blue eyes “pop.”
- Mature makeup wearers: The subtle, sheer formula works well for those wanting a touch of color without heavy pigmentation that can settle into fine lines.
- Nostalgic makeup lovers: Many reviews mention using this shade “for years” or returning to it after a long time, suggesting its appeal to those who appreciate classic makeup looks.
- Minimalist makeup users: If you prefer a simple one-shadow look rather than complex palettes, Sterling Blue offers versatility in a single shade.
- Those with fair to medium skin tones: Most positive reviews came from users with lighter skin tones, where the subtle blue shows up best.
- Ethical beauty consumers: The cruelty-free certification makes it appropriate for those prioritizing animal welfare in their beauty choices.
Who Should Consider Alternatives?
Sterling Blue may not be ideal for:
- Those seeking bold, dramatic blue: If you want highly pigmented, vibrant blue, this sheer formula may disappoint.
- Users with deeper skin tones: The subtle pigmentation may not show up as effectively on deeper skin tones without significant building or primer.
- Those who prefer matte textures: The slight shimmer/iridescence isn’t extreme but may not appeal to strict matte eyeshadow users.
- Those with very oily eyelids: Without primer, the longevity on oily lids may be limited.
Final Verdict
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1-Kit Eyeshadow in Sterling Blue earns a solid 4 out of 5 stars. Its primary strengths lie in its uniquely wearable color, buildable formula, eye-enhancing qualities, and affordability. Most negative feedback centers around shipping issues rather than the product itself, though some users desired more pigmentation or longevity.
Sterling Blue represents something increasingly rare in today’s beauty market – a simple, effective single eyeshadow that enhances natural beauty without overwhelming it. Its continued popularity despite trends toward complex palettes speaks to its effectiveness for its intended purpose.
The product does exactly what it aims to do: provide a soft, enhancing wash of cool blue that brightens the eyes and offers versatility for different ages and occasions. For those seeking a subtle blue with silvery undertones, Sterling Blue remains a go-to option that stands the test of time.
Pros:
- Unique, wearable shade difficult to find elsewhere
- Enhances blue eyes beautifully
- Buildable formula allows for customized intensity
- Affordable price point
- Cruelty-free certification
- Versatile across age groups
- Includes application tool
Cons:
- Fragile during shipping
- Moderate pigmentation may disappoint those wanting bold color
- Some issues with packaging design
- Varies in longevity without primer
Application Tips
To get the most from Sterling Blue:
- Use an eyeshadow primer for improved longevity and color payoff.
- For subtle enhancement: Apply a single light layer with the sponge applicator.
- For more intensity: Build up layers gradually or use a dampened brush for application.
- For evening looks: Layer over a white or cream eyeshadow base to make the blue more vibrant.
- For a quick everyday look: Apply Sterling Blue across the lid and blend toward the crease.
- For mature eyes: Focus the color on the center of the lid to brighten without emphasizing texture.
- If received broken: Try the alcohol repair method mentioned by a reviewer.
Sterling Blue represents a classic in COVERGIRL’s lineup – a product that has maintained a dedicated following despite changing trends, thanks to its unique color and versatile formula. For those seeking a subtle, wearable blue eyeshadow that enhances rather than overwhelms, it remains a solid choice worthy of consideration.
Buy on Amazon: Here
