Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m diving into COVERGIRL’s Eye Enhancer quad in the shade “Bellini Spritz.” As someone who’s tested hundreds of eyeshadow palettes over the years, I’m going to give you the REAL scoop on this clean, vegan formula that promises to be easy to wear with matte and shimmer finishes.
First Impressions 💭
When I first spotted this quad online, I was immediately drawn to those peachy, summery tones. The color story looked perfect for everyday wear – soft, approachable, and versatile. The packaging is typical COVERGIRL – simple, practical, and no frills.
But here’s where things get interesting… what you see online isn’t ALWAYS what you get in person!
Packaging & Delivery Issues ⚠️
I need to address something right away – there seems to be a MAJOR issue with how this product is being shipped. Many customers (myself included) received this palette with cracks and breaks in the shadows. It seems the packaging doesn’t provide enough protection during transit, which is super frustrating when you’re excited to try a new product!
The plastic casing feels lightweight and a bit flimsy compared to higher-end quads. This explains why so many people are experiencing breakage during shipping.
The Color Reality Check 👀
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room – the colors in real life versus what’s advertised. There’s definitely a disconnect! The online images show vibrant, pigmented peachy-pink tones, but in person, they’re much more muted and washed out.
The quad includes:
- A light champagne shimmer
- A peachy-pink shimmer
- A matte dusty rose
- A deeper mauve-brown
The good news? If you’re looking for subtle, workplace-appropriate shadows, these might actually work great for you. But if you were expecting those bright, juicy colors from the promo pics, you might be disappointed like I was.
Application & Performance 🖌️
Texture
I found the texture to be hit or miss. The shimmers have a decent consistency and apply pretty smoothly with a brush. However, the mattes definitely lean toward the chalky side, especially if you have deeper skin. I’ve tried using them with different primers, and while it helps somewhat, it doesn’t solve the underlying texture issues.
Blendability
When it comes to blending, these shadows are actually pretty user-friendly! Even though they don’t have the creamiest formula, they blend into each other nicely without too much effort. I appreciated how I could quickly create a soft diffused look in the mornings.
Color Payoff
This is where the quad really falls short for me. The pigmentation is WEAK, especially compared to what’s advertised. You need multiple layers to build up color, and even then, it’s never going to look as vibrant as the online images suggest.
I tried applying with my finger (which usually intensifies shadow color), using setting spray on my brush, and even tried applying over a cream base. While these techniques helped slightly, the color payoff remained disappointing.
Lasting Power
For a product that claims to be smudge-proof, I found the staying power to be just okay. On my normal-to-oily lids, I got about 5-6 hours of wear before noticing significant fading and creasing, even with a primer underneath. By the end of a workday, most of the color had disappeared.
Clean & Vegan Claims 🌱
The talc-free, clean, and vegan claims are genuinely positive aspects of this product. If you have sensitive eyes or are committed to using more ethical beauty products, these features might make the quad worth trying despite its shortcomings.
I didn’t experience any irritation or sensitivity while using this product, which is always a plus!
Value for Money 💰
At around $5-8 depending on where you purchase, the price point is definitely budget-friendly. However, even at this price range, there are other drugstore options that offer better pigmentation and staying power.
The question becomes: is it better to spend a few more dollars on a more reliable formula, or are you okay with the “you get what you pay for” reality of this quad?
Who Would This Work For? 🤔
This palette would be best for:
- Those seeking very subtle, natural eye looks
- Makeup beginners who want something foolproof
- People with fair to light skin tones (the colors show up better)
- Anyone who prioritizes clean/vegan formulas above performance
- Those who don’t mind using an intensifying base underneath
Who Should Skip This? ⛔
I wouldn’t recommend this quad if you:
- Have medium to deep skin tones (the colors barely show up)
- Want vibrant, long-lasting color
- Dislike having to build up layers of product
- Are looking for truly smudge-proof formulas
- Have oily eyelids
The Bottom Line ⭐⭐½
The COVERGIRL Eye Enhancer in Bellini Spritz gets 2.5 out of 5 stars from me. While I appreciate the clean formula, easy blendability, and budget-friendly price, the disappointing color payoff, chalkiness, and packaging issues hold it back from being a winner.
If you’re on the fence, I’d recommend checking out some of the other Eye Enhancer quads, as performance seems to vary between colorways. Some of the more neutral options apparently perform better than this one!
Tips If You Already Bought It 💡
If you’ve already purchased this quad and are feeling disappointed, try these tricks:
- Apply over a sticky white or peachy base to help the colors pop
- Use your fingers instead of brushes for the shimmer shades
- Spray your brush with setting spray before picking up the shadows
- Layer the shadows over a cream shadow in a similar tone
Have you tried the COVERGIRL Eye Enhancer quads? I’d love to hear your experience with this formula, especially if you’ve tried other shades!
Remember, makeup is personal – what works for one person might not work for another. Trust your own experience over anyone else’s reviews (including mine)!
Stay beautiful! ✨
Buy on Amazon: Here
