Hey beauty lovers! After trying practically EVERY mascara on the market, I finally got around to testing the Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Lashblast Mascara in Very Black. I’ve been using this for the past few months, and I’ve got THOUGHTS to share. Is it worth the hype? Let’s dive in!
First Impressions & Packaging
When my package arrived, I was excited to try this mascara that so many people have been raving about. The bright green tube is definitely eye-catching – you won’t lose this in your makeup bag! The pack of 2 is actually a pretty good deal compared to buying in-store where prices are nearly DOUBLE according to other users.
BUT… a word of caution: quite a few people (myself included) have had issues with the packaging upon arrival. Some folks reported receiving opened products or products without proper packaging. Several reviewers mentioned having to return their order because they couldn’t be sure if the mascara had been used before. So definitely check your package carefully when it arrives!
The Brush: A Game-Changer!
The standout feature of this mascara is 100% the brush. Unlike traditional mascara wands that load up with product and create those dreaded spider legs (we’ve ALL been there), this curved brush is designed to separate lashes beautifully.
The brush is firm but not scratchy, and the curved design helps reach even those tiny corner lashes. I found this design particularly helpful for getting a nice, even application. The brush is seriously the star of the show here!
Pro tip I learned from another user: “Wiggle it back and forth as you pull it up through your eyelashes.” This technique makes SUCH a difference in application and helps the product reach all the way to the ends of your lashes!
Application & Performance
What’s AMAZING:
- No Clumping: This mascara truly lives up to its “Clump Crusher” name! Even with multiple coats, it doesn’t clump up like other mascaras I’ve tried.
- Separation: If you hate the “stuck together” look, you’ll LOVE this. Each lash gets defined and separated.
- Color: The Very Black shade is truly deep black and gives good color intensity from the get-go.
- Consistency: Unlike some mascaras that are watery when first opened, this one provides good coverage from first use until the last drop.
- Easy to Remove: It comes off easily with regular makeup remover or micellar water – no aggressive rubbing needed!
What’s Not So Great:
- Volume Claims: Despite claiming “20X MORE VOLUME,” several users (including me) found it doesn’t actually add that much thickness. It darkens and defines, but if you’re looking for dramatic volume, this might disappoint.
- Not Actually Water-Resistant: Though it claims to be water-resistant, it definitely doesn’t hold up in rain or during sweaty workouts. Expect some smudging if you get wet or sweaty.
- Shelf Life Concerns: A few people reported that when they stored the unopened tube for a few months before using it, the product had dried out. So don’t stock up too far in advance!
- Product Amount: Some users complained that there seemed to be very little product on the wand when they pulled it out, requiring multiple coats.
Results on Different Lash Types
This is where things get interesting! The feedback varies SIGNIFICANTLY depending on your natural lashes:
- For Those with Already Long Lashes: This mascara is FANTASTIC for definition and creating a natural but enhanced look.
- For Short, Sparse Lashes: Unfortunately, several users with very short lashes found this mascara didn’t provide enough volume or dramatic effect. One reviewer sadly noted: “If you have very short lashes, don’t bother.”
- For Sensitive Eyes: Great news! Multiple reviewers with sensitive eyes mentioned this formula doesn’t cause irritation. One specifically mentioned: “I have VERY sensitive eyes/skin and this is the only kind that doesn’t burn for me.”
- For Gray/White Lashes: A reviewer with gray/white lashes mentioned this gave good thickness and length without clumping.
Longevity & Wear
The staying power is generally good for everyday wear. It doesn’t smudge under normal conditions, and many reviewers praised it for not giving them “raccoon eyes” by the end of the day.
However, don’t expect it to survive a crying session, intense workout, or rainy day. It’s definitely not waterproof, despite claiming to be water-resistant.
The mascara lasts several months according to most users, which is standard for mascara (remember that experts recommend replacing mascara every 3 months for eye health!).
Creative Uses
One user mentioned adding “just a little castor oil” to the formula and claimed their lashes actually grew! While I can’t personally vouch for this hack, it’s an interesting tip if you’re looking to experiment.
Comparison to Other Mascaras
Several reviewers mentioned they’ve tried TONS of different mascaras at various price points and found this to be “among the best” and “wonderful.” For the price point especially, many believe this performs as well as (or better than) much more expensive options.
One long-time user said they’ve been using this mascara for YEARS because it consistently delivers good results. That kind of loyalty speaks volumes!
Removal Process
This mascara is definitely on the easier side to remove, which is great if you hate tugging at your delicate eye area. Users mentioned successful removal with:
- Regular makeup remover
- Micellar water (particularly Garnier’s)
- Water and some coconut oil
- Regular face washing
No need for specialized waterproof makeup removers here!
Potential Downsides & Warnings
A few concerning notes from reviewers:
- One user claimed the mascara made their eyelashes FALL OUT and recommended only using it for special occasions.
- Several mentioned receiving dried-out products.
- A few reported allergic reactions with itchy eyes.
Price Value
At the Amazon price point for a pack of two, this is considered an excellent value by most reviewers. The same product costs significantly more in physical stores, making this a smart buy if you’re looking to save some cash on your beauty routine.
Final Verdict
Who Should Buy This:
- People looking for a clump-free, natural look
- Those who prioritize lash separation over volume
- Makeup users with sensitive eyes
- Anyone frustrated with “spider leg” mascaras
- Budget-conscious shoppers who still want quality
Who Should Skip This:
- Those wanting dramatic, voluminous lashes
- People with very short, sparse lashes hoping for a miracle product
- Anyone who needs genuinely waterproof mascara
- Those who tend to store backup makeup for long periods
Overall Rating: 3.8/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
The Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Lashblast Mascara delivers on its core promise of clump-free, well-separated lashes. While it doesn’t provide dramatic volume and isn’t truly water-resistant as claimed, it excels at creating a natural, defined look that’s perfect for everyday wear.
For the price point, particularly when purchased as a two-pack, it offers excellent value compared to high-end mascaras that promise similar results. Just be sure to check your package upon arrival to ensure you’ve received properly sealed, unused products!
Have you tried this mascara? I’d LOVE to hear your experience with it! What’s your go-to mascara for everyday wear?
Buy on Amazon: Here
