Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m diving DEEP into one of the drugstore’s most talked-about mascaras – the COVERGIRL Clump Crusher by Lash Blast in Black Waterproof. After collecting feedback from dozens of real users and testing it myself, I’m ready to give you the no-holds-barred truth about this green tube wonder.
First Impressions & Packaging
Let’s start with the basics – this mascara comes in a distinctive lime green tube that’s actually super practical (you can easily spot it in your makeup bag!). The wand is curved with short, firm plastic bristles that are designed to separate lashes and prevent clumping. The bristles have that quill-like design that’s become a signature of the LashBlast line.
One thing to note right away – despite being marketed as “waterproof” in some listings, this is actually the WATER-RESISTANT version. This distinction is important and I’ll get into why that matters later!
Application Experience
The application experience is where this mascara truly shines. The curved wand and firm bristles make application surprisingly easy and precise. Many users (myself included) have noted that this mascara is amazing for people who typically struggle with getting mascara everywhere during application.
As one longtime user put it: “I have some uncanny ability to get mascara all over my eyelids and under my eyes when applying most mascaras. It is a mix of both the wand and the formula with this mascara that keeps that from happening which is SO GREAT.”
The wand does an exceptional job reaching all lashes, even those tiny ones in the inner and outer corners. Several users specifically mentioned how the curved shape allows them to reach all their lashes and gives them some natural curl.
Performance: Does It Actually Crush Clumps?
YES! This mascara ACTUALLY delivers on its no-clump promise, which is pretty rare in the mascara world. Even after multiple coats, users consistently report minimal to no clumping. The formula goes on smoothly and evenly, making your lashes look naturally separated rather than spider-like or stuck together.
As one user explained: “The spiky brush looks a little scary, but it works. IT DOES NOT CLUMP, just like it says.”
Another great point: you can build it up! Most users find that 2-3 coats give the best results without any clumping issues. The mascara dries relatively quickly between coats, which helps prevent transfer to the eyelids.
The Look: Volume & Length
This mascara provides a more NATURAL look compared to some of the more dramatic formulas on the market. It excels at:
- Separation (it’s truly exceptional at this)
- Definition
- Making your natural lashes look enhanced but not fake
It’s not the most volumizing or lengthening mascara out there. If you’re looking for dramatic, falsies-like volume, this probably isn’t your best bet. Many users described it as providing “natural-looking results” that make lashes “more visible” rather than dramatically transformed.
One user summed it up well: “It gives my eyes just enough volume and just enough length. It doesn’t clump and it looks completely natural. If you’re looking for huge, going out on the town, eyelashes, I probably wouldn’t use this mascara.”
Staying Power & Water Resistance
Let’s clear up the confusion – this is the WATER-RESISTANT version, not fully waterproof. Here’s what that means in real life:
✅ It will hold up to:
- Light sweating
- Moderate moisture
- Normal daily activities
- Light rain
❌ It will NOT hold up to:
- Swimming
- Showering
- Heavy crying
- Heavy rain
Many users specifically mentioned that tears are this mascara’s kryptonite: “The only downside to this water-resistant formula is it really does not resist tears at all. It might be something about the saltiness of tears.”
For everyday wear, most users find that it lasts all day without significant flaking or smudging. However, if you have very watery eyes or allergies, you might experience some running.
Removal Process
One of the BIGGEST advantages of the water-resistant (vs. waterproof) formula is how easily it removes! Users consistently mention this as a major plus:
“Removes easily with face wash or makeup remover”
“It’s water resistant, not water-proof, so be cautious around water! But the applicator brush is fantastic.”
This makes it ideal for daily wear since it won’t damage your lashes during removal like some stubborn waterproof formulas can.
Special Considerations
For Straight Lashes
If you have very straight lashes that struggle to hold a curl, this might not be your best option. Several users with Asian or naturally straight lashes mentioned that this formula doesn’t hold a curl well:
“If you have stubborn straight lashes like mine – this isn’t the mascara for you.”
“I have straight Asian lashes, but they are long and thick because I use latisse. I like to use this as a base coat or a standalone.”
For Contact Lens Wearers
Good news for contact lens wearers! Several users mentioned that this mascara doesn’t irritate their eyes or cause random flakes to get under their contacts.
For Sensitive Eyes
Most users with sensitive eyes reported no issues with this mascara. One user specifically noted: “This is the only mascara I’ve found that doesn’t cause my eyes to water.”
Price Point & Value
At around $6-11 (prices vary on Amazon), this mascara offers EXCELLENT value for the quality. Many users mentioned trying high-end mascaras but always coming back to this one.
“I’ve tried dozens of mascaras both drugstore and high end and this one is in my top 3 (love Benefit Roller Lash and Lancôme Idole).”
Some users did mention that the formula seems to dry out somewhat quickly (around 1-2 months with regular use), which is something to consider.
The Pros & Cons Breakdown
PROS:
- Truly clump-free formula (lives up to its name!)
- Easy application with minimal mess
- Curved brush reaches all lashes
- Natural-looking results
- Easy to remove
- Doesn’t flake much during the day
- Great for sensitive eyes
- Budget-friendly
- Cruelty-free
CONS:
- Not actually waterproof (only water-resistant)
- Doesn’t hold curl well for straight lashes
- Not dramatic enough for those wanting major volume
- Runs when eyes tear up
- Formula can dry out relatively quickly
- Some reports of flaking after several hours of wear
Who Should Buy This Mascara?
This mascara is PERFECT for:
- Everyday, natural makeup looks
- People who hate clumpy mascara
- Those new to mascara application
- People with sensitive eyes
- Anyone who wants a mascara that’s easy to apply AND remove
You might want to look elsewhere if:
- You need truly waterproof mascara
- You have very straight lashes that need help holding a curl
- You want dramatic, falsies-like volume
- You have very watery eyes or allergies
Tips for Best Results
- For more volume, apply 2-3 thin coats rather than one thick coat
- Let each coat dry slightly before applying the next
- Make sure the green brush tip is firmly pressed into the wand (some users reported it coming loose)
- Use a lash curler before application if your lashes need extra curl
- For more dramatic looks, some users recommend using this as a base coat and then applying a more volumizing mascara on top
The Bottom Line
COVERGIRL’s Clump Crusher delivers on its primary promise – it truly doesn’t clump! It creates natural-looking, defined lashes that are perfect for everyday wear. While it’s not the most dramatic mascara out there, it’s incredibly user-friendly and performs impressively well for its price point.
Just remember – it’s WATER-RESISTANT, not waterproof, so don’t expect it to survive a swimming session or serious tears!
If you’re looking for a reliable, everyday mascara that won’t give you raccoon eyes or spider lashes, this is definitely worth trying. It’s become a holy grail product for many beauty lovers for good reason!
Rating: 4.2/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
Have you tried the Clump Crusher? What’s your experience been like? Let me know in the comments!
This review is based on real user experiences and product testing. Individual results may vary depending on lash type, application technique, and personal preferences.
Buy on Amazon: Here
