Let me tell you about this little stick that’s been a GAME CHANGER for so many people! I’ve been analyzing customer reviews of the COVERGIRL Smoothers Moisturizing Concealer, and wow, there’s a LOT to unpack here.
First Impressions
When you first get this concealer, you’ll notice it comes in a lipstick-style tube that’s super convenient for on-the-go touch-ups. It’s about an inch of product (yes, some customers mentioned it’s smaller than they expected for the price), but don’t let the size fool you – a little goes a LONG way with this.
The texture is what really stands out immediately. It’s creamy without being greasy and glides on smoothly, which is EXACTLY what you want in a concealer. No tugging or pulling at that delicate under-eye area!
Application Tips
I’ve noticed from the reviews that how you apply this makes a big difference:
- MOISTURIZE FIRST! Several users emphasized this, and they’re 100% right. Prep your skin with a good moisturizer before applying.
- You can apply it directly from the stick, but be careful not to twist up too much at once. Some customers mentioned it breaking off, which is frustrating when you’ve just spent money on it.
- For under-eye application, many users recommend letting it sit for about 30 seconds before blending. This helps with coverage.
- You can use it before or after foundation, depending on your preference. Some people put it on blemishes and under eyes, wait a couple minutes, then apply foundation over top. Others apply foundation first, then concealer.
- Set with powder if you want it to last longer without creasing!
Coverage
For a drugstore concealer, the coverage is IMPRESSIVE. It handles dark circles, redness, blemishes, and even some users mentioned covering acne scars and hyperpigmentation with it.
It’s not full-on stage makeup coverage, but it’s buildable without getting cakey. One woman in her late 60s said it completely covered her dark circles and made her look “ten years younger” – which is pretty much the dream, right?
Lasting Power
This is where opinions varied a bit. Some users reported it lasting all day without touch-ups, while others mentioned needing to reapply after about 6 hours. A lot depends on your skin type and what you’re doing throughout the day.
If you have oily skin, you’ll definitely want to set it with powder. If you have dry skin, it seems to adhere better but might settle into fine lines by the end of the day.
Shade Selection
The Fair shade seems to work well for most people with light skin tones. Several reviewers with pale skin mentioned it was a perfect match. A couple noted it was slightly lighter than expected, making it great for brightening the under-eye area.
For those with lighter skin and golden undertones, it also seems to work well without looking too pink or ashy.
Skin-Friendly Formula
One of the BIGGEST pros mentioned repeatedly is that this concealer is moisturizing without breaking people out. For a face product, that’s HUGE!
It’s fragrance-free, which is great for sensitive skin. Several reviewers with mature skin (60s and 70s) mentioned loving how it doesn’t emphasize fine lines or wrinkles – which is usually the main problem with concealers for aging skin.
Comparison to Higher-End Products
This is where things get REALLY interesting. Multiple reviewers who’ve tried expensive concealers (Benefit, MAC, Tarte Shape Tape which runs about $32) said this $7 concealer performs just as well, if not BETTER!
One reviewer who tried both this and Dermablend (a professional coverage brand) said the COVERGIRL held up better and blended with their skin tone more naturally.
The Downsides
Let’s be real – no product is perfect. Here are the cons mentioned in reviews:
- Size vs. price – some feel it’s too small for the cost (though it’s still much cheaper than high-end alternatives)
- Breakage – several people mentioned the stick breaking off if you twist up too much
- Some received damaged products during shipping
- A few reviewers mentioned it didn’t cover as well as they hoped or needed a second layer
- For some, it slipped off after a few hours without setting powder
Who This Works Best For
Based on all the feedback, this concealer seems to work ESPECIALLY well for:
- Mature skin (so many 60+ year-olds LOVE this product!)
- People with dry under-eye areas
- Those with fair to light skin tones
- People who want something easy for quick touch-ups
- Anyone who wants decent coverage without breaking the bank
Who Might Want Something Different
You might want to look elsewhere if:
- You need extremely heavy-duty, long-lasting coverage for severe discoloration
- You have very oily skin (it might slip off)
- You prefer a liquid concealer with a wand applicator
- You need a very specific shade match beyond what’s available
Value for Money
This is where this concealer REALLY shines. At around $7, many reviewers called it an incredible value. Several mentioned using it for DECADES (yes, literal decades) and trying other products but always coming back to this one.
One reviewer said, “I will never buy high-end makeup cover up again after using this.”
Long-Term Effects
I didn’t see any reviews mentioning negative long-term effects from using this product regularly. In fact, several long-term users (some 20+ years!) seemed very happy with how it’s treated their skin over time.
One 71-year-old reviewer who’s used COVERGIRL products her whole life credited them for her wrinkle-free skin, which is a pretty amazing testimonial!
Storage and Travel
The stick format makes this super convenient for travel and touch-ups. Several people mentioned keeping one in their purse or car for quick fixes throughout the day.
Just remember not to leave it in a hot car or the creamy formula might melt!
The Bottom Line
After analyzing ALL these reviews, I can confidently say that the COVERGIRL Smoothers Moisturizing Concealer is a solid, reliable product that performs way above its price point. It’s not the fanciest packaging or the trendiest brand, but it WORKS, and sometimes that’s all that matters!
It’s particularly great for mature skin and those with drier under-eyes who struggle with concealer creasing or emphasizing fine lines.
For $7, you’re getting a product that many people feel performs just as well as concealers 4-5 times the price. That’s pretty much unbeatable value.
Tips for Getting the Most Out of It
- Store it properly! Don’t leave it in hot places or the stick might break.
- Always twist it back down after use to maintain the integrity of the product.
- Layer with color corrector underneath for extreme dark circles (one reviewer mentioned using a peach-toned corrector first).
- If using on blemishes, pair with a blemish control primer underneath.
- For the most natural look, apply with fingertips, warming the product slightly as you blend.
Final Thoughts
The COVERGIRL Smoothers Moisturizing Concealer is proof that you don’t always need to spend a fortune to get quality makeup. It’s a tried-and-true product that’s stood the test of time for good reason.
For everyday wear, touch-ups, and especially for those with mature or dry skin, this concealer is absolutely worth trying. If you’re spending $30+ on high-end concealers, you might be surprised at how well this budget-friendly option measures up!
And if you’re new to concealer altogether? This is a PERFECT starter product that won’t break the bank while you figure out what works for your unique skin needs.
Have you tried it yet? I’d love to hear about YOUR experience with this little wonder stick!
Buy on Amazon: Here
