Hey beauty lovers! So I’ve been testing out the Covergirl Smoothers Moisturizing Concealer Stick in Light for a WHILE now, and I’m ready to spill ALL the tea on this drugstore classic. Is it worth your money? Let’s get into it!
Quick Take
This little concealer stick has been around FOREVER (seriously, some reviewers have been using it for 15+ years!) and there’s a good reason why. It’s a reliable, affordable spot concealer that offers decent coverage without drying out your skin. Perfect for on-the-go touch-ups and great for mature skin too!
Packaging & First Impressions
The Covergirl Smoothers concealer comes in a lipstick-style tube that’s super portable and easy to toss in your purse. The “Light” shade is perfect for fair to light skin tones with neutral undertones. It’s not the fanciest packaging out there, but it’s practical and you can easily see how much product you have left.
One thing to note: Don’t twist it up too high or it might break! Several users (including me) learned this the hard way. Keep it at a reasonable length and you should be fine.
Application & Texture
This concealer has a creamy, moisturizing formula that’s firmer than your typical lipstick but softer than a traditional stick foundation. It glides on smoothly without tugging at the skin, which is AMAZING for the delicate under-eye area.
I find it applies best when you warm it up a bit – either swipe directly on your skin or tap with your finger to pick up the product. It blends easily with fingers or a small brush, and doesn’t require much effort to look natural.
The texture is what makes this concealer special. Unlike many drugstore concealers that can be drying or cakey, this one has that moisturizing quality that helps it melt into the skin. It’s not greasy at all – just comfortably hydrating.
Coverage & Performance
Let’s talk about what this concealer does best:
Under-eye coverage
This is where the Covergirl Smoothers REALLY shines! The moisturizing formula doesn’t settle into fine lines or look cakey around the eyes. It brightens dark circles effectively without looking heavy or obvious. If you have extremely dark circles, you might need something with higher coverage, but for moderate darkness, this works great.
Blemish coverage
The stick format makes this perfect for spot-treating pimples or red areas. The coverage is medium but buildable. I find it stays put pretty well on blemishes throughout the day, especially if set with a light dusting of powder.
Age spots & discoloration
Many reviewers with mature skin praise this for covering age spots without emphasizing texture. The moisturizing formula doesn’t cling to dry patches, making it forgiving on all skin types.
The staying power is decent – about 6-8 hours before it might need a touch-up. It stays better than foundation but you might need to reapply once during a long day. It doesn’t tend to oxidize or change color throughout wear.
Best For…
This concealer works particularly well for:
- Mature or dry skin (doesn’t cling to fine lines!)
- On-the-go touch-ups (the stick format is so convenient)
- Natural, everyday makeup looks
- Spot concealing vs. full coverage concealing
- People who hate the feeling of heavy makeup
Not Great For…
This might not be your best bet if:
- You need extremely heavy coverage for very dark circles
- You want an all-over face concealer (it’s too dry for large areas)
- You prefer a matte finish (this has a natural, slightly dewy finish)
- You have very oily skin (though some oily-skinned reviewers still love it!)
The Value Factor
At around $6-8 depending where you shop, this concealer is a STEAL compared to high-end options. The 0.14 oz size might look small, but because you’re using it for spot concealing, it actually lasts quite a long time. Many reviewers mention having it for months before needing a replacement.
Several people mentioned they’ve tried expensive department store brands and still come back to this one! That says a lot about the quality for the price.
My Experience Over Time
I’ve gone through several tubes of this concealer over the years, and it’s earned its place as a staple in my makeup bag. Here’s how I typically use it:
Morning routine: After moisturizer and primer, I dot this under my eyes and on any red spots BEFORE foundation. I gently pat it in with my ring finger, then apply a lightweight foundation over top. This gives me that natural “I woke up like this” look where my skin shows through but imperfections are minimized.
Touch-ups: I keep one in my purse for midday fixes. If I notice a blemish or my under-eye coverage has faded, I can easily dab a tiny bit on without disturbing the rest of my makeup.
I’ve found this works best when set with a light dusting of translucent powder, especially in summer or in humid climates.
Potential Drawbacks
No product is perfect, so here are the honest downsides:
- Limited shade range – While the Light shade works well for me, Covergirl needs to expand their shade options!
- Packaging durability – Several reviews mentioned receiving broken product. This seems to be more of a shipping issue than a product issue, but worth noting.
- Not transfer-proof – It can transfer a bit if you don’t set it with powder
- Not for full-face application – It’s too dry to use as all-over coverage and will pull at your skin if you try
Tips & Tricks
After using this for so long, I’ve discovered some handy tricks:
- Apply it BEFORE foundation for a more natural look
- For extra stubborn dark circles, color-correct first, then apply this over top
- In winter when skin is drier, warm the product between your fingers first
- Don’t twist up too much product at once to prevent breakage
- Keep it away from heat (like in a hot car) as it can melt
Would I Repurchase?
YES! 100%! This has been my go-to concealer for years, and I don’t see that changing. In a world of constantly changing beauty trends and new product launches, this humble little concealer stick remains reliable and effective.
Who Should Try This?
If you’re looking for an affordable, no-fuss concealer that feels comfortable on the skin and provides natural-looking coverage, definitely give this a shot. It’s especially great for:
- Makeup beginners (so easy to use!)
- People with mature skin
- Anyone who prefers minimal makeup
- Those on a budget but still want quality
Final Thoughts
The Covergirl Smoothers Moisturizing Concealer Stick in Light isn’t flashy or trendy, but it WORKS. It gets the job done without fanfare, doesn’t break the bank, and is kind to aging or dry skin. In a beauty world full of expensive promises, this affordable little stick delivers real results.
What makes this concealer stand out is its longevity in the market. When people use a product for DECADES and keep coming back to it despite trying more expensive options, that speaks volumes about its quality and performance.
So if you’re tired of spending big bucks on concealers that don’t deliver, or if you’re just starting out with makeup and need a reliable concealer, give this Covergirl classic a try. Your skin (and wallet) will thank you!
Have you tried this concealer? What’s your experience been? Drop a comment below and let me know your thoughts!
Rating: 4.5/5 stars
✅ PROS:
- Moisturizing formula that doesn’t cake or crease
- Affordable price point
- Great for mature skin and doesn’t settle in fine lines
- Natural-looking coverage
- Portable stick format perfect for touch-ups
- Long-lasting company staple (hasn’t been discontinued!)
❌ CONS:
- Limited shade range
- Not ideal for very dark circles/high coverage needs
- Some shipping issues with broken product
- Not suitable for all-over face application
Buy on Amazon: Here
