As a beauty industry professional who’s tested countless foundations over the years, I’m always skeptical when products claim to be “ageless” or “wrinkle-defying.” Let’s be real – no makeup can actually erase wrinkles. But after thoroughly analyzing user experiences with COVERGIRL & Olay’s Simply Ageless Foundation in Creamy Natural, I can share what this product actually delivers versus what it promises.
First Impressions & Packaging
The COVERGIRL & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation comes in a round compact with a separate compartment for the included application sponge. While this seems convenient, MANY users report extreme difficulty opening the container. Some mentioned needing pliers or screwdrivers, and one person even resorted to using a hammer after spending two hours trying to open it! The twist-off design clearly needs improvement.
For those who could access the product, the cream foundation has a distinctly moist texture that surprised several first-time users. One reviewer mentioned thinking they’d accidentally gotten their application sponge wet because the foundation felt so creamy going on.
Application & Coverage
When it comes to application, this foundation generally receives high marks. It goes on smoothly and blends easily, whether using the included sponge applicator or a foundation brush. The coverage is described as medium but buildable, making it versatile for different needs.
The formula contains SPF 28, which is a HUGE bonus that many reviewers appreciated. Sun protection is crucial for preventing further skin aging, so having it built into your foundation eliminates an extra step in your morning routine.
Performance on Mature Skin
This foundation seems to work particularly well for those with mature skin concerns. Many reviewers in their 50s, 60s, and even 70s reported loving how it sat on their skin. One 76-year-old mentioned receiving compliments on her “flawless” skin while wearing this foundation!
The key insight I found from reading through experiences is that people initially misunderstood the “ageless” claim. As one reviewer explained after using it for two weeks: “I originally gave this foundation 3 stars but have bumped that up to 5. When I saw the advertising for ‘Ageless’ and that it floats over lines and wrinkles, I assumed it would conceal those imperfections… TOTALLY NOT THE POINT! The idea is that it IS antiaging because the product isn’t sitting in those lines (and pores!) making them deeper and larger.”
This is the correct understanding – the foundation doesn’t hide wrinkles through heavy coverage but instead contains moisturizing ingredients that don’t settle into lines and potentially make them more pronounced over time.
Texture & Feel
The texture is consistently described as “creamy,” “silky,” and “lightweight.” Many users with dry skin found it particularly hydrating and comfortable to wear. The addition of Olay’s moisturizing properties seems to make a real difference compared to standard foundations.
A 48-year-old reviewer noted: “I found that the foundations that always worked for me in the past have now started to accentuate my fine lines and settle into creases – and these are the very expensive ones I am referring to. Not the case with this one!”
Longevity & Wear
Most reviewers found the foundation lasted well throughout the day without the need for frequent touch-ups. Some mentioned it being particularly good for both professional settings and casual wear.
One user specifically tested its staying power and reported: “By the end of the day when I was ready to remove my makeup I’d been very happy with this product. My skin was neither oily in the T-zone, nor too dry.”
Skin Benefits
Beyond just coverage, this foundation includes peptides and moisturizing ingredients from the Olay side of the collaboration. Several users reported seeing actual improvements in their skin condition over time.
One reviewer with extremely sensitive skin wrote: “I am a very picky person… It has to be gentle on my skin and not cause any allergy or breakouts… It must not settle in my pores and fine lines.” She went on to say that after a month of use, she was “still very happy” and recommended it to “anyone who has extremely sensitive skin and/or prone to breakouts.”
The Mixed Results
However, not everyone had a positive experience. Some users found that despite the claims, it actually highlighted their wrinkles rather than minimizing them. A particularly disappointed customer wrote that it “should be labeled ‘wrinkle defining’ because it goes on rather dry and accentuates my fine lines.”
This mixed feedback suggests that skin type and preparation play significant roles in how well this foundation performs. Those with very dry skin who don’t properly moisturize beforehand may find it emphasizes texture issues.
Color Selection & Matching
The Creamy Natural shade seems to work well for light to medium skin tones with neutral undertones. Several reviewers mentioned it being a good match for those who typically wear MAC NW20 or Medium Beige in Bare Minerals.
Many users mentioned that the foundation applies lighter than it appears in the container, so choosing one shade darker than you think you need might be advisable. Some customers successfully mix two shades for a perfect match, particularly as their skin tone changes between seasons.
Value for Money
Compared to high-end department store foundations, many users found the Simply Ageless foundation to be an excellent value. One reviewer who had previously used Estée Lauder mentioned being pleasantly surprised by the quality, saying they “absolutely love it” despite initially being skeptical of drugstore brands.
Another reviewer who described themselves as a “cosmetics snob” admitted: “I was really surprised to really like this product. I am generally a bit of a cosmetics snob and in the past would only buy premium brands.”
The Bottom Line
After analyzing the collective experiences, this foundation seems to be particularly well-suited for:
- Mature skin that needs moisture and medium coverage
- Those seeking built-in SPF protection
- People transitioning from liquid foundation to something more hydrating
- Anyone looking for a foundation that won’t settle into lines and pores
It may NOT be ideal for:
- Those needing full coverage for significant discoloration
- People with very oily skin
- Those who prefer matte finishes
- Anyone who struggles with hand strength (due to packaging issues)
My Professional Take
As a beauty professional, I believe the COVERGIRL & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation represents a solid collaboration between two trusted brands. It delivers on many of its promises – particularly the moisturizing formula and the way it sits on the skin without emphasizing texture.
The inclusion of SPF 28 is excellent, and the peptides from Olay provide actual skincare benefits beyond just coverage. For the price point, this outperforms many higher-end foundations specifically marketed for mature skin.
However, proper skin preparation is ESSENTIAL. This foundation works best when applied to well-moisturized skin, potentially with a primer underneath. Without this prep, it may not perform as well, particularly on very dry skin types.
Tips for Best Results
Based on the collective experiences, here are some tips for getting the most out of this foundation:
- Apply moisturizer before using the foundation – this helps it blend seamlessly
- Consider using a primer if you have significant texture concerns
- Start with a small amount and build up as needed
- Try using a damp beauty sponge instead of the included applicator for a more natural finish
- Set lightly with powder only in areas that tend to get oily
- Remember that the shade may apply lighter than it looks in the compact
Final Verdict
For those over 40 looking for an affordable foundation that provides both coverage and skincare benefits, the COVERGIRL & Olay Simply Ageless Foundation is definitely worth trying. It offers a good middle ground between makeup and skincare, with the convenience of built-in SPF protection.
While it won’t perform miracles on deep wrinkles (no foundation can!), its formulation genuinely avoids the common problem of settling into fine lines that many other foundations have. Paired with proper skin preparation, it can provide a smoother, more youthful appearance without looking heavy or cakey.
If you can get past the packaging issues, this foundation represents excellent value for money and has earned its loyal following among users of all ages, but especially those with mature skin concerns.
Just remember – the key to its “ageless” benefit isn’t that it hides wrinkles, but that it doesn’t make them worse over time. That subtle distinction makes all the difference in how you’ll feel about this product!
Buy on Amazon: Here
