As a beauty professional who has tested countless lip products throughout my career, I’ve had the opportunity to extensively test the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in shade 55 “Atomic Love”. This pen-style lip stain has generated significant buzz in the beauty community, so I wanted to provide an in-depth analysis of its performance, application, longevity, and overall value.
Name: COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain
Shade: 55 Atomic Love
Format: Pen-style lip stain with precise tip
Finish: Satin stained
Transfer-resistant: Yes
Formula: Vegan
Size: 0.06oz
Price point: Budget-friendly drugstore option
First Impressions and Packaging
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain comes in a sleek, pen-like applicator that promises precision and control. The packaging is straightforward and functional, designed to resemble a marker or felt-tip pen. This design choice makes sense given the product’s staining properties.
Several users noted packaging issues upon delivery—some received items without product cards, loose caps, or missing security cellophane wrap, raising concerns about potential tampering or prior use. This suggests some quality control or shipping issues that COVERGIRL should address to maintain consumer confidence.
When properly sealed and new, the product looks appealing with its clean lines and portable size that can easily slip into small makeup bags or purses.
Color and Pigmentation
Shade 55 “Atomic Love” is marketed as a classic red with warm undertones. Based on user experiences, this shade appears to be a vibrant, somewhat bold red when first applied, though perceptions varied:
- Most users describe it as “the perfect red”
- Some noted it appears more intense than expected
- A few users observed that the color shifts to a magenta or bright pink tone as it fades
- One user mentioned confusion because they purchased two shades (Iconic Ruby and Atomic Love) that appeared identical despite different packaging colors
The pigmentation seems to vary from user to user. While many find the color payoff satisfactory, some reported that the product lacked sufficient tint, particularly after a short period of use. This inconsistency might be due to batch variations or product shelf life issues.
For those seeking a true red lip stain, Atomic Love generally delivers, though the potential shift to pinker tones as it wears should be noted for those specifically wanting a true red that doesn’t change undertones throughout wear.
Application Experience
The application experience with this lip stain received mixed feedback:
Positive Application Experiences
- Many users found it “super easy to apply”
- The precision tip allows for detailed application, functioning well as a lip liner
- Quick-drying formula reduces transfer and smudging issues
- Smooth application reported by several users
Negative Application Experiences
- Some users found it doesn’t go on smoothly or evenly
- A few reported a drying sensation during application
- One user described the formula as “dry yet sticky”—a contradictory sensation that was uncomfortable
- Some experienced issues with the product apparently drying out in the tube within weeks of opening
The pen-like tip receives consistent praise for its precision, making it particularly effective for outlining lips or creating defined looks. This design aspect sets it apart from traditional liquid lipsticks that use doe-foot applicators.
For best application results, users recommend:
- Exfoliating lips beforehand (some mentioned pairing it with lip peel products)
- Working quickly as it dries rapidly
- Having a steady hand for precise application
- Applying in thin layers for more control over intensity
Longevity and Wear
The most polarizing aspect of this product appears to be its longevity, with dramatically different user experiences:
Impressive Longevity Reports
- One user conducted a hand swatch test where color remained visible after 24 hours and multiple hand washings
- Several users reported the stain lasting throughout eating and drinking
- Many praised its transfer-proof qualities
- Some noted it leaves a pleasant subtle stain even after the main product has worn off
Disappointing Longevity Reports
- Some found it coming off after simply drinking coffee
- A few users returned the product due to poor staying power
- Others mentioned that while it lasted, it didn’t quite meet the “outlast” promise implied by the product name
This variation in wear time might be attributed to:
- Individual lip chemistry and pH levels
- Preparation of lips before application
- Eating habits (oily foods tend to break down lip products faster)
- Product batch inconsistencies
For maximum longevity, some users recommended layering techniques—using the stain as a base and topping with clear gloss for a more moisturizing finish while maintaining the color.
Comfort and Feel
The comfort level of this lip stain varies significantly among users:
- Some found it comfortable, noting they “don’t think it’s drying as some long-lasting lipsticks can be”
- Others described it as very drying but simultaneously sticky
- Many appreciated that it “doesn’t feel like it’s there” after drying down
- The lightweight feel was a positive for users who dislike heavy lip products
Lip stains generally tend to be more drying than creamy lipsticks by nature, as their staying power comes from their ability to set down firmly on the lips. This product seems to follow that pattern, with the added benefit of feeling relatively lightweight once set.
Several users mentioned pairing it with gloss or balm to add moisture while maintaining the stain’s longevity. This hybrid approach seems to offer the best of both worlds—the staying power of the stain with the comfort of a hydrating topper.
Versatility and Usage Scenarios
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in Atomic Love demonstrates considerable versatility in how it can be used:
- As a traditional all-over lip color – For bold, statement lips
- As a lip liner – The precision tip makes it excellent for defining lip borders
- As a base for other products – Many users layer gloss or balm over it
- For gradient or “popsicle-stained” lips – Apply to the center and blend outward
- For long-wearing occasions – Particularly useful for events where touch-ups are inconvenient
Its ability to function in multiple ways increases its value proposition, essentially offering several products in one. The precision tip particularly enhances its versatility compared to other lip stains on the market.
Comparison to Similar Products
In the context of drugstore lip stains, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain positions itself as a budget-friendly option with performance that, when at its best, rivals more expensive alternatives. Users who have tried multiple brands often noted:
- Better precision than many comparable products due to the pen tip
- Comparable longevity to mid-range brands when properly applied
- Less transfer than traditional lipsticks
- More comfortable wear than some competing long-wear formulas
- Good value for the price point when the product performs as expected
Some users specifically mentioned it outperforms other stains they’ve tried, while others felt it didn’t quite match up to higher-end options from brands like Benefit or YSL.
Value Assessment
At its price point (typically under $12), this lip stain offers:
Value Pros
- Long-lasting color (when performing optimally)
- Precise application
- Versatility in usage
- Vegan formula
- Transfer-resistant properties
Value Concerns
- Inconsistent quality control
- Potential for quick dry-out in the tube
- Variable performance
- Small product amount (0.06oz)
Most users who experienced positive results felt the product represented excellent value, while those who encountered issues understandably felt it wasn’t worth the price. The key variable appears to be product consistency and whether users received a fresh, properly functioning unit.
Standout Features
After analyzing all user feedback, several features stand out:
- Precision application – The pen-like tip consistently receives praise
- Transfer resistance – When properly set, it minimizes transfer to cups, masks, etc.
- Lightweight feel – Users appreciate that it doesn’t feel heavy on the lips
- Color impact – The vibrant red shade makes a statement
- Staining effect – Leaves a subtle tint even after the main product wears off
These features align well with what consumers typically seek in a lip stain, suggesting that when the product performs as intended, it successfully delivers on its core promises.
Potential Drawbacks
Several concerns emerged consistently across user feedback:
- Formula inconsistency – Variation between units suggests quality control issues
- Drying effect – Some users found it excessively drying
- Color shift – The potential for the red to fade to pink/magenta
- Packaging/delivery issues – Multiple reports of products arriving in questionable condition
- Short shelf life – Some units apparently dried out within weeks
- Application learning curve – The precision tip requires some skill to use effectively
These drawbacks should be weighed against the positive aspects when considering whether this product is right for a particular consumer.
Best Suited For
Based on all feedback, the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in Atomic Love seems best suited for:
- Those seeking long-wearing color without frequent reapplication
- Makeup enthusiasts who appreciate precision in application
- People who prefer lightweight lip products
- Those who enjoy layering lip products (stain + gloss/balm)
- Consumers seeking vegan beauty options
- Those who prefer a subtle stained effect rather than opaque coverage
- Makeup users on a budget seeking performance
It may be less ideal for:
- Those with chronically dry or chapped lips
- People who prefer creamy, moisturizing formulas
- Users who want guaranteed consistency
- Those seeking a true red that doesn’t shift undertones
Application Tips for Best Results
To maximize your experience with this product, consider these expert tips:
- Prep properly – Exfoliate lips and apply a thin layer of balm, blotting excess before application
- Work quickly – The fast-drying formula requires swift, confident application
- Layer strategically – Build color gradually for more control
- Consider a hybrid approach – Use as liner and blend inward, or apply all over and top with gloss
- Store properly – Keep cap tightly closed and store tip-down to prevent premature drying
- Prime lips – Some users found success using a lip primer underneath
- Set expectations – Understand that even long-wearing formulas require occasional touch-ups
The Science Behind Lip Stains
To better understand this product, it helps to know how lip stains generally work. Unlike traditional lipsticks that sit on the surface, stains use dye-based or water-based formulas that temporarily penetrate the top layer of lip skin. This explains both their longevity and their tendency to be more drying.
The COVERGIRL Outlast follows this approach, using water-soluble dyes that bond temporarily with lip tissue. The vegan formula avoids carmine (a red pigment derived from insects) commonly used in red lip products, making it suitable for those with ethical concerns about ingredient sourcing.
Final Verdict
The COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in 55 Atomic Love presents a study in contrasts. When performing at its best, it offers impressive longevity, precise application, vibrant color, and good value for money. However, inconsistencies in product quality, potential dry-out issues, and variable wear experiences make it somewhat of a gamble.
For the price point, it remains a worthwhile option for those seeking a true lip stain with a precision applicator, particularly if you’re willing to experiment with application techniques and layering. The vegan formula also adds value for ethically-minded consumers.
Rating Breakdown (out of 5)
- Packaging Design: ★★★☆☆ (Functional but quality control issues)
- Application Ease: ★★★★☆ (Precision tip but requires some skill)
- Color Payoff: ★★★★☆ (Vibrant with good pigmentation when fresh)
- Longevity: ★★★☆☆ (Highly variable, excellent for some, disappointing for others)
- Comfort: ★★★☆☆ (Lightweight but can be drying)
- Value: ★★★★☆ (Good price-to-performance ratio when product works as intended)
- Overall: ★★★½☆ (A promising product with some inconsistency issues)
Purchasing Recommendations
If you decide to try the COVERGIRL Outlast Lipstain in Atomic Love, consider:
- Purchasing from retailers with good return policies
- Checking that packaging is properly sealed upon arrival
- Testing as soon as possible to ensure the product hasn’t dried out
- Having a complementary gloss or balm on hand for layering
- Considering buying during promotions to maximize value
With realistic expectations and proper application techniques, this lip stain can be a valuable addition to your makeup collection, providing long-wearing color with a lightweight feel at an accessible price point.
Whether you’re new to lip stains or a seasoned user, the COVERGIRL Outlast in Atomic Love offers a budget-friendly way to explore the category with its unique precision applicator and classic red shade that transitions to a natural-looking stain as it wears.
Buy on Amazon: Here
