After seeing SO many mixed reviews about this mascara, I just HAD to try it myself and share my thoughts! As someone who’s tested countless mascaras over the years, I was particularly interested in this “clean” formula option from a drugstore brand. Is it worth the hype? Let’s dive in!
First Impressions
The packaging is actually pretty sleek – it has that nice, substantial feel in your hand. The tube has a modern design that looks more expensive than it actually is (always a plus!). Opening it up, the first thing you notice is that HUGE brush. It’s definitely on the bulkier side with an hourglass shape that some people might find challenging.
Application Experience
OK, so this is where things get interesting! The formula consistency seems to vary A LOT between tubes. Some users reported it being too thick and goopy right out of the package, while others found it to be the perfect consistency. In my experience, it was slightly on the wetter side when first opened.
The brush is definitely a love-it-or-hate-it situation. Its size makes it great for adding volume, but it can be TRICKY to use if you have smaller eyes or shorter lashes. I found I had to be super careful around the inner corners to avoid smudging.
The application process requires some patience – this isn’t a quick swipe-and-go product. You need to work with it a bit, especially if you’re going for multiple coats. The formula builds well when you let it dry between layers, but rush it and you’ll end up with clumps.
Performance Throughout the Day
This is where opinions really divide! Some users experienced significant flaking and smudging after just a few hours, while others report it staying put all day.
For me, it held up reasonably well for about 6-7 hours before I noticed any smudging under my eyes. It’s definitely NOT a true waterproof formula (even though it doesn’t claim to be), so don’t expect it to survive tears, rain, or intense workouts.
The “smudge-proof” claim seems to be hit or miss. Some reviewers specifically mentioned raccoon eyes developing within an hour, while others were impressed with how well it stayed in place. This inconsistency might be related to individual skin chemistry, eye shape, or even climate conditions.
Results on Lashes
When applied correctly, this mascara DOES deliver on volume! It definitely makes lashes appear fuller and more dramatic. The black pigment is rich and intense – one of the most consistently praised aspects in the reviews.
Length-wise, it’s decent but not exceptional. If you’re specifically looking for extreme length, you might want to look elsewhere or pair it with a lengthening primer.
For those with naturally short or sparse lashes, many reported that this mascara made a noticeable difference in making their lashes more visible and defined.
For Sensitive Eyes
This is one area where the Cleantopia formula shines for MANY users! Several reviewers with sensitive eyes mentioned this was one of the few mascaras they could wear comfortably. The “clean” vegan formula seems to be genuinely less irritating for those prone to reactions.
However, it’s not perfect – a handful of users still experienced irritation, redness, or watering with continued use. As with any eye product, individual sensitivity varies greatly.
Removal Process
Most users found this mascara relatively easy to remove with standard makeup removers or cleansers. It’s not as stubborn as waterproof formulas, which is a relief for those concerned about lash damage from aggressive removal techniques.
A few reviewers mentioned using micellar water or makeup wipes with good results. Some even reported that warm water and facial cleanser was sufficient, though that wasn’t my experience.
Ingredient Considerations
The “clean” and vegan claims were major selling points for many reviewers. However, a few ingredient-conscious consumers pointed out that it still contains some synthetic components like paraffin, microcystalline wax, and propylene glycol.
If you’re strictly looking for an all-natural product, this might not meet your standards. But compared to traditional mascaras, it does eliminate many common irritants and animal-derived ingredients.
Value for Money
At its price point (typically around $10-13), most reviewers felt this mascara offered good value, especially considering its “clean” formula credentials. More expensive clean beauty mascara options can run $20+ easily!
Some mentioned the product seemed to dry out faster than expected, which affects the overall value. Others found that adding a drop of saline solution helped extend its life when it started to thicken.
Who Would Love This Mascara?
Based on the reviews and my experience, this mascara would be GREAT for:
- People with sensitive eyes looking for a less irritating formula
- Those who prioritize cruelty-free and vegan beauty products
- Anyone seeking volume over length
- Makeup wearers who prefer a more dramatic lash look
- People with medium to long natural lashes
Who Should Skip It?
This might NOT be ideal for:
- Those with very small eyes (the brush is bulky!)
- People who need genuinely waterproof performance
- Anyone who prefers a more natural, subtle lash look
- Those seeking primarily length enhancement
- Makeup minimalists who want a quick, foolproof application
Tips for Best Results
If you decide to try this mascara, here are some tips gathered from successful users:
- Wipe excess product from the brush before applying – this helps reduce clumping
- Let each coat dry for a few seconds before adding another
- Use a lash comb if needed to separate any clumps
- For hooded eyes or oily lids, consider setting your undereye area with powder to prevent smudging
- If the formula gets too thick, add a drop of saline solution and mix (don’t pump the wand, which introduces air)
The Verdict
Covergirl Lash Blast Cleantopia Mascara is a solid option in the “clean” drugstore mascara category, but it’s not perfect for everyone. Its performance seems inconsistent across users, which might reflect batch variations or individual differences in application technique and eye chemistry.
For the price point, it’s worth trying if you’re curious about clean beauty options without committing to high-end prices. Just be prepared for some trial and error with application techniques to get the best results.
Overall rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5 stars)
PROS:
- Intense black pigment
- Good volumizing effect
- Generally comfortable for sensitive eyes
- Cruelty-free and vegan formula
- Affordable price point for a “clean” product
- Relatively easy to remove
CONS:
- Bulky brush that can be challenging to use
- Inconsistent smudge-proof performance
- Can clump if not applied carefully
- Not truly waterproof
- Some formula inconsistency between tubes
Have you tried this mascara? I’d love to hear about YOUR experience with it! Everyone’s lashes and preferences are different, so what worked (or didn’t work) for you might help others decide if this is their next mascara purchase.
Buy on Amazon: Here
