Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m diving DEEP into one of the most talked-about drugstore lip glosses out there – the COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss in the shade “You’re Just Jelly”. I’ve been testing this for a while now, and I’ve got THOUGHTS.
First Impressions & Packaging
The moment I got my hands on this gloss, I was immediately drawn to its cute packaging. The tube is the perfect size – not too bulky but contains enough product to last. The applicator is honestly one of the BEST parts of this product – it’s a large doe-foot that’s super soft and applies the product evenly. The pointed tip is particularly useful for reaching the corners of your lips with precision. It’s the kind of applicator that makes you wonder why all lip products don’t come with something this good!
Shade & Color Payoff
You’re Just Jelly” looks like a vibrant berry color in the tube, which had me excited. But let’s be real – this is definitely a SHEER formula. On my lips, it gives a cool berry tint that’s subtle but noticeable. If you’re looking for opaque color payoff, this isn’t it. But that’s not necessarily a bad thing!
The sheerness makes it super wearable for everyday looks. I’ve noticed many reviewers with naturally pigmented lips found it shows up less, while those with more colorless lips (like me) get a nice wash of color. It’s the kind of shade that adapts to your natural lip color in a flattering way.
Scent & Taste
OK, the scent is a MAJOR selling point! This gloss has a delicious strawberry jelly smell that’s sweet without being overwhelming. It’s nostalgic in the best way – reminds me of strawberry candy but with a more sophisticated edge.
The taste is pleasant too – not chemical-tasting like some glosses can be. Though I should note that a few users reported a perfume-like taste, so this might vary person to person.
Texture & Feel
This is where things get interesting! The texture is thick and jelly-like (living up to its name). It’s DEFINITELY not your typical thin, runny gloss. The thickness gives it that gorgeous high-shine finish that makes your lips look plump and juicy.
Despite the thickness, it’s surprisingly not very sticky! This was a pleasant surprise for me. Don’t get me wrong – it’s not completely non-sticky (that would be impossible for a gloss this shiny), but it’s nowhere near the hair-catching lip gloss nightmares from the early 2000s.
One thing to note though – some users reported a tingling or numbing sensation. This isn’t marketed as a plumping gloss, so this effect seems unintentional. I personally experienced a slight cooling sensation, but nothing uncomfortable. If you have sensitive lips, this is something to consider.
Longevity & Wear
For a gloss, the staying power is pretty impressive! I can get about 4-6 hours of wear before needing to reapply, depending on eating and drinking. The shine does last longer than many other glosses I’ve tried.
It wears off evenly and doesn’t leave that gross ring around your lips (you know what I’m talking about!). When it fades, it leaves behind a slight hint of color and my lips still feel moisturized.
Hydration & Comfort
This gloss feels genuinely hydrating on the lips, which is a huge plus. My lips tend to get dry easily, and this formula keeps them looking and feeling juicy. The moisturizing effect lasts even after the gloss has worn off.
It fills in fine lines on the lips really well, giving that smooth, plump appearance that we all want from a good gloss. It’s comfortable enough for all-day wear, which isn’t always the case with glossy formulas.
Value for Money
At its price point (usually under $10), this gloss offers AMAZING value. The quality rivals much more expensive brands – several reviewers specifically mentioned that they prefer this over high-end options like Dior lip oils!
The tube contains a generous amount of product, and since you don’t need much for each application, it lasts quite a while. I’ve been using mine regularly for months and still have plenty left.
Shade Range & Versatility
While I’m focusing on “You’re Just Jelly,” it’s worth noting that the Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss line comes in several shades. Many people seem to be collecting multiple colors because they love the formula so much.
“You’re Just Jelly” specifically works well both on its own for a natural look or layered over lipstick for more dimension. I’ve tried it over a mauve lip liner (similar to the NYX Espresso that one reviewer mentioned), and it creates a gorgeous deeper berry look that’s perfect for evenings out.
Practical Considerations
A few practical things worth mentioning:
- Like all glosses, it can catch hair on windy days. That’s just the nature of glossy products!
- The thick jelly texture means it doesn’t spread quite as easily as thinner glosses, but the large applicator compensates for this.
- The tube design has some edges that prevent taking too much product, which is a thoughtful touch.
Potential Concerns
I need to address the reports of tingling/burning from some users. While most people (including me) find this gloss comfortable, there seems to be an ingredient that causes sensitivity for some. If you have very sensitive skin or known allergies to cosmetic ingredients, you might want to patch test first.
A very small number of reviewers also mentioned receiving products with broken seals or wrong shades through online ordering. This seems to be an isolated shipping/handling issue rather than a problem with the product itself.
Who Would Love This?
This gloss would be PERFECT for:
- People who want that trendy “jelly lips” look without spending a fortune
- Anyone who prefers sheer, buildable color rather than opaque coverage
- Those who hate sticky glosses but still want high shine
- Fragrance lovers (that strawberry scent is addictive!)
- Makeup beginners and teens (several parents mentioned buying these for their teenagers who loved them)
- Anyone looking for a moisturizing gloss option
Who Might Want to Skip?
This might not be the best choice if:
- You prefer completely colorless or highly pigmented lip products
- You have very sensitive lips that react to fragranced products
- You absolutely cannot stand any level of stickiness (though this is less sticky than most glosses)
- You dislike sweet scents in your makeup
Final Thoughts
After weeks of testing, I can confidently say that the COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss in “You’re Just Jelly” has earned a permanent spot in my makeup collection. The combination of beautiful shine, comfortable wear, hydrating properties, and delicious scent makes it a standout drugstore find.
Is it perfect? No product is! The sheerness might disappoint those wanting more color impact, and the tingling sensation isn’t for everyone. But considering the price point and overall quality, it’s an exceptional value.
For me, this has become a daily staple – I keep it in my purse for touch-ups throughout the day. It gives me that “my lips but better” look with a gorgeous glossy finish that makes me feel put together without trying too hard.
If you’re on the fence about trying it, I say GO FOR IT! At this price point, it’s a low-risk purchase with potentially high rewards. And based on the reviews, I’m not alone in my love for this little tube of glossy goodness!
Have you tried the COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss? I’d love to hear your thoughts and which shade is your favorite!
Buy on Amazon: Here
